Even with the growing challenges of underground drug importation,
there is still little evidence regarding the knowledge of the crime and the
process involved in bringing these criminals to book. In addition, the different measures taken by
drug law enforcement agencies around the world do not really tackle the main issue
and the real culprits in the multi-billion dollar underground industry. The
main aim of this report is to come up with a better understanding of the
process or underground drug importations and analyze various cases so as to
come up the best Situation Crime prevention techniques by using the crime
scripts. This will be achieved by
providing an analysis of 10 court cases whereby the crime script containing
various stages will also be identified.
In addition, the report will also come up with prevention measures which
will be summarized in the analysis framework. The report will conclude by
showing that by only focusing on the chemicals, location and equipment used to
conduct the vice will eventually have a damaging effect on the whole
manufacturing of the script.
Introduction of Illegal drug networking with manufacturers
Illegal drug importation is a business that is operated by
organized and well-connected groups which are used to secretly networking with
manufacturers of illegal drugs and importing them is a growing concern for the
drug law enforcement agencies around the world. However, even with the increase
of the number of illegal drug imports detected every year, there are different approaches
which are used by law enforcement agencies that have often relied on poor
mechanisms, mostly reactive in nature.
In this manner they are never as effective. When looking at law enforcement agencies,
they mostly rely on informants, crackdowns and raids, undercover operations and
will mostly suffer from the general lack of high quality form of
intervention. This is because most
agencies will favor approaches that will lead to arrest of people found with
illicit drug imports, court convictions or the seizure of the warehouse.
However they still lack the detail needed to understand the vice and how the
people responsible are well connected.
According to Y, et al., (2011) the use of crime scripts in
understanding and solving illegal drug important problem is very innovative and
can provide an much more detailed way of understanding the factors involved in
the whole crime syndicate and come up with a situation crime prevention measure
or technique. This is because crime scripts can be able to map the different forms
of actions taken or used by offenders drug the act. Crimes scripts are also
important as they enable drug law agencies to capture sequences of the same
crime, including the operations involved in the illegal drug importation. The understanding is also very important
since it will provide a lasting solution for the prevention of illegal drug importation.
This is because while coming up with a crime script, one is able to understand
the complete sequence, the decisions taken during and after the commission of
crime and will analyze all stages in the process. At this the law enforcement
officers will be able to come up with a fuller variety of situational crime
prevention strategies (Porter, 2008). These strategies
will be used to counter the different stages of illegal drug importation.
Case 1: R v Silva [2010] QCA 79
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was Cocaine
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 99 packets, about 89kg ( 79% pure)
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
Jorge Ernesto Velarde Silva (Velarde), Jackson and Nudd
|
Location
|
Colombia to Mexico to Australia
|
Transport Used
|
Ship
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
Telephone intercepts, obtaining false Identification,
|
Tools
|
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
Obtaining false Identification, payment of $1,000,000 for
transportation.
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
commercial
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Colombia cartel
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
They were obtained in packet form.
|
Sequence of Events
Accused transported the drugs through a ship after hiring
Sparkles plenty vessel.
The skipper of the vessel had the accused son and himself as
crew members
The police intercepted telephone conversation between
Jackson a resident from of Puerto Vallarta in Mexico and the accused.
The vessel was sailed to Mexico via Columbia and the Panama
canal,
At this point Jackson agreed to the journey with cocaine
worth $1,000,000
Drugs were brought to sparkles plenty via a small craft (
panga)
Cocaine was discovered in water tanks at a stopover in Tahiti
7 days later Jackson was queried by customs officer on
arrival to Australia and apprehended.
Case2: R v Dehghani; Ex parte Director of Public
Prosecutions
(Cth) [2011] QCA 159
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was Methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA – ecstasy)
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 81,000 pills weighing 26.096 kg with a pure weight
of MDMA of
5.219 kg
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
K Gill” at 5 Laurel St
Redbank Plains., D. Campbell
|
Location
|
From the United Kingdom to Australia
|
Transport Used
|
Air transport
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
Interception by customs office at Brisbane Airport
|
Tools
|
Label Boxes marked as Toys,
DVDs, children’s, games
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
Used false ID to transport the drugs
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
UK
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
They were transported as toys to Australia.
|
Sequence of Events of Illegal drug networking with
manufacturers
The customs office at Brisbane intercepted two boxes posted
from the United Kingdom on January 31st 2007.
The boxes were labelled as containing Toys, children games
and DVDs.
After dismantling the boxes ecstasy pills were found.
There was a surveillance device which was placed in the
boxes and the accused phone was intercepted.
It recorded how the accused repositioned the boxes using a T
shirt to avoid finger prints.
The respondent’s car was intercepted and he was
apprehended.
Case 3: R v Jimson [2009] QCA 183
|
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was Cocaine
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 1,686.8
grams estimated at $759,083.49
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
|
Location
|
Chile to Australia
|
Transport Used
|
Air inside a suitcase
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
Customs officers, Federal Police intercepted the package
|
Tools
|
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
Transported inside a suitcase, with instructions written under.
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial.
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
The package came from Chile
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
They were obtained as a package.
|
Sequence of Events of Illegal drug networking with
manufacturers
On March 3rd 2008 the offender arrived at Brisbane airport
in Australia on a flight from Chile using a Malaysian passport.
When questioned by the customs office she responded with
broken English that she came to Australia for holiday.
Her suitcase was then examined.
Cocaine was found in a sealed packaged that was concealed
within the lining.
Her bag had a diary with instructions given to the accused
regarding transportation of the suitcase.
After reaching Brisbane airport she was to take the bag to
an address in Sydney where it would be collected.
The police found that she was instructed by a woman from
Brazil.
She was apprehended with 1.686.8 grams of pure cocaine.
She co-operated and entered a guilty plea.
Case 4: R v Oprea [2009] QCA 184
|
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was Cocaine
|
Amount Discovered
|
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
It was found that unknown amounts of Constantine Oprea, Simone
Harris, Jesse Bradford, Iaon Dobrovolski ( prosecution witness)
|
Location
|
Costa Rica into Australia
|
Transport Used
|
Courier Truck
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
Interception of the truck
|
Tools
|
Truck and gift pack
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
The drugs were transported in a courier truck
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
commercial
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Costa Rica
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
Packaged gift
|
Sequence of Events of Illegal drug networking with
manufacturers
A parcel posted from Costa Rica was intercepted by the
Sydney customs. The parcel was addressed to Daiana Grimes, 235 Jefferson Lane,
Palm Beach on the Queensland’s Gold Coast.
This was later found to be a fake address.
The package had four boxes of chocolate, inside them were
packs of cocaine under the chocolate layers.
The total amount of cocaine found was 1.489.7 grams of pure
cocaine.
The cocaine was removed and the package reconstructed and
delivered to the address.
Jesse Bradford took the package and delivered to Harris (co-offender).
He tried to contact Oprea and discussed arrangements to pick
the package disguised as a ‘Christmas present’.
She instructed the package be taken to her car which was being repaired.
She was intercepted as she tried to open
the package and apprehended.
Case 5: R v Tran [2007] QCA 221
|
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was Heroin
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 2,159.4 grams gross, and 1,473 grams pure heroin
valued at $1,000,000
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
Anh Kiet Tran
|
Location
|
Cambodia as the source to Australia
|
Transport Used
|
Air
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
X-ray at customs office
|
Tools
|
Plastic Jars and condoms
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
The drugs were already manufactured and ready for transportation
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Cambodia cartels
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
The drugs were sealed in plastic jars wrapped with masking tapes and
in condoms.
|
Sequence of Events
Tran left Sydney on 24th February 2006 for Vietnam where he
stayed till 24th February. He later flew to Cambodia and obtained heroin.
On March 1st he arrived at Brisbane.
His bags were examined by custom officers. They found two
large plastic jars that were wrapped in masking tape to cover the contents. The
barrels also contained cut sections of fish and condoms.
After X-ray the jars and condoms were found to contain a
mixture of 68% of heroin with a street value of $1,000,000.
Case 6: R v Nwabueze [2012] QCA 275
|
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was Herion
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 852.6 grams
of pure heroin contained within 1,395.5 grams of powder
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
Edwin Uchenna Nwabueze, Piyaporn
Eiwarun with Francis Okafor,
|
Location
|
From Bangkok to Australia
|
Transport Used
|
Air
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
X-ray at customs
|
Tools
|
Suitcase
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
Stored in powder form
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial syndicate
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Bangkok through Ms. Piyaporn Eiwarun
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
Disguised as a bag containing Indian clothes
|
Sequence of Events
On November 2007 a female Thai national, Ms. Piyaporn
Eiwarun came to Australia as a student of English. She was acquainted with a
man named Francis Okafor over the internet.
The soon lived together as lovers. Okafor told Eiwarun that
he was a doctor working in India.
He organized for a flight for her to go to India, thereafter
meet his family in Nigeria. Later on she spent a month in Delhi with Okafor.
When she was returning the Australia, Okafor asked her to
take a package to a friend in Australia who wanted to open a shop for Indian
cloths.
On March 9th 2008 she arrived at Brisbane airport. When her
luggage was X- Rayed Herion was identified in false compartment.
It was later found that the bag contained 852.6 grams of
pure heroin.
She agreed to cooperate with the police. Where 30 calls
between him and the accused were recorded.
She was later apprehended and charged with the transporting heroin.
She still continued to cooperate with the police who later caught up with
Okafor when he was boarding a taxi.
Case 7: R v Hill, Bakir, Gray & Broad; ex parte
Cth DPP [2011] QCA 306
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was GBL
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 30kgs of pure GBL
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
Steven Milton Hill, Yassar Bakir, Candice Ruth Gray, Anthony Keith
Broad
|
Location
|
Australia and in universities
|
Transport Used
|
Air and road
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
X-ray and interception
|
Tools
|
Suitcases and other forms of disguise
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
Imported as GBL and sold in the market as GHB
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial and syndicate involved
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Australian syndicate
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
Sold in bottled packages after a chemical process to transform it to
GHB
|
Sequence of events of Illegal drug networking with
manufacturers
The accused were in business of importing GBL
They used GBL to manufacture GHB which was an illegal
substance. And sold it in universities and streets.
One of the accused was asked to cooperate which ensured that
the other members of the cartel were arrested.
Case 8: R v Handlen & Paddison [2010] QCA 371
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was cocaine, 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine
(ecstasy)
and methamphetamine)
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 135.7 kilograms of cocaine powder and 121,291
tablets containing a mix of
3,4 methylenedioxymethamphetamine and methamphetamine
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
( Canadian Citizens) Dale Christopher Handlen, Dennis Paul Paddison, Kelsey
Nerbas
|
Location
|
Canada to Australia
|
Transport Used
|
Shipment container
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
Container inspection, probably with sniffer dogs
|
Tools
|
Cathode Ray tubes and computer monitors
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
Transportation as electronics
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial and syndicate
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Reliable Computer Conversions Pty Ltd
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
It was packaged as computer monitors
|
Sequence of Events of Illegal drug networking with
manufacturers
The appellants were both Canadian citizens.
They were involved in the shipment of large amounts of ecstasy,
methamphetamine and cocaine from their country to Australia.
It is reported that the first importation took place on May
2006.
The second one took place on June 2006.
The first accused Handlen was charged with possession in the
first shipment.
The shipment was packaged in cathode ray tubes of computer
monitors.
After inspecting the warehouse container where the monitors
were stored, 480 monitors were found to contain the drugs.
These containers were destined for Brisbane.
After more than 4 months surveillance the accused were found
guilty and apprehended. They were also found with an email from Reed regarding
the next shipment, the computer monitors were seized. It also contained 698
tablets of ecstasy.
Case 9: R v Tsay [2006] QCA 423
|
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug types were Methyl amphetamine and a commercial quantity of
3, 4- methylenedioxymethamphetamine (ecstasy).
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 413 kgs, ( 1
and half kg of ecstasy tablets) 259.2 kilograms of methyl amphetamine tablets
which were 26.2 kilograms pure; and 152.25 kilograms of methyl amphetamine crystal,
123.17 kilograms pure contained.
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
Chien Shen Tsay, and two Malaysian nationals named Khoo and Kwek
|
Location
|
Australia, Airlie Beach
|
Transport Used
|
Boat
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
apprehension
|
Tools
|
Sniffer dogs,
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
False ID
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial and syndicate involved
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Self-imposed
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
Moved in bags from the Gold Coast
|
Sequence of events
The appellants, by use of false name assisted the co-accused
on their arrival to Australia.
He advised them to rent a motel room, where they paid an
advance bond and rent on a unit.
A bank account was open to which they deposited their
expenses.
They drove together at Airline beach where the appellant
negotiated to buy a yatch.
A customs officer boarded on the Yatch while they were
training to ride it.
He recorded a series of questions and answers.
During a telephone conversation, Khoo was given instructions
of transporting drugs in the yatch, however while bringing the bags to land by
the Gold coast unit.
The appellants were apprehended on a boat at Mooloolaba
where they were found with 413 kgs of drugs. They included 1 ½ kgs tablets of ecstasy,
259.2 kilograms of methamphetamine tablets and 152.25 kgs of meth crystal. This
had a street value of $125 million.
Case 10: R v Lebanon; ex parte Cth DPP [2006] QCA
529
|
|
|
|
DESCRIPTION
|
ANALYSIS
|
Drug Type
|
The drug type was methyl amphetamine
|
|
Amount Discovered
|
It was found that 7.314 kg of pure methyl amphetamine were with the
accused.
|
Actors and social Network Involved
|
Andrew Lester Lebanon, Daniel Maio, Mehdi Mohammad
|
|
Location
|
Darwin then to Townsville
|
Transport Used
|
US War Ship and by air and motor vehicle
|
Security Measures ( including weapons)
|
Use of the war ship made it difficult to suspect but inspection by
police unfoiled the plot, interview records
|
Tools
|
Carry Bag
|
Steps involved in the manufacturing process (e.g. false ID, storage,
transportation)
|
Carried in a carry bag
|
Purpose of manufacture (e.g. personal use/ commercial/ syndicate
involved)
|
Commercial and syndicate involved
|
Precursors used in manufacture
|
Miao
|
How the recipe, equipment & precursor chemicals were obtained
|
Disguised as a blue carry bag
|
Sequence of events
Lebanon was a petty officer on the US Warship USS Boxer
On 8th June 2005 the Boxer visited Australia’s Townsville,
being a public vessel owned by a foreign state and engaged in government work.
Lebanon was spotted packing a blue carry bag that had a
number of packages including his laundry.
After being cleared with security he travelled to Seagulls
resort with friends.
He later left his back in a hotel.
Later made several calls to co-offender that include Maio
and Muhammad. Later on delivered the bag to Maio.
After being intercepted he agreed to participate in a police
record of interview.
From the interview Maio and Muhammad were intercepted by AFT
officer with the three packages containing 7.314 of pure methyl amphetamine of
a street value $10.3M.
Pattern Identification for all the cases of Illegal drug
networking with manufacturers
From the analysis of the above scripts, the patterns two
which illegal importation if drugs in Australia appear to move in the same
channels as follows
Matrix of Collated Data
Cases
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
6
|
7
|
8
|
9
|
10
|
Total
|
%
|
Actors Involved
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Offenders
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
10
|
100
|
Victims
|
|
|
|
|
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
|
4
|
40
|
Co-offenders
|
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
Y
|
7
|
70
|
Offender's Friend
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Victim's Friend
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Bystanders
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Offender's Age At time of offence
|
|
|
21
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Victims age at time of offence
|
|
|
|
|
|
30
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Script Steps for cases
References of Illegal drug networking with manufacturers
Porter,
L. (2008). Using archival data and multidimensional scaling to explore
leadership: Examples from group crime. . Issues in Forensic Psychology, 8,
33-44. .
Y, N. C., Leclerc, B., & Townsley, M. (2011). Crime
script analysis of drug manufacturing in clandestine laboratories. . British
Journal of Criminology, 51, 355-374.