One
of the brightest stars of the music industry faded last week in the form of
death of unrivaled Queen of soul, the one and only Aretha Franklin. She passed
away after losing the battle against one of the deadliest diseases, the
pancreatic cancer. All across the nation, people felt the loss and expressed
their condolence and memories that they had with the legendary singer (Independent.
co. uk, 2018). Madonna also delivered a speech of her personal experiences with
the Queen of Soul, Aretha Franklin. The social media criticism aroused due to
the self-centered speech of Madonna and cultural appropriation was also
discussed by analyzers. The things became worse due to brief video compilation
in which she was expected to honor the late Aretha Franklin. In a nutshell, she
made a speech entirely about herself and explaining how the music of Aretha
Franklin helped her in reaching the top of the charts (Independent. co. uk, 2018).
The
unit of my analysis is to identify key point Mentioned by Madonna in her
tribute to the late Aretha Franklin that she delivered to 2018 MTV Video Music
Awards. Madonna delivered a speech that was directly related to having felt
about Aretha Franklin. She described her personal connection with the song
"you make me feel like" Sang by Aretha Franklin in the first launch
edition of Madonna. She illuminated the effect of inspiration and connected the
queen of the soul with hard feelings while presenting the album on the award. This
was her story, which was inspired and driven by the music and personality of Aretha
Franklin.
Coding Categories of Madonna's Tribute Content Analysis
After
having the analysis of heart reviewed, I can express my confusion regarding the
attempt of signer about traditional criticism and tribute. While having an
analysis of her attribute I found some glitches in her reflection of words.
Instead of talking about the life of Franklin as it was expected by the viewers
and listeners, Madonna preferred to discuss her own personal journey towards
becoming a singer; a journey which was inspired all the way by Aretha Franklin (Independent. co. uk, 2018).
Initially,
she said that Aretha Franklin changed the course of her life and dragged her
from darkness towards the icon personality. While delivering The Tribute she
mentioned about her story that how successfully the song of Aretha Franklin
aided her in the audition. She decided to share the story of how suddenly she
started singing the song of Aretha Franklin on the spot in the audition and how
she became back dancer in "A French Disco Sensation". Madonna was
also accused of the wrong appearance for the cultural appropriation of her
outfit. The viewers dragged her on social media especially as a woman of color
and not showing a proper process for the honoring of Queen of Soul Aretha
Franklin (Independent. co. uk, 2018; Usatoday. com, 2018).
Results of Analysis of Madonna's Tribute
Madonna
was expected to deliver tribute and to put lights on the personality traits of
Queen of Soul Aretha Franklin in 2018 MTV Video Music Awards. Instead of discussing
how she learned from Aretha Franklin, she picturized her personal experience of
how she got success by singing the well-known song of Aretha Franklin. She
discussed her struggle story, her dreams of becoming a professional dancer, and
how she was accepted in the audition (Independent. co. uk, 2018). After discussing
about the early career struggles of becoming a singer, Madonna revealed the
role of Aretha Franklin in her career.
She
discussed that she sang a song of Franklin ("You make me feel like")
in a breakthrough audition. She shared a whole part of her journey and how she
entered in the music industry and thanked Madonna to lead her on the way of
success. The tone-deaf tribute steal back the spotlight of her intentions and
depicted more reactions of audience (Usatoday. com, 2018).
She
was asked to anecdote any career connection with Aretha Franklin but
definitely, it was not completely related to her. She shared a part of the
career journey and thanked Aretha for having inspiration for young talented
followers. Unfortunately, all the context was judged quickly by the audience
and get a short attention span.
After
analyzing the whole situation and incident, I could add my opinion that regardless
of whether it was or not the initial intention of Madonna to discuss her story
instead of paying tribute to Queen of Soul Aretha Franklin, the main
consideration is that it was not an appropriate way to pay tribute to legendary
soul in two minutes with the tinsel of award show and noise of viewers. The
network of 2018 MTV Video Music Awards could have some argument about what was
done a bit more related to the tribute of Aretha Franklin.
I
can also say that we may give benefit of the doubt to Madonna as well because
maybe she was there to pay tribute to Queen of Soul Aretha Franklin, but she
got carried away in the moment of grief and gratitude. Maybe, her thoughts were
scattered to talk about a legend and an inspiration of her music journey that
she could not got her words together in a proper manner to pay a great tribute.
But still, it was certainly wrong the way Madonna paid her tribute. She had
enough stage appearances and faced so many audiences, so there was no point to
get carried away. So, it can be said that she should have prepared a speech to
pay a proper tribute to her music inspiration, Queen of Soul Aretha Franklin.
References of Madonna's Tribute Content Analysis
Independent. co. uk. (2018, 08 21). Madonna faces
backlash for ‘disrespectful’ Aretha Franklin tribute. Retrieved from
www.independent.co.uk:
https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/madonna-aretha-franklin-tribute-vmas-2018-mtv-watch-a8500571.html
Usatoday. com. (2018, 08
21). Madonna responds to VMAs uproar: ' I did not intend to do a tribute' to
Aretha Franklin. Retrieved from www.usatoday.com:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/life/music/2018/08/20/vmas-madonna-focused-aretha-franklin-tribute-missed-mark/1049376002/