Overall, the main competitor for Chester was Digby. Digby was the only company that was close to
Chester in cumulative profit all game, and was the only other team that ended
up having a cumulative profit at the end of the simulation. Overall, Digby had some very similar
strengths to Chester, maintaining similar contribution margins, and having a
better average market share than Chester did.
They also did a great job of adding another sensor to the High End
market in order to secure a bigger market share there, and did it while adding
atomization in order to make sure that they would still be making a profit with
their units sold. Digby’s strategy
actually made it so in the later rounds they were losing less money than
Chester was, and even managed to make a profit in one of the rounds before
8. The main weakness Digby had was at
the start, taking out several significant emergency loans in the first few
rounds, this can most likely be attributed to the fact that they expected to
sell more in those rounds than they actually due to the several millions of
dollars they had in inventory on their balance sheets at the end of those
rounds. They did fix the problem later
into the simulation and stopped taking emergency loans, so they figured it out
eventually. They were pretty even with
everyone in all the markets, and were the main competition for Chester in all
the markets Chester was strong in.
Although Digby was the main
competitor overall, the way Capsim was structured made it so that each market
would create different main competitors.
This means that Digby was not the biggest competitor for Chester in
every single market, but rather the competitor depended on which market is
being discussed.
Company’s Future
Chester’s
future as of the last round would not be great, most of the capacity was sold
off so they would not be able to produce the amount of sensors demanded. Therefore, the company would most likely be
unable to continue. On the other hand,
even if the company had continued as normal, Chester was losing money every
year instead of making it. Unless it was
some sort of government needed company, Chester would most likely go bankrupt
soon. The only thing that could save
Chester would be that since they lost the least amount of money in round 8, the
other companies would most likely go bankrupt first allowing
Chester to sell more products with less competition. This would drive prices up
which might cause Chester to actually make a profit.
What we Learned
Our team learned a few things during
this simulation, the first being that just because you make good business
decisions, it does not guarantee that the company will make a profit. We also learned how important it is to pay
attention to one’s competition that way you are not too surprised about what
happens in the future. There are also
several strategies that companies can use, and each can be successful depending
on the market they are implemented into.
As for how the departments interact,
each business decision made had an impact on the other departments. For instance if we wanted to research our
sensors, we had to finance it, and this research would affect how much we would
be able to sell, which affects how much we should produce of each sensor. How much we would be able to sell was also
effected by its price, sales and promotion budget, and capacity, all of which
affected how much money the company would need from its financial
department. It was extremely important
that after decisions were made to go back and double check that all the numbers
were right in other departments because, as we learned, if we input one number
wrong it could have a significant negative effect on the company.