In Saudi Arabia on healthcare in spite of the relatively
high expenditure, in the main cities its health system is highly centralized
with its focus on secondary as well as tertiary care relatively than primary
care. For the healthcare providers this has led to several ethical challenges.
With a panel of practitioners study this article reports conducted the study
results along with non-clinicians. In Saudi Arabia, for healthcare providers,
patient, as well as their families, in order to find the top ten ethical
challenges but we discuss here only three out of ten.
Material & Methods of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
On Cross-sectional, descriptive, along with qualitative one
the study was designed. Question was asked by the participants: “in Saudi
Arabia what challenges are facing in health care? Throughout a modified Delphi
process the participants were asked to rank the ethical challenges, using a
scale of ranking. After three rounds of question a consensus was reached as
well as an experts’ meeting.
Results of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
Here we described the 10 major ethical issues, by the
participants as perceived in order of their important: rights of patient,
resources of equity, patients confidentiality, safety of patients, conflicts of
interest, privatization ethics, Consent informed, opposite sex dealing, start
and end of life, as well as ethics of healthcare team.
Conclusion on healthcare In Saudi Arabia
Although by the participants many of the challenges listed
that have received significant public along with worldwide specialized
attention, in Saudi Arabia scant attention has been paid to these top challenges.
To help address these key challenges we propose many possible steps.
Introduction of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
With a surface region of 2,150 thousand sq km, Saudi Arabia
is the second greatest Arab nation, as well as 25.5 million a populace, around
7 million of whom are non-Saudis. It is the main Muslim nations, for Muslims as
two of the most sacred locales (Makah and Madina), are situated here where
millions come to love as well as work each year. in the Eastern Mediterranean
Region, Contrasted with different nations it has one of the most elevated gross
national livelihoods per capita as well as use on health (USD 22,300 and 6.4%
(as level of (GDP)), respectively.
On health (5% of GDP) regardless of this generally high use,
in the human services framework the vast majority of the offices remain to a
great extent amassed in the three principle as well as most thickly populated
cities, to be specific: Riyadh, with18% the political capital of the MoH (Ministry
of Health) clinics as well as for 6.2
million individuals 18% of the Primary Health Care Centers (PHCCs); Jeddah
along with Makah with 9% of the Ministry of Health doctor's facilities as well
as for a populace of 4.9 million 7.5% of the PHCCs; along with the Eastern
Region, including Dammam as well as Qasim, which has 15% of the Ministry of
Health doctor's facilities, as well as for a populace of 3.4 million 13.4% of
the PHCCs.
In 1925, the advancement of the medicinal services
framework, in Saudi Arabia started by a Royal pronouncement when a Public
Health Department was built up. In 1926 the principal school of nursing was
opened, in 1927, trailed by the School of Heath and Emergencies.
In industrialized countries relating to healthcare systems
there is growing international literature that discusses the ethical issues.
Although with specific specialties’ these generally deal or else given group of
patient. By JM Berslin as well as colleagues done this leading study also
recognize the top ethical challenges that patients as well as in the healthcare
system their families in Toronto, Canada, face. In their study the top three
challenges: (1) between patient disagreement/ about treatment decisions
families and healthcare professionals (2) waiting list (3) as well as for the
aged access to needed resources, the chronically ill, along with the mental
ill.
Similarly, related to the healthcare system other studies
were carried out to recognize the national ethical problems. ‘Ethical problems’
perceive by the clinical situations doctors along with nurses. To oncology
nurses as highly important to describe the ethical issues deemed. By the Canadian study as frequently
encountered these studies the conclusion reached reflected the ethical issues
close to those revealed for example, in the healthcare problems reform process,
interactions professionals, along with relationship of doctor-patient. For
oncology nurses the top three priority ethical issues were assisted suicide,
decision of end of life, along with the pain management [1].
Moreover, in terms of volume and scope in Saudi Arabia the
literature relating to the medical/ Clinical ethics. On the Islamic perspective
most of the studies focus of some clinical practices for example donation of
oxygen, orders of do-not-resuscitate, as well as issues of end-of-life, or else
others issues like the satisfaction of patients. By Kalid Bin Saeed a study
that is worthy of note was conducted views of executive’s physician as well as
in Saudi Arabian hospitals clinicians on ethical issues. To the presence of
ethical issues the contributory factors leading. This examination is gone for
characterizing, gathering, as well as positioning in the medicinal services
framework the major moral difficulties experienced in Saudi Arabia, as seen by
the human services suppliers as well as the general population. By Breslin as
well as associates it likewise proposes a way to deal with the administration
of these moral issues in accordance with other global investigations,
particularly the Canadian examination
Materials & Methods of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
Descriptive, cross-sectional, as well as qualitative the
study was based on this. The three main cities of Saudi Arabia include Riyadh,
Jeddah, as well as Dammam and other smaller cities. In the major health
institutions the population study included ethics committee’s member. In
medical ethics along with medical administration who had experience. As the
table show below have the information of ten hospitals. From February to May
2010 this data was collected. In the study 90 replied, rate of 82% giving a
response, as well as 83 provided their professional as well as contact data out
of 110 participants. Clinicians as well as medical doctors both male and female
participants include 46 (55%) and 12 (15%) [2] [2].
Hospital & city
|
Participants
|
Riyadh
KFMC (king fahad Medical city)
KFNGH (king faisal national Guard hospital)
Hospital of military
KKUH (king Khalid university hospital)
|
34
|
Jeddah
KFSH (king faisal specialized Hospital)
KAUH (king abdul-Aziz university hospital)
|
24
|
Dammam
Dammam central hospital
King faisal specialized hospital
|
8
|
Others
Taif- hospital of military
Tabuk- hospital of military
|
24
|
Total
|
110
|
Collection of Data & analysis of healthcare In Saudi
Arabia
In three rounds a modified Delphi process was conducted. In
the first round, to write down a list of 110 participants were asked about what
they perceived as the top ten medical ethics challenges regarding to health
care. By the researchers these forms were then collected, listed along with
ranked. In the second round the ranked data was again sent to all the members.
As the top ten ethical issues regarding to the healthcare the participant have
to rank the list again as well as return by the researchers [3].
From all participants’ responses after ranking the obtained
ethical issues, to the participants the list was again sent in the third round,
to indicate their agreement. As they saw fit they were requested to re-rank the
items. By the participants to the research team than re-ranked responses were
returned, that is happen only when they didn’t agree what they were sent. An
open session was held to, at the experts’ meeting: (1) definition of the
problem unify; (2) top ethical problems selections; as well as (3)using a scale
re-rank these problems on the following four items that depended: (1) problem
size; (2) problem seriousness; (3) solving the feasibility; as well as (4)
public awareness status [4].
Results of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
Out of 110 members, in the examination 90 answered time
frame giving a reaction rate of 82%. Following the first cycle, 32 moral issues
were recognized, the best three of which were: Patients' rights (55; 61%),
privacy of patients' data (41; 46%), as well as medicinal carelessness/blunder
(31; 34%). The slightest critical were: in broad daylight healing facilities
Language hindrance, private segments, and nursing rehearses (2, 2, and 1%,
individually). In the second round the members' positioning was indistinguishable
to the first round. Patients' rights, quiet classification, as well as
restorative carelessness/mistake were positioned the most noteworthy of the
moral issues. From the members' perspective the third round and the gathering
of the board of members brought about the under listed top 10 restorative
morals issues confronting the Saudi populace [5].
Items
|
Problem size
|
Problem seriousness
|
Problem solving feasibility
|
Status of people awareness
|
total
|
Rights of patients
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
3
|
192
|
Resources equity
|
4
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
192
|
Patients confidentiality
|
4
|
4
|
3
|
3
|
144
|
Safety of patients
|
4
|
4
|
2
|
4
|
128
|
Interests conflicts
|
4
|
4
|
2
|
4
|
128
|
Privatization ethics
|
4
|
4
|
2
|
4
|
128
|
Informed consent
|
4
|
4
|
3
|
2
|
96
|
Opposite sex dealing
|
4
|
3
|
2
|
4
|
96
|
Start and end of life
|
4
|
4
|
2
|
2
|
64
|
Ethics of healthcare team
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
2
|
54
|
Discussion of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
In a culturally diverse population, the presence of a
centralized healthcare system as well as to a set of ethical issues healthcare
providers may give rise. For example, in many peripheral areas Saudi patient
have to travel to seek health care one of the main cities. Hence, organized
approach is introduced to control these ethical issues. Within the public the
highest ranked ethical challenges in the healthcare system was the issue of
patient’s rights according to the study of Canadian. The first major ethical
issues were the disagreements among patients/ families on decision of treatment
healthcare professionals. In Saudi Arabia, the ‘Manual Guide for Medical
Practitioners’ this is the only known national document issued to provide
guidance to practitioners. This unmistakably expresses the privilege of
patients to: the entrance of 'good' treatment; for any restorative intercession
give assent; classification of his/her medicinal data; to reject treatment
against therapeutic advice as well as the privilege. Since it is just an
archive that 'directs', the onus has been on the primary healing facilities to
build up their Patients' Bill of Rights. Lamentably, this is still during the
time spent being detailed, concluded, as well as embraced [6].
Equity of access to resources this is the 2nd highest ranked
ethical challenges that in the healthcare system facing by the public. In the
Saudi Arabia healthcare system the equity of distribution of major issues is health
resources, in the main cities as most of the resources are primarily. In spite
of this, even within these cities there are inequities among Saudis along with
non-Saudis. With some serious diseases few exception are made for patient, for
instance, dengue fever along with tuberculosis, to free management who should
have access to this, their legal status
although [7].
Confidentiality of the patient is the third highest ranked
in ethical challenges that is faced in Saudi Arabia healthcare system.
Importance of this issue is understood by the panels that have to give the
serious attention. On the management of patient information there are no clear
policies, mostly the records of medical in many hospitals. To the discretion of
the clinician the management of these records is usually left. On sharing any information this includes
decisions regarding the patient without the proper consent of the patient. By
Khalid Bin Saeed this finding was made, in his study who indicated that 80% of
the clinicians has stated that in their hospitals patient confidentially was a major
ethical issue.
The most plausible reason is that patients are probably not
going to realize that their classified data has been shared, and thusly, are
more averse to document a grumbling against the treating specialist or the
healing facility. With an expanding number of patients suing their treating
specialists in Saudi Arabia, preventive measures have taken the main hospitals.
The solution of these problems is that we should develop policies for the
patient confidential report. The report was only given to the family member of
the patient with the permission of the patient [8].
Conclusion of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
It is concluded that this examination was expected for
correlation with those of the Canadian investigation. Due to the distinctions
in culture as well as medicinal services frameworks of Saudi Arabia along with
Canada Contrasts were without a doubt expected. It is concluded that in
contrast to the Canadian examination, the suppositions of managers as well as
legitimate agents this investigation incorporated. Albeit by the members a
considerable lot of the difficulties recorded have gotten noteworthy open as
well as around the world concentrated consideration, in Saudi Arabia almost no
consideration has been given to these best difficulties.
In spite of the fact
that a code of morals requires not set down principles that are an unchangeable
reality, it can furnish direction to manage moral issues as they emerge. The
best moral issues mirrored the national and social characteristics of the Saudi
populace and health framework. In any case, the Arabic-Islamic good qualities
one can sensibly accept that the issues talked about will be appropriate to
different nations of the locale that share. Contrasts will, notwithstanding,
stay, as from various wellbeing conveyance frameworks there will be issues that
emerge.
References of healthcare In Saudi Arabia
[1]
|
I. G. Cohen:, The Globalization of Health Care: Legal and
Ethical Issues, Oxford University Press, 2013.
|
[2]
|
G. D. Pozgar, Legal and Ethical Issues for health
professionls, Jones & Bartlett publisher, 2014.
|
[3]
|
V. D. Lachman, Ethical challenge in healthcare, Springeer
publishing company, 2009.
|
[4]
|
J. Larson and Contributor, 6 March 2013. [Online].
Available:
https://www.amnhealthcare.com/latest-healthcare-news/five-top-ethical-issues-healthcare/.
|
[5]
|
J. Mfutso-Bengo, F. Masiye and A. Muula, "Ethical
challenges in conducting research in humanitarian crisis situations," Malawi
Med J, pp. 46-49, 2008.
|
[6]
|
M. A. Speers and L. K. Bairy, "Practical solutions to
challenges in research ethics proceedings of Bangalore conference," Perspect
Clin RES, pp. 227-232, 2013.
|
[7]
|
C. Yip, N.-L. R. Han and B. L. Sng, "Legal and
ethical issues in research," Indian J Anaesth, pp. 684-688, 2016.
|
[8]
|
A. F. Alkabba, G. M. A. Hussein, A. A. Albar, A. A.
Bahnassy and M. Qadi, "The major medical ethical challenges facing the
public and healthcare providers in Saudi Arabia," family community Med.,
pp. 1-6, 2012.
|