The impacts of the VAT implementation are discussed in the study and the research study is revolving
around top measure the impacts of the VAT implantation in Saudi Arabia. In the first
section of the research study the background of the VAT has explained in
extensive way along with objectives and research question and this part
provides the significance of the study. The literature review discuss the views
of the previous authors on the implementation of the VAT in Saud Arabia.The primary
data has been used to conducting this research study which based upon the self-designed questionnaire.
The data is collected from the 80 respondents for analyzing the implementation
of the VAT in Saudi Arabia. To perform the correlation and regression analysis
the SPSS has been used in this study. All of the test shows that by implementing
the VAT the performance of the companies of the Saudi Arabia will be enhance as
well.
Literature Review of the VAT (Value Added Tax)
The
VAT has three principal types that are
categorized according to their treatment of capital equipment’s destructibility, i.e. gross product (Value Added Tax),
consumption (Value Added Tax), and income (Value Added Tax) (Schenk and Oldman,
2007). A gross product VAT, according to this typology, contains the largest base of tax. Only a limited
deductions choice is permitted by this, such as raw materials cost. Therefore,
when it comes to capital investments purchase, it causes tax expenses. Somehow,
additional deductions are permitted by an income value added tax (VAT).
Furthermore, depreciation is the expense that we deduct on capital goods as a
purchase of net investment (depreciation subtracted by gross investment). So, finally, the total capital investment deduction
is allowed by a consumption VAT, with business purchases being excluded or
deducted.
Despite an immense value-added tax structures range and besides methods of
implementation, that were investigated
later, the consensus is facing some
problems and critical issues. At the
first value-added tax is considered as a tax that relates to the consumer spending on services and several kinds of goods, somehow,
consumption is the final base of tax. A consumption valued added tax (VAT) is
the reason because of which feeis credited
on the purchases of capital goods. Somehow, it does not change prices for products that are
based on the transactions of purchase or sales between manufacturers,
and subsequently, have characteristics related to production efficiency maintenance
that is beneficial. Also, as it is levied at given each level of production,
whereas ensuring guarantee that tax will only affect consumption, it is
essential to do not break the VAT chain
while allocating tax on inputs. (Ebrill et al., 2002).
VAT liability can be calculated through the use of three methods:
credit-invoice method, addition method and subtraction method (Schenk and
Oldman, 2007). Nevertheless, it is universally (Excluding Japan) considered
that the most efficient manner of calculating
VAT liability is the credit-invoice
method (Owens, 2005). The main of this discussion is not to comment on the
performance of these different calculation methods although later in the
chapter such aspects are discussed briefly. Though, the principal reason here regarding this issue is that liability
calculation method known as the credit-invoice
method is attributed as most efficient on
the basis that it links with the tax credit on input account of buyers to the
remitted tax. Here tax is paid by the
input providers (who sell out the input to the manufactures), false
undervaluation regarding average sales is
discouraged. Somehow, it can also be said
that the VAT tax can be avoided by the credit-invoice method as it is designed to
provide accuracy and original
interpretations (Owens, 2005). As a result of this compliance get enhance. Thus, a research study conducted
on this method by Grinberg in 2009 claims that the
invoice requires the key factors and aspects that generate the difference
between the subtraction-method and credit-invoice method.
The study conducted was made by
Rao (2004) to examine that what kind of loss or gain is held by the states in
terms of having uniform design features, value added tax, tax base extension to
transactions other than 1st point sale, inputs tax credit, and for
international exports & interstate trade, holding zero rating. She also
said that the tax system’s cascading
problem would not be resolved just by services exclusion from the base. The
base of significant sales tax was on the
output of the manufacturing sector, so
VAT’s estimated impact was just there to get an idea
about the manufacturing industry, which is
registered (Rao, 2004).
The
author made the further argument
that VAT’s structure & rates homogeneity was remarkable in terms of reducing the tax competition scope among st
states, as well as for economic activity, the tax system neutrality was also
important. But rates homogeneity cannot make sure that all nations will maintain the current revenue level. With the
variation in tax GSDP ratio, the indication was
made that interests of different countries were
different from each other, so in the later
part, VAT’s structure & rates may be changed
by the rules. The author concluded on assumptions that few countries expected not to gain anything from
VAT, but few countries consistently
looked to learn much from it (Rao, 2004).
It was pointed out by Bezborah
and Singh (2005) that structure of sales tax various weaknesses such as loss of
revenue, pyramiding effects, cascading nature, rates multiplicity, as well as
tax rates lacking in uniformity. It was also pointed out by them that what are
the necessary elements of the excellent
structure of sales tax, like VAT was one of the best alternatives as compared
to sales tax. But there are some black
spots hold by VAT as well. Moreover, the VAT implementation also comes with
many problems in India. Further points discussed by them included refund
mechanism, threshold limit, taxes unification, CST removal, rates uniformity etc., and it was
also concluded that VAT implementation should not see more delay in
India.
The interest of authors Malone
and Acevedo is revolving around the potential long term and short term impact,
which can be made by VAT rate changes, and inflation rate’s effect on the
revenue of VAT. This discussion is based
on the fact that what monetary policy, as well as VAT tax rate direction,
should be set in Mexico. This model is based on induced as well as direct economic
effects made by changes in tax rates without making any restrictions on how economic outcomes and policy variables
are going to be interrelated. In these countries, the role of VAT rate, revenue
of VAT, inflation as well as government’s indigent is more crucial because
there is significant integration between
economic and political structures. The case of Mexico is unique to discuss
because it has allowed that how the connection
between some of these variables can be analysed
with regards to increasing fiscal as well as economic reforms (Maloney and
Azevedo, 1995).
Oldman and Woods (1983) have
observed that taxable transactions failure of reporting should be discouraged
by the VAT system as per theory. For instance, if a consumer and a vendor, both
get together for conspiring the lower price with the help of VAT, and sale is not reported, then reduced rates will not be applied by the vendor until the consumer is agreed to communicate
his/her actual transaction. If a colluding consumer’s client decides that his/her actual purchase will be notified with the colluding
consumer so that VAT credit can be obtained,
so the colluding consumer should provide an
invoice. This is how it works, and then VAT amount must be paid by the
colluding vendor as per requirements (Oldman and Woods, 1983).A point of view
is supported by most researchers, which states that investment and savings are
promoted by VAT because rather income consumption, the consumption of taxes is made (Charlet and Owens, 2010).
In addition to that as per
accumulated data of researchers of OECD, it was
indicated that VAT had shown more
values of pro-growth as compared to corporate or income tax being applied (Johansson, Heady, Arnold, Brys
and Vartia, 2008). But VAT has also shown neutral characteristics in terms of
individual taxpayers that whether they spend or save money when they interact
with consumer products. However, it is essential
to understand that consumption tax is only for current consumptions, and it is not levied on saving in a certain period, so as compared to other taxation
forms, it is considered more efficient
economically (GAO, 2008).
Reckon (2009) has utilised the numbers of EU economies structural
indicators so that VAT gaps determinants can be
obtained through tests of econometric type. There was a strong relationship between the found variable
and VAT gap size, and it is connected
with the corruption’s perceived level in the country, where lower VAT gap has
its association with lower rate of fraud.
However, it was surprising to know claims were
made by the report that there was no critical
relationship was found between the VAT burden and VAT gap, when measurements
errors are considered in the contingent liability’s estimation with the use
of instrumental variables of regression. As compared to that other studies and
their results have come up with quite contrasting results consistently. It can be presumed that these difference in different countries may be accounted for by the macroeconomic
conditions, which are different from each other.
According to
Martin Harrison, (2010), the taxation issues is by no means of a new one and it
is struggling for introducing the indirect or direct taxation in the previous
dates as in the 1980s. At that time
various tax policies are implemented in Kuwait
and Saudi Arabia, in 1955 the corporate tax was
introduced in Kuwait, and until
1975 the Saudi Arabia implanted the income tax for
foreigners. Saudi Arabia suspended this
tax in 1975 due to the oil revenue’s scale. They had required hiring the
large numbers of the foreigner for developing the infrastructure of their
economy. The income tax had reintroduced by the government of Saudi Arabia in 1988 on foreign workers for
balancing the decreasing in oil revenues. The charge
had been potentially allowed for the replacement of the foreigners who did not
want to stay in Saudi Arabia. In Saudi Arabia,
the opposition for the income tax was most striking from the leaders of the
local business and expatriate and these all issues are also about to the local
socio-political culture. It is noted by
the report of 1985 which is conducted on
Bahraini economy the person, and
corporate tax is charging by the
government. All the people of the area
are regarded as dangerously socialist for this idea by not Arabian(Harrison, 2010).
Kaya (2016)
stated, for measuring the distortion wealth distribution the various level
of the taxation is commonly used while the Transparency International Corruption Index can
measure the level of the corruption. For the four measurements, the world average has been achieved by various countries particular
for most of the indicator the high
ranking is making by the Qatar and UAE.
For the protection of property rights
Saudi Arabia, Oman and Kuwait, were mostly
on the world average. This model is based
on induced as well as direct economic effects made by changes in tax rates
without making any restrictions on how
economic outcomes and policy variables are going to be interrelated. For
the institutional quality related to the economy,
the countries have achieved good performance. The Gulf countries are involved in facing the increase in the presses
for the spending of the government of the
Finance which is also considered as the
crucial domestic stability for all of these states. Through the direct prediction of the property
as well as excessive tax the private property can be grabbed by the entire government. By following the
distortionary taxation policies,
inefficient or Disruptive wealth distribution can be the tough obstacle for the long term growth which is discouraged by the private investment,and it becomes the cause of outflows of the
capital(Kaya, 2016).
In the early 21st
century to introducing the VAT has become the big challenge for the local
market of the Saudi Arabia. To prepare for these changes all of the
organization are required less than the four months. It provides the warning to
those organization which have not started they must be implements it
immediately to measure the impacts of the tax on their entire operation of the organization.
It also includes the commercial and pricing strategy which have impact on their
financial and IT reporting system. The extensive system of the VAT
implementation has been experienced by the KSA, UAE and several other countries
which are active presence in the region(Niblock, 2004).
Now a days the
Arabia countries are seeking to develop the modern tax system collectively and
individually. These all of the countries are dependent on the oil and
generating the diversified and broad revenue which is based upon the stable
revenue stream. The system of the VAT is recommended by the authorities to
calculating the tax in Saudi Arabia. It is highly recommended that the GCC must
be agree on the destination which is based upon the VAT by using the common
rate 3-5 percent. The credit invoice method must be used for the calculation
the tax. In the UAE the common legal framework has been developed along with
the lines which are not established earlier(Ahmad, 2010).
For discussing
the implementation of VAT in Saudi Arabia it discusses the structure of the
Saudi economy is necessary because it describes the need of the implementation
of the VAT in SaudiArabia. The economic situation of the Saudi Arabia is considered
as the quite unique because the sustainability is eroded by it percapita GDP
since 1981. The comparable per capita GDP has been founded in the Saudi Arabia
which is figured out as $15600 and this GDP has risen about the $38000. This
following healthy economy has been recorded in the 2000 because of the oil
prices and high oil production(Chemingui, 2004).
The main of this discussion is
not to comment on the performance of these different calculation methods
although later in the chapter such aspects are discussed briefly. At the first value-added tax is considered as a tax that relates to the consumer spending on services and several kinds of goods, somehow,
consumption is the final base of tax. The VAT
tax can be avoided by the credit-invoice
method as it is designed to provide accuracy and original interpretations. It was also pointed out by them that what
are the necessary elements of the excellent
structure of sales tax, like VAT was one of the best alternatives as compared
to sales tax.VAT’s structure & rates homogeneity was remarkable in terms of reducing the tax
competition scope amongst states, as well as for economic activity, the tax
system neutrality was also important (Thacker, 2008).
References of the VAT (Value Added Tax)
Ahmad, E. &. (2010). Fiscal reforms in the
middle east: VAT in the Gulf Cooperation Council. . Edward Elgar
Publishing.
Chemingui, M. A. (2004). Tax policy reform in Saudi
Arabia: A general equilibrium analysis. In proceeding of the Economic Research
Forum’s. 11th annual conference.
Harrison, M. (2010). Taxation and the GCC States.
gulf1bank.
Kaya, A. &.-T. (2016). Inclusive Economic
Institutions in the Gulf Cooperation Council States: Current Status and
Theoretical Implications. Review of Middle East Economics and Finance, ,
12(2).
Niblock, T. (2004). Saudi Arabia: Power, legitimacy
and survival. . Routledge.
Thacker, S. (2008). Taxation in the Gulf:
Introduction of a Value Added Tax. . Mich. St. U. Coll. LJ Int'l L., 17,
721.