It is important to understand that Islamic
Financial system is quite different from the Western financial system. The
standard financial system around the world is based on various principles revolving
around interest, whereas Islamic financial system is against the interest, and
the system is developed without keeping any interests in the contracts and
other financial activities. That’s why Islamic financial system has developed
Islamic financial contracts on the principles of Isla, guided by Quran and the Prophet
Muhammad (PBUH). These contracts are off various kinds with different names
like Murabaha, Mudarabah, Musharakah etc. The legal issues in murabaha system
complies with the civil law; because there can be issues in the contractual
laws. Civil laws are not favorable to the murabaha system because there are not
benefits to the economy. There are issues related to the credit risks; as there
are issues in the defaulting in the debt paying.
From the profit-sharing modes; it is analyzed
that credit risks can result in non-payment of the shares. Other issues of
murabaha system can be related to the market risk, assets price risks,
liquidity, operation and legal risk. However, the risks that are involved in
Mudarabah system, can be related to the prohibition of financial interest; they
could be in different forms. Other risks are related to the profit/loss that
may be implies with the shariah rules. There could be avoidance of the
irrational use of the capital funds. These contracts offer business and other
partnerships between two or more than two parties and these contracts are
followed as per the principles of Sharia laws. But the issue with all of these
contracts is that they have various relevant legal and Sharia issues to be
resolved. As mentioned above that interest or Riba is prohibited in the Islam,
but legally it is hard for these contracts to remain distant from Riba or
Interest. The overall financial system even in an Islamic country is also based
on the western banking models, where interest is the main aspect in all
financial activities. It means that Islamic fiancé has to deal with these legal
issues and make things compliant to Islamic Sharia laws (Zandi 2012)
The
legal issues related with Murabaha contract are more related to the financial
risks that one party may have to bear. This contract is more like an
installment based system, and it is also one of the mostly used contracts in
Islamic finance. The Murabaha contract comes with liquidity risks, where the
lender may face issues in getting timely payment for the assets. There can be a
situation, where a bank sends a commodity to the client, but client does not
accept it due to any reasons. In this situation, the bank will remain in the
risk until they find another client for the same commodity so that they can get
some returns on their commodity. The other most important risk associated with
Murabaha contract is credit risk. It means that there can be a situation, where
a client may not be able to pay installments for the commodity lend from the
bank. When due amount is not paid in a given time period, it enhances the level
of liquidity risks for the bank. So, these are few legal issues and risks
associated with the Murabaha contract of Islamic finance (Almohana 2017)
References of There are Shariah and legal issues in some Islamic Financial Contrast i.e Murabahah and Mudarabah contrasts. Analyze these legal issues by choosing any contract of your choice and explain it.
Almohana, Mohammad. 2017. Legal Risks Faced By
Investors in Dealing with Islamic Financial Transactions and Mitigation
Actions/Strategies to Keep Off Legal Risks: The Case of Murabaha Transaction.
University of Exeter.
Zandi, Gholamreza. 2012. "Some issues on
Murabahah practices in Iran and Malaysian Islamic banks." African
journal of business management 6 (24).