A
research study conducted by the HO, LEE, CHAN,
NG, and CHOY in 2010 elaborate that the power elites in the society as tight
knits business state network is a challenge for the democracy in the country.
Basically, the main focus of the research is on the power elite system in Hong
Kong (HO, LEE, CHAN, NG, & CHOY, 2010). therefore to
collect information about the topic through analyzing and measuring the results
through the software and a network analytical program known as UCINET 6 was
used in the research for the purpose of analysis. In the research, information
is also extracted from the secondary research papers and primary research
papers therefore while presenting and discussing the results limitations and
the bias-related information is also given to enable the readers to understand
the reliability and validity of the research.
however, the research is a great
contribution to study the ruling elite in hong kong as in this research
researchers have collected and gathered all important and most concerning
information in a single article. thus rather than reviewing a number of
articles one can get a better understanding of the power elite in Hong Kong by
reviewing this research article. in the article, researchers discussed the elections
process in the hong kong and the policies of the SCNPC towards electing the CE.
in accordance to research more than 7 million people of hong kong are not using
their right in electing the leaders (Ortmann, 2009).
During the colonial period (started from
1841 to 1997) Hong Kong was under the control of Britain designated government.
after that first CE in 1997 was a businessman from the power elite group. even
after 1997 Hong Kong was reverted to China and new rulers were elected on the
basis of democracy but still, democracy is not very common in Hong Kong. even
in democratic government structure ruling power is from the business sector and
other groups of power elites.
In Hong Kong, the power elite
exists even in the present age. a research conducted in 1990 concluded that
power elites in the hong kong are taking advantage of their business success,
family terms with rich people and large corporations behind them. ExCo and
LegCo are the governing power that contains the elites from the
business-government sector. in the research, HO and his team have studied four
groups tertiary education, government, corporate, and welfare that all prove
that the power elite is common in Hong Kong.
above all, there are some
questions that are not discussed in the research that should be discussed in
detail. for instance, the research should clearly discuss whether the culture
and social values are the motivating or demotivating factors for the power
elites. While research should also discuss the impact of the power elite in the
society. these questions should be given importance in the research only then
we can find out the reasons and level of intensity (for the issue) that will
support us to overcome the issue. in my knowledge that is extracted from the
course material and reviewing research studies, the researchers should pay more
focus on the public opinion about the power elites and the efforts of the
governments towards the power elites control. By taking the middle-class
employees and businessman as the research samples we can get their responses
and views about the power elites in Hong Kong.
References of Analysis of the assigned empirical article on HK
Clegg, S. R., Courpasson, D., & Phillips, N.
(2006). Power and Organizations. SAGE Publications Ltd. Retrieved 11
14, 2018
Domhoff, G. W. (1990). The Power Elite and the
State: How Policy Is Made in America. Transaction Publishers. Retrieved
11 14, 2018, from
https://books.google.com.pk/books?id=A35GpAnLR5EC&dq=the+power+elite+and+the+state&source=gbs_navlinks_s
HO, W.-C., LEE, W.-L., CHAN, C.-M., NG, Y.-N., &
CHOY, Y.-H. (2010). Hong Kong’s Elite Structure, Legislature and the Bleak
Future of Democracy under Chinese Sovereignty. Journal of Contemporary
Asia, 40(3), 466-486. Retrieved 11 14, 2018
Manza, J., & Cook, F. L. (2002). Navigating
Public Opinion: Polls, Policy, and the Future of American Democracy.
Oxford University Press. Retrieved 11 14, 2018
Mills, C. W. (2000). The Power Elite. Oxford
University Press. Retrieved 11 14, 2018
Ortmann, S. (2009). Politics and Change in
Singapore and Hong Kong: Containing Contention. Routledge. Retrieved 11
14, 2018
Phillips, P. (2018). Giants: The Global Power
Elite. Seven Stories Press. Retrieved 11 14, 2018
Shipman, A., Edmunds, J., & Turner, B. (2018). The
New Power Elite: Inequality, Politics and Greed. Anthem Press. Retrieved
11 14, 2018