If you ever ask
any person in the workplace that if problem-solving and decision making is
there activities part of workplace then answer will be definitely ‘Yes!’ But
the important thing is learning how to solve the particular problem as it is
the critical element of work and it should be done effectively. Usually,
specifically in the teaching field, teachers tend to do multiple things when
faced the problem at the workplace such as they usually don’t get uncomfortable
or afraid and try to confront the problem; teacher always know it that they
must come up with the satisfactory answer and answer must be right, and they
look to blame someone else. A teacher faces multiple issues and problems at the
working place an important thing to solve those issues and problems in an
effective way of problem-solving and decision making. The process of
problem-solving includes decisions followed by ideas, discussion, and
activities that occur from a problematic situation’s first consideration of the
goal.
Intellectual
and developmental disability of the students is a real problem Definition
Intellectual
and developmental disability of the students is a real problem faced by a
teacher in the classroom. Analyzing the problem is really necessary for
problem-solving and decision making. The relationship between teacher and
students is important at this stage of problem-solving and decision making. ‘What’
is the first step to explore the aspects of a problem, however, the focus of
this stage is on the ‘why’. A teacher, at this step, can discuss with students
the potential cause of their intellectual and developmental disabilities, but
it is important not highlight directly that students are intellectually and
developmentally disabled to avoid the discouraging behavior among students. The
teacher may also want to start the setting out the timeline or agenda for the
problem-solving process faced due to intellectual and developmental disable
students, looking forward to other problem solving and decision to make stages.
Moreover, in
order to analyze the problem completely, the teacher can discuss the common
variables of problems. For example: if student has problem with the accent of
teacher and he or she is unable to understand the teacher language while
teacher is delivering lecture; what the reason that student feels uncomfortable
to raise question during lectures; and despite the good participation in class
and good attendance why student is not performing well in class assessments and
tests. Once the teacher has analyzed the problem, the teacher can pose the
problem question that will guide him or her as the possible solutions can be
generated through it.
“How critical
thinking approach can be developed among students with intellectual and
developmental disabilities?” can be the problem question in such situation. It
can be seen that the problem statement is less complex than the problem question
since the teacher has moved on the discussion with students of the problem that
more in-depth.
Data Collection During this stage of
problem-solving and decision making
During this
stage of problem-solving and decision making, a teacher can generate the
possible solution that has analyzed above. At this stage, solutions to the
problem can be clarified and proposed only, not evaluated. The question at this
stage should be what a teacher can do to address the identified and analyzed
problem, not what a teacher should do to address the problem. It is perfectly
okay for the teacher to ask questions to students to generate ideas by asking
questions like “How would you like to be treated in the classroom by your
instructor?’” or “How can a teacher make you feel comfortable in the
classroom?” The need to go back to the previous stage might be revealed by the
discussion at this stage to fully analyze or define the problem. Since most of
the problems are multifaceted, it is essential for the teacher to generate
solutions of each problems’ part separately, so that multiple solutions could
be made sure for each part of the problem (OECD, 2012).
Furthermore, stopping
the process of solution-generating prematurely may lead to more thinking. The
teacher would need to generate the solutions to each aspect of the problem question
that is previously posted. Possible solutions to the problem question could be transparent
communication between teacher and student, break down silos, open-minded
students in the classroom, and a solid foundational strategy (Raising Children Network, 2018).
Possible Causes
During this stage, based on the completeness, worth, and credibility,
During this
stage, based on the completeness, worth, and credibility, the solutions to the
problem can be evaluated critically. After narrowing down the potential
solutions to the problem based on more understandable differences in merit and
relevance, a teacher should analyze each and every solution based on the
potential impacts of the particular solution, the negative impacts should be
considered especially. A teacher who is required to report the decision
rationale to some higher authority of the institution, as the decisions of the
teacher may be subject to the scrutiny of the institution as well as students, would
be wise to generate the criteria's set list for evaluating each and every
solution.
In the
addition, a teacher can evaluate the possible solutions based on how particular
solution will fit with the skills and abilities of the students. In order to do
so, the teacher may ask, "Does the proposed solution live up to the actual
and potential mission or purpose of problem-solving and decision making?” and “Is
it possible to implement the solution actually with the current connections and
resources available for both teacher and students?” and listening skills and effective critical
thinking within own self as well as students.
The possible
options here in order to resolve the problems are the prioritization of the
problems that what problem need to be resolved first, as there are several
related problems, therefore, there is need to focus on the
"important" and "urgent" problems so that issues or
important problems. There are problems that may deserve more attention
therefore, it is the second option, as there is need to focus on the role in
the problem that also helps to greatly influence the role; other than blaming (Managementhelp.org, 2018).
Root Causes decision
making is the larger process's part of problem-solving
Moreover, decision
making is the larger process's part of problem-solving that plays a significant
and prominent role at this stage of problem-solving and decision making. While
there are so many similar models that so are fair for problem-solving, the
technique of decision making is also varied that a teacher can use at this
stage according to the convenience. For instance, to narrow down the proposed
solutions’ list, the teacher may decide by the possible impacts of each
solution, by giving weight to each advantage and disadvantage, or by discussing
those solutions with colleagues until the consensus is reached. Once the teacher
has reached the final decision, the respective institution can be informed to
confirm its agreement. A solid foundational strategy is most suitable for the
students with intellectual and developmental disabilities and can be adapted to
develop a critical thinking approach among such students.
Four-Step RCA
can be a helpful technique in this way, as there is the of the management or
teacher to follow all four steps that are involved in the RCA, example, first
is to focus on the team, the second is to find out the root cause and then
there is the need to fix the root cause and in last finalize solutions.
Teachers for the effective management can get help from the RCA.
Solution “a
solid foundational strategy”
Some advanced
planning is required to implement the decided solution i.e. ‘a solid
foundational strategy’, and the planning should not be rushed unless the
teacher is operating under delays or some strict time restraints as it may lead
to harm and hurdles. Although it is possible to implement some solutions
immediately, other solutions may take a few days, or months, even years. As it
was noted in above discussion that it could be beneficial for the teacher to
poll the respective and concerned entities as to their individual opinion of
it. It is clear that a teacher can take such students along with the brilliant
students by proper decision making; students having intellectual and
developmental disabilities will be able to meet the expectations of their
instructor if the explicit instructions are given to them by the teacher.
SMART
goals to Solving Problems and Making Decisions
SMART goals
|
Implementation by teachers
|
Specific
|
there can be a more specific goal in the school
|
Measurable
|
The
goal then need to broke down into smaller parts
|
Attainable
|
It is analyzed that whether the goal is even
possible to achieve or not.
|
Relevant
|
It
is focused that which component is important.
|
Time-Bound
|
Every goal have a deadline or there is the
specific time frame.
|
Plan
of Solving Problems and Making Decisions
Although the
metacognitive, as well as cognitive problem solving's demands and the process
of decision making, have resulted in the assumption that is held generally that
most of the students having intellectual and developmental disabilities find it
difficult to understand the lectures properly and develop critical thinking
analysis approach. Such students can grow in their educational and social life
if teacher cooperates with them and vice versa. There are numerous strategies
and validated approaches to developing critical thinking among students with intellectual
and developmental disabilities within both cognitive and social framework. Though,
in all contexts, problem-solving and decision making is itself a skill that
needs to be developed among such students so that they could be able to address
the situations and contexts which are both anchored and meaningful in reality.
In order to
monitor the program, the best strategy that is required for the implementation
of the decisions in an effective way is the communication; communication helps
the teacher and management in order to understand that what needs to achieve
and what should be foremost. There will be clearly understood of the goals in
this way, and better strategies can be there.
Follow-up for Solving
Problems and Making Decisions
The pilot test can also be conducted in
order to observe the solution’s effectiveness and what will be the reaction of
people. Before implementation of the solution, the teacher also need to
determine that when and how he or she would assess the solution’s effectiveness
by asking questions like, "How teacher will know if the solution has
worked or is working or not?" Since the assessment of the solution will
vary based on either the teacher is disbanded or not with students, he or she
needs to consider the multiple questions like, "If the solution fails, how
to take the responsibility of this failure"? And "If the solution
fails, some other solution could be applied or not?”
References of
Solving Problems and Making Decisions
Hicks, T. (2018). Seven Steps for Effective Problem
Solving in the Workplace. Retrieved from
https://www.mediate.com/articles/thicks.cfm
Llopis, G. (2013, November 4). The 4 Most Effective Ways
Leaders Solve Problems. Retrieved from
https://www.forbes.com/sites/glennllopis/2013/11/04/the-4-most-effective-ways-leaders-solve-problems/#7a4364f24f97
Managementhelp.org. (2018). Problem Solving and Decision
Making. Retrieved from
https://managementhelp.org/personalproductivity/problem-solving.htm
OECD. (2012). Equity and Quality in Education Supporting
Disadvantaged Students and Schools: Supporting Disadvantaged Students and
Schools. OECD Publishing.
Raising Children Network. (2018). Problem-solving
strategies for parents and teachers. Retrieved from
http://raisingchildren.net.au/articles/problem-solving_strategies_for_parents_and_teacher.html/context/591
Valerio, N. (2017, March 21). APPLIED PROBLEM SOLVING IN
WORKPLACE. Retrieved from
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/applied-problem-solving-workplace-nicole-valerio
Wehmeyer, M. L. (2007). Promoting Self-Determination in
Students with Developmental Disabilities. Guilford Publications.