In that video, there is one ethical issue discussed between the project
director and the project manager. Actually, project director want to complete
the contract early while ignoring the security problems. In this project, encryption
was considered essential to prevent security problems such as data breaches and
external attacks on internal information system. Somehow CEO and directors are
interested to complete this project as early as possible to get more projects
from the contractor. Therefore, they forced project manager to complete this
project without working on encryption that can cause problems in future.
Considering the risk factor project manager is not ready to complete this
project without encryption. Other than security risk, another reason preventing
project manager is that CEO and other directors are not ready to take
responsibility. Therefore in case of security issues in future, he will have to
face liability.
The ethical issue I have
identified in this video is that the project director enforcing the project manager
to deliver in-complete and security risk-based services to their customer while
project director will not face negative consequences. For that, there will risk of hacking.. This is one of the biggest ethical issues that has been discussed in that video.
Ethical issues from the perspective of
the Australian Computer Society Code of Professional Conduct of the ethical
issue
The ethical issues from
Australian Computer Society Code of Professional Conduct are presented below:
To uphold and advance the honor,
dignity and effectiveness of the profession of information technology and in
keeping with high standards of competence and ethical conduct. According to
this company is responsible to deliver high standard work rather than launching
risk-based program.
Priorities
Priories are also not according
to the code of professional conduct as priority is to earn financial advantages
even through wrong ways (that is of course unethical)
Competence
Competence is also important in
the accordance to the Australian Computer Society code of conduct that is
ignored in this case.
Honesty
According to the Australian
Computer Society, there is a discussion
about the new technologies and software through which the company is able to
launch new programs if your company wants
to introduce new programs in their organization so that they have to work hard
and they have to launch their products/ programs with full honesty. If the company uses shortcuts, for the project, so it
is a completely unethical way to launch a computer program.
Recommendation of the
ethical issue
I have some recommendation after
the analysis of the ethical issue that has been discussed. I can say that the
company has to launch a program according to the Australia Computer Society. In
that act, there is proper mentioning
about the professional development of how
the company is able to make a computer program
by following this act in a proper way.
This is because if the company
follow such an act in a proper way so that there will be no ethical
issue in the company in any case. In that
video, the project director discusses the issue with the project manager
and introduce a new program with the help of encryption. In my opinion, a
project manager is a sensible
person, and he knows everything about the consequences. If the company wanted to
introduce any new program so they must have to follow Australian computer
Society code of professional development that
would ensure the company that they are
moving in the right direction for the change.
This issue is related to Information
and communication technology because the company wants to encrypt the program and launch it for the company before
the time.
In the ACS section 4.5, there is proper information about professional development in the computer
organization. But in the video, they are
not working according to section 4.5.
There is only one solution for
solving the ethical problem in the organization, and that is they must have to follow the Code of the conduct of this issue so that the company is
able to implement any program with perfection if
the company is following the shortcuts, so
it is completely against the ICT professional that are using Australian
Computer Society code of ethics.
Furthermore, in this situation
best solution for project manager is to resolve the matter by discussing the
matter with top level management in a face to face meeting. In case they reject
his suggestions then he can blow the whistle. Project manager can also visit HR
manager to get solution of his problem or he can just leave this job to safe is
good reputation and professional career. Or in clear words we can say that, he
should not accept project director’s or CEO’s offer regarding incentives as in
this situation taking monetary benefits is also un-ethical.
Video link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JjLK_JjAu48
In
that video, there is a proper recommendation about the project manager
what he has to do for the ethical issue in the organization. In this scenario, the project manager discusses the problem with the project manager.
There are three possible endings
of the video, and I have chosen the third
ending in which the project manager follows up the team order through
discussion. In that video, they showed how the project manager listens the discussion of the project director in detail and agree
with it. The project director said that it is totally unethical if we do that
project in that way because if we get hacked such
important information of the customer will be missed used by the others and
that not a good idea. The project manager completely agrees with the point of view of the project director (Dittrich, Bailey, & Dietrich, 2011).
Recommendation about the ethical solution
I have chosen that scenario for
the ending of the video. In my opinion,
this solution is one of the best solutions
for solving this ethical issue in the organization. This is because the first
solution was related to the project director pressure. That he will get under
pressure from the words of the project manager.
This solution means that the
personality of the project director is
extremely weak. The next solution is to
follow up the recommendation of the project manager. This solution is also not
suitable because it is going completely against ACS. This is the reason why the
last solution is perfect because in that the project director gave
recommendation according to the ACS and solved the issue in a proper way.
References of the ethical
issue
Dittrich, D., Bailey, M., & Dietrich, S. (2011).
Building an active computer security ethics community. IEEE Security & Privacy , 32-40.
McDermid,
D. (2015). Ethics in ICT: An
Australian Perspective. Pearson Higher Education AU.