It
is regrettable that the castes are only informed for people who are from Hindu
denomination. Therefore, the following analysis is limited to the castes. The
focus is mainly on one of the questions that were asked during the interview.
The question was: “among the social classes, in which one do you think you
belong?”. Basically, in this research, we focus on the Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes, because their positions are clear-cut. The two categories of
castes will be compared to the non-scheduled classes.
Almost
half of the Scheduled Castes group are in either upper or upper middle classes,
while 25% of the groups that are non-scheduled are in upper or upper middle
classes. This is unexpected, now that both the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes were anticipated to occupy lower classes of the society. The Scheduled
Tribes always perceive themselves as belonging to the lowest end of the social
classes.
Averagely,
the Scheduled Castes are more educated than the Scheduled Tribes, although
slightly less than the non-scheduled groups. The distribution of education varies
depending on the caste, despite it being only a 5% significance level between
the Scheduled Castes and the other groups.
There
is also a different distribution of income across the castes. In the middle
ranges, is the income gathered for the non-scheduled groups, whereas for the
Scheduled Castes, the income distribution is more spread. Therefore, the
percentage of people among the Scheduled Castes that earn more than 20000
Rupees per month is 17%, and 3% among the non-scheduled. On the average, the
Scheduled Castes are wealthier than all the other groups, which also includes
the non-scheduled ones. The Scheduled Tribes income range is distributed at the
lower end.
Occupation
also has an impact on social identity, and it depends on whether the position
held is manual or a subordination. The percentage of people who occupy
non-manual positions is similar between the Scheduled Castes (49%) and the
non-scheduled castes (44), while the percentage is lower for the Scheduled
Tribes (26%). The Scheduled Castes group have the highest percentage of
professionals who hold positions with the most pay. The other groups hold
lesser paying jobs than the Scheduled Castes.
Issue with Sampling on Caste System in India
One
might find it strange that the characteristics of Scheduled Castes are not very
much different from the non-scheduled groups. The sampling technique employed
ensured that it included individuals aged 18 years and above. Furthermore, the
sample did not include any illiterate person, which may be a direct effect of
the sampling procedure. According to the World Values Survey, there are three
levels of education, and that is Primary and below, Secondary, and College.
It
is worth noting that people are averagely more educated in the World Values
Survey sample. This bias may be due to a large percentage of the sample came
from the urban areas with more than 10000 residents.
Untouchability
and Public Infrastructure
In
this section, we address the issues of violence caused by the caste. The use of
common resources is strongly defined through prohibiting sharing of these
resources with the outcasts. For example, a survey carried out on 565 villages
by Shah et al. (2006), found out that almost half of them all, the untouchables
were restricted from accessing water facilities. It was also discovered that
28% of the people in the survey were not allowed to enter the police stations,
and 18% of them all did not have access to either health centers or roads. The
prohibition of accessing the primary public resources is what is called
untouchability is most noticeable in the case of accessing water. This
untouchability mainly happens because of the belief that the outcasts are not
pure and they may taint them if they make contact. The ritual pollution is
mostly conveyed by food and water. Water is regarded as tainted if untouchables
of their containers touch it. In many cases, the outcasts are prohibited from
sharing wells with the higher castes. There are also cases of the outcasts
being beaten for having used the wells of the higher castes. In this section,
we discover that the violent acts committed on the untouchables is associated
with how water is distributed. If the water sources are commonly shared by
these groups, the number of violent acts is eventually higher.
The data
collected in a survey by the National Crimes Record Bureau of the Indian
Ministry of Home Affairs helped in the analyzing violent acts against the
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. The collected data covered 581
districts in 2001. The people in these districts are then associated to the Census
data by the percentage of the population with access to water either through
tanks, wells, taps, or tube wells.
According
to the results, as much as the untouchability laws are outlawed, they still
exist and are enforced violently. The relationship evidenced, indicates that
development programs for water, which target to improve the health of people,
has a good side effect of controlling the violence caused by the castes.
Presentation of Data on Caste System in India
The
data analyzed in this section fall under the Indian Penal Code (IPC), and they
were gathered from the National Crime Records Bureau, for the year 2001. The
data was from 31 states and union territories. The crimes analyzed include
rape, murder, abduction, and kidnapping, dacoity, arson, robbery and hurt.
These number of violent acts were gathered regardless of the perpetrators.
According to the analyzed data, the number of crimes committed against the
untouchables is 16 in every 100000 people, although it shows strong variations
in each state. At the district level, the variations are even larger.
Access to Water and Other Public Resources
on Caste System in India
The
data used here come from Census of India of the year 2001. The data gives
details at both the town and village levels with details about wells, tanks,
tube wells, taps. The information helped in calculating the percentage of the
population who have access to water through different media. Whenever a village
had one source of water, the entire population of the village was recorded to
have access to water through that source. Some villages had more than one
source of water, and the whole village was accounted for each source. The only
problem with the data is that the census does not indicate if that particular
source is private or public.
Although
the government has tried to improve access to water by its citizens,
heterogeneity in water access remains despite water being set as the main
target of the poverty eradication program. Averagely, 56% of the entire
population has access to water through taps.
Social Fragmentation and Public Resources
on Caste System in India
This
section makes use of collected data by the World Bank during the Survey of
Living Conditions in the northern Indian states of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh in
1997 and 1998. The probability of the village has more than five public
resources is analyzed based on the characteristics of the village. These public
resources include electricity connection, access to good roads, availability of
waste disposal system, public school, health facilities, as well as the
availability of bus networks (Subedi, 2011). There is a significant positive
impact on the availability of the named public resources, and a negative impact
on the presence of public schools. The result is important to the inclusion of
indicators of the effect on how castes dominate and the fix the state.
Introduction of inequality measures weakens the significance of the positive
coefficients.
This
part of the research paper aims at testing the effect of caste fragmentation on
public resource allocation. At first, fractionalization can play a positive
role in social fragmentation. Secondly, the impact of social fragmentation is
not associated with potential antagonisms, because there are no significant
polarization indices.
Data and Main Variables on Caste System in India
The
analysis is gotten from the data gathered by the Survey of Living Conditions in
1997-1998 in the northern Indian states (Bihar and Uttar Pradesh). Data covered
2250 households in 120 villages. The two states are the ones that are always
referred to as Indian’s poverty belt. The relationships among the castes in
this region are called confrontational. In 1998, 29% of the violent acts were
committed in the two states against the outcasts.
Hindus
are divided into two groups, the caste, and religion. The caste system
institution advocates for social fragmentation. This, in turn, is
underestimated by the classification, and it embraces the groups which have a
sense of belonging to a particular community. For example, some upper caste may
feel not related to other castes.