The agreements of peace were signed in 1979
between Egypt and Israel which also resulted in the withdrawal of Israel from
Sinai Peninsula. It was followed by the military government abolishment in the Gaza
Strip and West Bank in the favor of Civil Administration of Israel. With the
establishment of treaty, both the US and Israel began to aid Egypt in terms of
both its economy and military. Due to this foreign assistance, Egypt has
prospered and its economy has gotten better. Even though it appears that peace
between the two nations is strong, the peace between them is explained through
the term of cold peace. Both of the nations are wary and concerned about each
other. They are uncertain about the actions of each other and due to it, there
is always a possibility of war between them (USIP, 2019).
For almost
seventy years, the conflicts between Palestine and Israel have influenced the
landscape of Middle East. International efforts have been evaded by a detailed
and complex diplomatic solution which has left several ambiguous and confused
about peace prospect. In spite of the peace treaties between the two countries,
issues have prevailed and there have been problems. One of the most important
reasons for the conflict between the two nations is their relatable religious
histories. Both of
the nations have religious claims about the land and that is what keeps them
apart from each other. The primary reason why conflict exists between Israel
and Palestine is their land. Israelis claims the land to be theirs because of
their ancestral footprints on the group and Palestinians claim the land to be
solely theirs as it also has the footprints of their ancestors on the land.
Battles between the two countries have been ensued because of this issue and
they have yet to reach a mutual conclusion. In fact, even though treaties have been
developed, the peace between them is not sustainable. Due to it, other countries have also been
affected. There are a number of other reasons including this one as well why
peace hasn’t been established between the two nations. In this paper, these
issues will be discussed and historical background will be discussed (Quandt, 2010).
Obstacles in Peace Establishment
Land Issues of Peace between Arab and Israel
It can be said that the part of conflict
arose from claims about the land. For instance, territory which is regarded by
the Jewish people as their homeland is at the very same time when it was
regarded by Arab Palestinians. Both of the communities had claims about the
land and this played an important role in their conflicts.
Religious Aspects of Peace between Arab and Israel
Palestine and Israel both are religious nations
and their history can be traced back to decades. The religions being followed
by Palestinians and Israelis are different. For instance, Palestinians practice
Islam and its rituals while Judaism is practiced by the Israelis. These
religions have a clear difference between them in both traditions and other
values. However, these religions have had a history together and battles
between the two communities have been noted by scholars. These differences are
utilized by politicians and governmental officials within the two nations to
keep the instability between two religions. Due to the fact that religious
aspects are included in international relations and politics, peace is
inhibited.
International and External Obstacles
Iranian Conflict of Peace between Arab and Israel
Generally, following the peaceful negotiations
between the Palestinian Authority and Israel, movements of Palestinian militant
led and controlled by Hamas served to initiate a campaign of terror for
disrupting and derailing the negotiations. It can be said that attacks on
Israel have increased since 2010 after four civilians were assassinated by
militants of Hamas. Rocket attacks have been increased by Palestinians at
Israelis. Hamas militants, on 2nd August, launched several rockets
at Aqaba and Eliat, which killed a Jordanian civilian while four others were
wounded (Beinin & Hajjar, 2014).
Egypt &
Peace between Arab and Israel
After the Accords of Camp David, a peace treaty
was signed by Egypt and Israel in 1979. In accordance with the terms, Sinai
Peninsula actually returned to the hands of Egyptians and the Gaza Strip
remained under the control of Israel, to be included in the Palestinian State’s
future. In general, the agreement also offered a free passage for the ships of
Israel through Suez Cana and required the recognition of Gulf of Aqaba and
Straits of Tiran as international water ways.
In accordance with the figures of Israel, 57 were civilians and
120 were soldiers among the killed people. Due to it, international outcry was
ensured and many criticized Israel for what it had done as it was quite a
violent response. Additionally, protests were ensued on numerous campuses across
the United States of America and in front of the consulate of Israel. Additional
protests also occurred across the countries of Middle East, South America, and Europe.
But the governments of Netherlands, Czech Republic, Bulgaria, Australia,
Germany, Canada, United Kingdom, and the United States expressed support the
right of Israel to defend itself against attacks. They also condemned the
attacks which were targeted at them.
Similar to Israel, Egypt also suffered an irreplaceable and unbearable
loss due to the battle between the two countries. The numbers are not
highlighted by studies but it has been determined that more than 1,000
Egyptians were killed by Israelis at a single time and most of them were always
soldiers. In comparison with Israel, Egypt lost more soldiers and people and
that is one of the important reasons peace is unstable between them. In
response to it, most of the Arab countries sided with Egypt and criticized
Israel for its actions because due to it, countless humans had died.
Following the rise of attacks by Hamas, an operation was started
in the Gaza Strip in 2014. Meanwhile, the military role of Israel in the Civil
War of Syria has actually been limited to just missile strikes which were not
acknowledged officially until 2017. Although the official position of Israel is
neutral in the issue, it is opposed to the presence of Iran in Syria
nonetheless. It has been determined that even in the Civil War, there were
involvements of Israel and it caused Syria to be agitated about the situation
of cold peace between them.
Some proxies of Iran like Hezbollah are generally suspected by
Israel for performing attacks against the positions of Israel on borders to
Lebanon and Syria, and Israel is also suspected of performing strikes against
carriers which were transferring weapons to different organizations. In 2017, the
President of the US announced that the nation was recognizing Jerusalem as
Israel’s capital. It promoted condemnation from other nations and also resulted
in protests along with the Gaza border. In 2018, a new embassy of the US was
opened.
This support has been criticized by several Muslim and Arab
nations because of Israel’s involvement in several attacks on Egypt and
Palestine. In accordance with them, Israel is responsible for killing countless
humans. It has been reported in the recent times by Syrian media that warplanes
of Israel struck various sites in Syria and killed both civilians and fighters.
Due to it, the situation has only become adverse between Muslim countries and
Israel. All of these nations are involved in the battles and both have suffered
from losses (Cohen, 2015).
References of Peace between Arab and Israel
Beinin, J., & Hajjar, L. (2014). Palestine,
Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict. Midle East: The Middle East Research
and Information Project.
Cohen, H. (2015). Year zero of the Arab-Israeli
conflict 1929. Brandeis University Press.
Quandt, W. B. (2010). Peace process: American
diplomacy and the Arab-Israeli conflict since 1967. Brookings Institution
Press.
USIP. (2019). The Current Situation: Israel, The
Palestinian Territories, and the Arab-Israeli Conflict. Retrieved from
USIP:
https://www.usip.org/publications/2019/08/current-situation-israel-palestinian-territories-and-arab-israeli-conflict