MD Company is working in the
manufacturing sector to produce and sell sports cycles and other sports
products. The company owns the capital of more than $100000 and 300 plus
workforce in the manufacturing and organizing departments. MD Company is
seeking for opportunities to improve the financial health of the company
through improvement in strategies and systems. In the present work, cash
budget, budgeted income statement, and budgeted balance sheet are developed in
the master budget of MD Company. Furthermore, present work is also based on financial
ratios calculation, monitoring of strategic planning, and comparison of MD
Company with market benchmark scores. Present work will also elaborate on
Management Accounting skills sets and characteristics of effective management
accountant in MD Company.
Learning Objective: 3
Master Budget of MD
Company
Cash Budget:
In the following table, the cash balance is projected on a
monthly basis for MD Company. In accordance to this table, ending cash balance
of each month (after meeting expenditures, cash outlays, and purchases) would
be more than $50000 (Bebbington, Gray, & Laughlin,
2001).
Cash
Budget
|
OCT
|
NOV
|
DEC
|
JAN
|
FEB
|
MAR
|
Budgeted
Total
|
Actual
|
Variance
|
Beginning Cash Balance
|
$22,500.00
|
$55,500.00
|
$53,000.00
|
$50,000.00
|
$52,500.00
|
$52,500.00
|
$286,000.00
|
$314,600.00
|
$28,600.00
|
Current
month sales
|
$25,000.00
|
$27,500.00
|
$27,500.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$170,000.00
|
$187,000.00
|
$17,000.00
|
Previous month sales
|
$
-
|
$25,000.00
|
$27,500.00
|
$27,500.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$140,000.00
|
$154,000.00
|
$14,000.00
|
Add:
Cash Collections
|
$25,000.00
|
$52,500.00
|
$55,000.00
|
$57,500.00
|
$60,000.00
|
$60,000.00
|
$310,000.00
|
$341,000.00
|
$31,000.00
|
Total Cash Available
|
$47,500.00
|
$108,000.00
|
$108,000.00
|
$107,500.00
|
$112,500.00
|
$112,500.00
|
$596,000.00
|
$655,600.00
|
$59,600.00
|
Less:
Cash outlay on Administrative Expenses
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$180,000.00
|
$198,000.00
|
$18,000.00
|
Less: Cash outlay on Purchases
|
$
-
|
$25,000.00
|
$25,000.00
|
$25,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$30,000.00
|
$135,000.00
|
$148,500.00
|
$13,500.00
|
Less:
Cash outlay on equipment purchase
|
$20,000.00
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$20,000.00
|
$22,000.00
|
$2,000.00
|
Utilities
|
$
-
|
$ -
|
$3,000.00
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$3,000.00
|
$6,000.00
|
$6,600.00
|
$600.00
|
Interest
|
$2,000.00
|
|
|
|
|
$1,000.00
|
$3,000.00
|
$3,300.00
|
$300.00
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
$0.00
|
$0.00
|
$0.00
|
Total
|
$52,000.00
|
$55,000.00
|
$58,000.00
|
$55,000.00
|
$60,000.00
|
$64,000.00
|
$344,000.00
|
$378,400.00
|
$34,400.00
|
Excess (deficiency)
|
($4,500.00)
|
$53,000.00
|
$50,000.00
|
$52,500.00
|
$52,500.00
|
$48,500.00
|
$252,000.00
|
$277,200.00
|
$25,200.00
|
Loan
|
$60,000.00
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$ -
|
$60,000.00
|
$66,000.00
|
$6,000.00
|
Ending Cash Balance
|
$55,500.00
|
$53,000.00
|
$50,000.00
|
$52,500.00
|
$52,500.00
|
$48,500.00
|
$312,000.00
|
$343,200.00
|
$31,200.00
|
Budgeted Income
Statement
Following table represents budgeted income statement for
next half of the fiscal year. In accordance to the calculated sales, expenses,
and cost, MD Company would have $70,800 as net income (excluding taxes).
Budgeted Income Statement
|
Sales
|
$ 310,000.00
|
CGS
|
$
51,200.00
|
Gross Margin
|
$
258,800.00
|
Selling and
Administrative Expenses
|
$ 180,000.00
|
Utilities
|
$
6,000.00
|
Operating Income
|
$
72,800.00
|
Interest Expense
|
$
2,000.00
|
Net Income
|
$
70,800.00
|
Budgeted Balance
Sheet
Budgeted balance sheet shows the financial position of MD Company
on 31 March, 2020.
Budgeted Balance Sheet
|
|
Non-Current Assets
|
$
61,000.00
|
Current Assets
|
$
85,500.00
|
Total Assets
|
$ 146,500.00
|
Equity and Liabilities
|
|
Ordinary Share capital ($100
per share)
|
$
81,500.00
|
budgeted closing stock
|
$
30,000.00
|
Reserves
|
$
2,000.00
|
Non-current Liabilities
|
|
10% loan notes
|
$
20,000.00
|
Current Liabilities
|
|
Accruals
|
$
7,000.00
|
Trade payables
|
$
6,000.00
|
Total Equity and Liabilities
|
$ 146,500.00
|
Analysis of master budgets shows that the cash budget is a
basis to calculate ending cash balance for a company that we mention on the
current assets section of the budgeted balance sheets. Cash budget also enables
the financial managers to develop further plans about the execution of the future
operations of the company (Bhagat, 2017). According to
evaluation, ending cash balance of the previous month was used as the beginning
cash flow of the next month. However, comparatively cash amount in the current
assets of the budgeted balance sheet is greater than the actual historical data
(balance sheets of 2019, 2018, and 2017)
Advantages and
Disadvantages of Planning Tools
1) Budgets
Budgets are developed in the organizations to plan assets
utilization, management of cash flows, and balancing cost in accordance with
the profit. Budget assist managerial staff members as a guideline to control
and manage the financial health of the company (Loughran,
2011).
There are some advantages and disadvantages associated with budgeting technique
which are detailed below:
Advantages:
·
The budget enables the managerial staff to see
how cost occurs.
·
Budget support is the forecasting of future
sales and profit.
·
The budget enables the management to MD Company
to set prices
·
Budget is also supportive of capital and credit
procurement.
Disadvantages:
·
Budget only concerns with the financial outcomes
of a company
·
The budget does not provide information about
uncertainties in the operational market.
2) Pricing:
Several pricing strategies are commonly in use of
organizations. Various kind of pricing strategies is psychology pricing, price
skimming, value pricing, and penetration pricing. Advantages and disadvantages
linked to pricing strategies are presented below:
Advantages:
·
Appropriate pricing strategies can enable MD
company to win in the competitive market
·
Selection of right pricing strategies build
customer equity for MD Company
Disadvantages:
·
A wrong selection of pricing strategy can cause
failure in the targeted market.
3) Strategic Planning Tools
Strategic planning tools assist
managerial staff members to develop better organizational policies and
strategies concerning with the future operations of the company. Strategic
planning tools include balanced scorecards, SWOT analysis, and PESTLE analysis, porter 5 model and
balance scorecard. In this case scenario, only two strategic planning
tools are explained and analyzed in details.
1. PESTLE Analysis
PESTLE analysis is based on 6 major external
environment-related factors which can draw an impact on the business outcomes
and profitability of a company. The analysis shows that Political, Economic,
Social, Technological, Legal and Environmental factors can bring change in the
customer market of MD company thus the company would have chances of both increase
and decrease in the sales. A PESTLE analysis has some advantages and
disadvantages while we use such strategic planning tools for MD Company for
budgetary control. Some key advantages and disadvantages are enlisted below:
Advantages:
a)
It provides information about possible risk
factors associated with economic development in the targeted market which can
influence sales positively or negatively.
b)
It provides information about the political
policies that need to be considered in the planning stage before investing in a
project.
Disadvantages:
a)
PESTLE analysis only provide information about
the external environment
b)
PESTLE analysis does not provide numerical and
quantitative information that can assist in the budgeting process at MD
Company.
2. SWOT Analysis
SWOT analysis represents the situation of the internal and
external environment for MD Company. Managerial staff can use this kind of
information to ensure accuracy and authenticity in the future organizational
plans and budgets for operations execution. SWOT analysis has some advantages
and disadvantages for budgeting and strategic planning which are enlisted
below:
Advantages:
a)
It provides information about gaps in
improvement in the internal operations and environment of the company.
b)
It provides information about intangible assets
and supportive factors (such as reputation, employee productivity, customer
loyalty and goodwill) that can draw an impact on future sales of the company.
Disadvantages:
a)
SWOT analysis provides limited information about
competitive forces and customer market trends.
3. Balance score
card
A balanced scorecard managed
efficiently by the MD Company for the better management of the product. Balance
scorecard strategies can help the company to monitor the strategies related to
strategic planning. Effective management accountants should be trained for
revenue growth, long-term survival, efficient calculation of the operating
income, customer perspective, etc. Moreover, these strategies can bring
management better accounting skills sets under the semi-standard structured
report as consequences arising can be monitored and enterprise can understand
the efficiency and effectiveness of internal business procedures.
4. Porter 5 model
a) Threat of
substitutes
There is the threat of substitute
products to the MD Company as the substitute products have attractive prices or
better quality and thus the customers can switch from one product as they can
switching from car to bicycle when they get good or better resell options.
b) Rivalry among
existing competitors
It is a profitable industry so
there is an intense rivalry among existing competitors and the market share is
aggressive because of the high exit barriers and products that are not
differentiated. The competitors have equal size and also in the industry, there
is low customer loyalty.
Learning Objective: 4
Ratios of MD
Company
Ratio analysis provides information about the financial
strength and health of the company in the specified period usually a fiscal
year. In the following table, ratio analysis of MD Company is presented. The
following information is based on the budgeted financial statements for the
next half year (ended at 31 March 2020) of MD Company (Brigham &
Houston, 2012).
Ratios
for financial year
|
2018
|
2017
|
Gross
profit ratio
|
0.36
|
0.375
|
Operating
profit margin
|
0.18325
|
0.240714
|
Current
ratio
|
4.576923
|
4.5
|
Quick
ratio
|
3.423077
|
3.509434
|
Gearing
ratio
|
-7.33
|
-13.48
|
According to the ratio analysis liquidity
situation of MD Company is strong because of great contribution by cash in the
current assets of the company. Liquidity ratios such as current ratio and quick
ratios are greeter than benchmarking ratios of average competitors and
historical ratios of MD Company. Quick ratio shows that the company had limited
attention given to the inventory and stocking. Although, profit margin ratio
and operating margin ratio represents the profitability of MD Company regarding
future operations (Minterellison.com, 2016). The analysis shows
that the gross profit ratio and an operating ratio of MD Company are 0.83 and
0.23 which are below the gross profit and operating profit margin ratio of
companies similar to MD Company. The difference in the average (benchmark
ratio) and calculated ratios of MD Company present variance level. The analysis
shows that ratios calculated for MD Company half-year performance and similar company’s
performance ratios have variance at a large scale. Conclusively ratio analysis and
variance indicate that MD Company needs to bring changes in the business and
asset management strategies to ensure high efficiency of asset and working
capital utilization in the company for the execution of business
operations.
Management
Accounting Skill Sets
In this section, management accounting and characteristics
of an effective accountant are discussed in reference to the case scenario of
MD Company. Here characteristics of an effective accountant are presented:
1)
Effective management account keeps competence to
use knowledge about accounts appropriately.
2)
Provide assistance to the decision-making
process on the basis of logical reasoning
3)
Performance all-important duties in MD Company
while following law and regulations.
4)
Work with integrity and loyalty to the MD
Company.
5)
Only follow up with credible information and
disclose relevant information with stakeholders
6)
Communicate confidently in front of stakeholders
(including investors and shareholder) about the policies of MD Company.
a) Financial Governance
Financial governance is the
governing bodies who concerns with the financial details of the company. Financial
governance of MD Company has a board who deals with the legal, financial, and
moral responsibilities of the company (lexicon.ft.com, 2018). Board of governance
develops strategies to ensure fair and accurate financial information presented
to the shareholders and investors by encouraging internal and external audit
system in MD Company. Financial governance is usually given names such as an
executive committee, the board of governance, and executive’s council. Financial
governance in MD Company ensures that funds to be used in the company are
utilized for the benefit of organizational beneficiaries and stakeholders. They
evaluate financial details and funds details to check that MD Company has
enough funds for business operations. They also develop plans to get funding
from external sources in case funds available in the company are unable to meet
future requirements of production and operations department. Financial governance
also has responsibilities in the MD Company to check and monitor internal and
external auditing reports. They monitor organizational operations and
efficiency of assets utilization as they are accountable to the stakeholders
and beneficiaries of MD Company.
b) Management Accounting Skills Sets
Management accounting skills set in MD Company is based on
five major skills which are presented below:
1)
Decision Making Skills: Management accounting
requires skills to manage and understand risk factors, develop suitable
alternatives, and find out the best course of action or mitigation strategy.
Effective decision-making skills increase chances of better risk
management.
2)
Leadership Skills: Management accounting also
require leadership skills to lead and collaborate with other colleagues and
team members at MD Company to avoid conflict and ensure better performance
outcomes.
3)
Operations skills:Accountants working the
finance and accounts department must-have skills about the operations of
accounts department including the recording of sales data, expense management,
and budgeting plans.
4)
Technology skills:Appropriate technological
skills are essential to understand advanced accounts recording system in
databases and analysis of big data for the decision making process.
5)
Planning and Reporting Skills:The basic
requirement of management accounting skills set is the acquisition of planning
and reporting skills. It concerns with the evaluation of financial details and
performance to develop future plans and current financial reports of the MD
Company.
c) Effective Strategies and System
Effective strategies and system are essential for the future
better performance of MD Company. Management of the company has
responsibilities to bring changes in the organizational system and strategies
for the improvement of business operations and profitability outcomes. In MD
Company, the managerial staff is focused on corporate social responsibilities
(CSR) related strategies and fair accounts treatment system to build a
trustworthy relationship with investors and get secure opportunities for future
funding.
d) Development of Strategies and Systems
Development of effective strategies of communication and
application of international standards of auditing and financial reports
presentation can support MD Company to accomplish their business goals. However,
for this purpose management need to have a critical evaluation of each strategy
prior to its implementation in the company. Development of risk mitigation
strategy in the light of information about the likelihood of occurrence and
impact of the risk factor on MD Company enables the company to ensure secure
business operations. Concerning with successful management of MD company are
also required to develop strategies and system about timely reporting,
disclosure of financial details, and other key audit matters of the
company.
Conclusion of
MD Co.
The whole discussion concludes that
MD Company has strong market equity and chances of an increase in future
profitability. Managerial staff and financial governance of the company are
concerned with the improvement of financial position and increase in
profitability while keeping in mind the benefits and advantages to the
stakeholders and beneficiaries of MD Company. Characteristics of effective management
accountant include integrity, confidence, leadership, knowledge, and loyalty to
the company. Some important skills for management accounting relate to
technological skills, leadership skills, and decision-making skills. Financial
analysis including master budget analysis, ratio analysis, and variance
conclude that company need to focus on improvement in asset utilization and
asset management. Moreover, MD Company
need to focus on the selection of right strategic planning tool to develop a
more realistic budget.
Bebbington, J., Gray, R., & Laughlin, R. (2001).
Financial Accounting: Practice and Principles. Cengage Learning EMEA.
Retrieved 2019
Bhagat, S. (2017).Financial Crisis, Corporate
Governance, and Bank Capital. Cambridge University Press.
Brigham, E. F., & Houston, J. F. (2012). Fundamentals
of Financial Management. Cengage Learning, 8 серп.
lexicon.ft.com. (2018). Corporate Social
Responsibility (CSR) Definition from the Financial Times. Retrieved from
lexicon.ft.com:
http://lexicon.ft.com/Term?term=corporate-social-responsibility--(CSR)
Loughran, M. (2011). Financial Accounting For
Dummies. John Wiley & Sons. Retrieved 2019
Minterellison.com. (2016). Federal Court Finding
that Storm Financial Directors Breached Their Duties. Retrieved from
www.minterellison.com:
https://www.minterellison.com/articles/federal-court-finding-that-storm-financial-directors-breached-their-duties