What are the
similarities and differences between the two versions of this fairy tale? Why
do these differences exist? How would audiences interpret these two different
versions today?
The
Tangled is based on tale of Rapunzel. There are many of the similarities and
difference in both the stories. In both the stories of Rapunzel there are many
similarities with colors as well as shapes that are connected with the theory
of Molly Bang. The feeling of fear, curiosity, as well as anxiousness the tall,
as well as sharp edged corners along with the darkness in the tower in version
Zelinsky, reflect. In the story the author wants the audience to escape the
feeling of fear as well as know that she is a protagonist the Rapunzel has a
blonde color long hair. In the Disney version, there are many happier curves
and shapes found. As the Disney version of Rapunzel is very interesting for the
children as well as an adult. The picturization of the Disney version is very
mesmerizing. The prince is the thief in both the version of Rapunzel. There is
also a difference in both the version of Rapunzel story. In Disney version,
there is a magic flower, but in Rapunzel version, there is no concept of the
flower. For saving the queen, the magic flower is used. In the tower life, the key difference is that
protecting her secret as we see the Grimm version there is a huge stone.
At
this point, the behavior of Gothel’s toward the Rapunzel is quite mysterious.
As compared to the Disney version the Rapunzel is much more, intelligent,
active as well as unwilling and the Gothel in Disney version is much more
cunning or manipulative as well as sinister. In Disney version a pleasant whose
dream of living in a castle by princess Rapunzel technically granted to the
boy. Starting with the bout of assault their relationship is a slow burner. But
this is not happening in the Grimm version where they do not go outside the
tower. But they are happy couple through the outset. By Rapunzel escape as well
as her new boyfriend the Disney Gothel is angry; the reason behind this is that
he scared that she found her identity, as well as nothing, can change the mind
of the girl. But in the Grimm’s version, the Rapunzel pregnancy and the Gothel
is less brutal in this version. In Disney version Gothel’s limit the freedom of
the princess Rapunzel. In the Disney version, Rapunzel tears are enough to
bring back someone in life.
As
it can see that both versions of the fairy tale story have the context with a
little difference in the writing and scenes of the movie. In the Disney movie Tangled,
there are more reasoning occur behind the situation in more detail, for example
in the Tangle the magical flower is used to make a reason why she has a long
hair, but in the Rapunzel, there is no reason for that. The Disney make this movie more realistic,
although it is based on the fantasy, but still, the depiction of the characters
in the film is so brilliant that they the audience can get emotionally connect
with the characters (Blogspot.com, 2015).
The
difference between both of the version of the same story exit because Disney
doesn't want to make the behavior of any characters extreme. In the Rapunzel,
the characters of the mother were so evil in all of the sides, but in the
Tangled, Disney not only gave the name to the mother but rather than making her
extremely evil, they make her neutral to evil and selfish lady who thrive for
the external beauty (Sylvanfire, 2016).
They
Disney make the movie more into the fantasy by using the lanterns and her dream
to seem them. Unlike Rapunzel, Disney not just focus on the beauty and problems
of the princess but also put a lot of adventure and festivity in it to make
adore her and in some way feel the connection with her. There is more suspense
in the Tangled more as compared with the Rapunzel, for example in the Tangled
at the end, the her lover finds her, that was the trick of Mother Gothel, but
in the Rapunzel, the Flynn finds the princess by listening to her voice.
The
audiences like the Tangled movie more than the older version Rapunzel because
the Tangled movie not just take the fairy tale story, but also make it more
fancy, adventurous and full of humor. The people of all ages from children to adults
can joy and adore the Tangled movie, because of the liveliness go side by side
with the love story. The animation in Tangled makes it look more realistic and
beautiful. Although the audiences see the Rapunzel as the childish and girlish
movie on the other side, the Tangle does not seem to target just girls but the character
of the Flynn is so bold, charming and intelligent in the movie that makes is
loveable for all kinds of audiences (Ailime.blogspot.com/, 2011).
The
new version Tangle also broke the stereotype in the fairy tales that Prince is
always a gentleman, who is very decent and there is nothing wrong with him. In
the Rapunzel, there is a prince, who is the lover of the Rapunzel, but in the
Tangled the boy who saves her and loved her was a thief, and it is very new to
people to see any main lead in the story as thief. So the audiences no doubt
finds the Tangled more adorable, humorous, adventures and romantic than the
older version Rapunzel that is somehow is not very relatable for the audiences (Blogspot.com,
2015).
References of
Disney's (2010) "Tangled" and the Grimm brothers'
"Rapunzel."
Ailime.blogspot.com/.
(2011, June 21). Rapunzel - Grimm versus Disney. Retrieved from
http://ailime.blogspot.com/2011/06/rapunzel-grimm-versus-disney.html
Blogspot.com. (2015). Rapunzel
vs. Tangled. Retrieved November 14, 2015, from
http://disneygrimm.blogspot.com/2015/11/rapunzel-vs-tangled.html
Sylvanfire. (2016,
January 20). Disney VS Grimm: Rapunzel (aka Tangled). Retrieved from
https://geekgirlpenpals.com/disney-vs-grimm-rapunzel-aka-tangled/