In general, there are
significant differences between coaching and mentoring. Some of the differences
are as follow:
Coaching
|
Mentoring
|
Relationship between the coach
and individual has a specific duration.
|
Relationship is ongoing and it
can last for a long period.
|
It is usually more structured
in terms of nature and meetings are regularly scheduled.
|
It can be informal and some
meetings can also take place according to the requirements of mentee.
|
Generally, coaching is not
carried out based on the needs of coach for having a direct experience of
occupational role of the client unless coaching is skills-focused and
specific.
|
In contrast, a mentor is more
qualified and experienced than the mentee. And often a senior employee is
chosen as the mentor for passing on information and knowledge.
|
Generally, focus is on issues
and development at work.
|
The focus is on personal
development and career.
|
Meanwhile, the agenda is
concerned with achieving immediate and specific goals.
|
Mentee sets the agenda and
both guidance and support are provided by the mentor for preparing them for
future responsibilities and duties.
|
Coaching is concerned with
more specific issues and development areas.
|
It is concerned with the
development of professional career of the mentee.
|
The
same can be said about other L&D methods as well as they are long-term
activities and aimed at the career development of a person. Meanwhile, coaching
can focus on other aspects as well like issues faced by the person.
Descriptions of 3 different
types of coaching and 2 different styles of coaching.
The three types of coaching
include:
·
Executive Coaching: This
type of coaching tends to focus on assisting senior leaders within a firm in
improving their personal performance and leadership. It can enable an executive
to have a specific thinking space to concentrate and focus on some specific
issues.
·
Leadership Coaching: Leadership
coaching generally has the objective of helping leaders in improving their
leadership skills and capabilities. The coach often has more experience and
knowledge than the leaders who need improvement in their abilities.
·
Career Coaching: In
this area, a coach is focused specifically on the career development of the
person. He is likely to utilize a diversity of skills such as mentoring,
consulting, and advising in helping the individual in getting additional
insights (David Megginson, 2005).
Meanwhile,
two different coaching styles include:
Autocratic:
In
such a style, decisions are made by coaches and individuals have to follow the
orders. The control is solely practiced by the coach.
Democratic:
It
is quite different from the autocratic style as it is focused on shared
decision making and control. Perspectives of participants are also valued in
this style. This is a common type of coaching style as it results in better
outcomes and innovation.
An analysis of the stages
in a one-to-one coaching process and the roles of coach and coachee.
The
stages in a one-to-one coaching process include:
Analyzing:
The
first stage is concerned with collecting and interpreting the data of a
coachee. Unique habits and issues are identified for ensuring that coaching
intervention can be effective.
Preparing:
The
second stage is all about setting the objective of coaching session, focusing
on behaviors of the coachee in each meeting, planning the interaction, and anticipating
the objections. The required feedback is also planned which has to be delivered
to the coachee.
Conducting:
At
this stage, questions are asked for opening the dialogue and sharing both
ingihts and perspectives. In addition to it, it also involves extensive
communication between both the coach and coachee to ensure that issues are not
faced by the coachee.
Documenting:
In
this stage, measureable goals are set and specific steps are chosen for further
improving the performance of coachee (Renton, 2010).
Following
Up: The last stage is all about reviewing and repeating if an
issue needs more attention.
A
coach has a role similar to that of a mentor and he/she assists a coachee in
reaching his full potential or resolving an issue. Meanwhile, a coachee is the
person or apprentice who requires the assistance of coach to explore his skills
or resolve an issue.
An explanation of the
potential benefits of coaching for coach and coachee.
Following are the benefits
of coaching for a coach:
·
It will enable a fuller utilization of
potential and talents of the coach.
·
Helps him to learn new things through
different experience of the individuals
·
Also helps him to increase personal
learning skills and development
·
Through coaching the individual is able
to enhance skills regarding achieving goals and targets
·
Moreover, the person is able to gain
the ability to identify a new solution for the issues
·
Furthermore, the person is also
improving its self-awareness skills by communicating and training
·
The person is also able to communicate
in a more efficient way with others
·
The person is also able to contribute
to different activities in a proper way
·
The person is also able to act more
positively in achieving different goals
·
Also, the individual is able to enhance
his social skills
·
It can be noted that coaching is a safe
place to increase perspective (Parsloe & Leedham, 2009)
·
One of the huge advantages of coaching
is that it will help the coach to increase his deeper level of learning new
things.
·
It will also help the individual to
enhance specific skills that will change the nature.
·
With coaching the individual is able to
identify high-quality skills in their employees
An explanation of the
concept of mentoring and the nature of the relationship between mentor and
mentee
The concept of mentoring is
quite unique. It is the main process in which an experienced member of the
organization is assigned to give a demonstration to an inexperienced member of
the organization and trained that individual according to the nature of the
organization. It is also one of the most important forms of teaching in which
an individual check and analyze the performance of his team that is working in
the organization (David Megginson, 2005).
Moreover, in many
organizations, there are some mentoring programs that are only designed for
promoting the performance of their employees.
Relationship between mentor and mentee
This
can be explained through the help of a simple explanation, and the mentor is
that person now has the ability to train mentee. Therefore the mentor is the
main gate for the success of the mentee. If any mentee wanted to gain success
and honor in his life, then he must have to give proper and absolute respect to
his mentor. The mentor is the person that is involved in giving proper
direction to the mentee. On the other hand, the mentee is able to gain proper
knowledge from the mentor to gain proper success in his life. The mentor
relationship must contain such elements as personal connection and shared
values.
Descriptions of a typical
mentoring process and the roles of mentor and mentee
The
mentoring process is quite simple in that process. There are about five main
steps. In the first step, the mentor needs to understand the mentee in a proper
way. He has a sound knowledge about mentee. In the next step, the mentor will
work on shaping the main goals for the mentee. Moreover, in the next step, the
mentee has to check out the daily progress of its mentee and also highlight its
main mistakes. In the fourth step, the mentor has to give proper feedback on
the progress of the mentee and give essential suggestions for the future. In
the last step, he just has to conclude the main goals of the mentor (Western, 2012).
Roles of mentor and mentee
·
There are a lot of roles of mentor and
mentee some of them are given in the section below
·
Mentee roles
·
The mentee has to take proper charge on
its personal development
·
The mentee also has to carry out all
tasks in an essential way
·
The mentee should able to reflect and
relate his own skills
·
Mentee also has to listen to its mentor
Role of mentor
·
He has to create positive counseling
for his mentee
·
He also has to work on the professional
growth of his mentee.
An
explanation of the potential benefits of mentoring for mentor and mentee
There
are some potential benefits of mentee and mentor that are given below
Mentee’s benefits
·
He is able to gain practical advice for
supporting and encouragement.
·
He is also able to learn a different
kind of things through experiences.
·
He is also able to enhance his personal
skills
·
Being a mentee, he can easily improve
his academic and social skills for the future
·
The mentee is also able to increase his
communication skills and his confidence
·
He can easily identify different goals
and also work for achieving
·
He is also able to make new friend and
groups with others
·
He is able to solve different problems
regarding studies
Mentor’s benefits
·
The mentor is able to increase its
personal skills
·
He can easily enhance his communication
skills
·
One of the major advantages of being a
mentor is that he can easily develop leadership and management skills.
·
It will be easy for that person to
enhance his confidence and motivation.
·
A mentor is also able to gain benefits
from enhancing his personal growth.
·
He can easily increase the main circle
of his friends.
·
The mentor is able to enhance his CV in
a proper way (Parsloe & Leedham, 2009).
Explanations of 2 models
and 2 techniques which can be used in coaching and mentoring and how these can
support individual learning
The
two main models of coaching and mentoring are Grow and Fuel model
Grow model
It
consists of 4 parts in which
G =
Goal
R
=Reality
O =
Options
W =
Will
This
is also one of the most important models for coaching. At the start of the
model, the organization looked for the main objectives and then after this, and
they will analyze these objectives for checking its reality. After this, they
worked for the main obstacles that are present in it, and the last stage of
this model will figure out the main processes and other things that will help
to carry out the project.
Fuel model
This
model also consists of four main stages. In the first one the coaches are involved
in farming the main conversation with the mentees in detail. Through this, they
can be easily able to analyze the need for required training for achieving the
objective.
Techniques
The
two main techniques that are used by the mentor and coaches are
Devising
of clear goals of the organization that contain deadlines and benchmarks
The
next technique is related to time management, and the coaches must be prepared
according to the situation and also react properly (Renton, 2010).
Part 1
Provide a short introduction to the
organization
According
to the situation, the HR director of the organization is wanted to apply a new
HR strategy for the next 12 months. In that case, she wanted to identify one
team that can easily able to handle these tasks in a perfect way. She just
wanted to train her team so that they are able to support the anticipated
change in the organization. According to that, she has assigned me an important
task that is related to the development of the team. For that, there is a need
for proper research that can easily able to develop some important resources
and also support away day for the HR team. There are also some important tasks
in the away day that are related to change in the organization. The HR department
of the organization just needs to adopt these new changes and also support
their employees according to it. The main task is that the HR department has to
train its employees according to the change process in the organization. the
reason is that through this training it would be quite easy for the employee to
adopt such changes in an effective way.
Refer to at least 6
factors (this must include both internal and external factors) that explain why
organisations need to change
There
are 6 factors that will give proper information about why there is a need to
change process in the organization. All of these factors may be related to
internal and external
Control
This
is the first factor because things were going out of control, and the
organization is unable the meet the demand of the customers so this is why
there is a need to change process.
New technologies
In the
world of technology, many companies are adopting new technologies regarding new
software applications or machines for carrying out all tasks in a proper way.
Crises
The
next factor is related to the crises, the organization is dealing with some
problem, and that can be solved through the help of the change process.
Pressure
Another
important factor is related to the market pressure. The HR director has a sense
of huge market pressure. Due to this, she had applied new changes in the
management system of the organization so such problems can be minimized easily.
Time management
There
were a lot of problems that occurred due to bad time management due to this
there is a need to change process so such risks can be minimized easily.
Organizational climate
There
is a need to change the climate of the organization (Beerel, 2009).
Identify 3 ways that your
organisation might be impacted by these changes, referring to models as
appropriate
There
are many ways through which the organization is able to impact changes in the
organization.
From
them, there is some important model for the change in the organization are
explained in a proper way.
McKinsey 7 S model
This
is one of the most important models for change in management. This model
consists of six important stages. The first stage is related to the strategy.
In that stage, there is a need to plan the change that is going to implement in
that organization. Now in the next stage, there is a need to make a proper
structure of the plan. Then implement some system and shared values for
carryout the main tasks. The last two stages consist of style and staffing.
Kotter’s change management theory
This
model is one of the most used in many organizations when there is a need for
any change management. The main idea behind this model is related to
management. It will help the organization to apply any change in an effective
way.
Lewin’s change management model
It is
also a popular and most used model in organizations. The main reason is that
through this model, it would be quite easy to make some changes and also able
to understand the main culture of the organization.
Explain four factors that
will be involved in the change process
There
are a lot of factors that are included in the change management, but according
to the nature of the organization.
From
them, one of the most important factors is related to the active executive
support in the organization. , working on a change in the management system.
For that case, if the HR department of the organization is active enough, so
this department is able to implement any kind of change in a perfect way.
Moreover, due to this factor, it will be quite easy for the organization to
carry out different functions.
The
next factor is changing management leadership. If this factor is strong, then
it will be extremely easy to implement any kind of change in the organization.
The reason is that high-quality leadership will high-quality with all tasks in
an effective way and also helps the organization to carry out all tasks.
Moreover, if the leadership is powerful, then there will be no mistakes while
completing different tasks (Reiss, 2012).
Another
factor is dealing with the engagement of employees in supporting the change. If
the employee of the company is active and also sincere, then it will be for
them to implement any change in the organization. The main reason is that
active employees are always working according to the requirement of the
organization. Therefore, they will support that change and work efficiently.
The
last factor is ideal communication with the employees. This means that if the
member of the organization is involved in effective management through
communication so any change can be implemented easily. In that case, the
organization must have to give proper information about the change with the
best way of communication. This will help the employees to deal with any kind
of change in a proper way (Frank Voehl, 2017).
Explain and compare 3
different approaches your organisation could take in managing change and the
approach to change management you would recommend for your own organisation
There
are about three different approaches through which the organization is able to
manage any kind of change in the organization. The three approaches are tools,
turnaround, and transformation. If there is any need for an internal change
management system of the organization, then they focus on the turnaround. The
reason is that this approach only deals with internal management change. The
main reason is that this approach is able to manage any change in an efficient
way for welfare if the organization.
Moreover,
there are many organizations that are using tools and techniques to implement
any change. These kinds of tools are helping organizations to apply any change
in a successful way. This is because, through these tools, it would be quite
easy to manage the change.
Furthermore,
the next approach is related to the transformation of implementing change in
the organization. This is because it is just targeting the main behavior of the
employee and also increase their capabilities that will help him to achieve the
main goal of the organization. Also, it can be seen that this approach is
overlapping with the implementation of tools for the change in the
organization. Moreover, turnaround is also overlapping with transformation (Little, 2014).
Part B
Describe 3 different
behavioural responses seen when change takes place in an organisation
In
many organizations there are many employees that are not agree with any kind of
change in the organization. The main reason is that they don’t want any kind of
change in the organization. From them, one of the huge and common behavior
responses of the employee is related to their anger. There are many employees
that get angry after any change in the organization. Some of them get
frustrated after the change and started work with an upset mood. Most of them
tried to overreact and also take work stress after that particular change. Due to this anger, they thought that due to
such action, their job might be getting into danger.
After
this, their next response is related to started make gossip about that change
in the management. The reason is that they are not agreeing with that change
and also no accepting that change in the organization. Therefore, they started
to talk about that change in a proper way. They started to talk about the
issues related to this change and also how they are able to control that change
in the organization. Many employees were talking about the new change in the
organization, and they decided how this change will represent the nature of
their work.
The
next thing is that the employees of the organization try to resist that change.
This kind of behavior response is extremely common in most of the organization.
The main reason is that they are not trying to accept this change. They thought
that it would lead the individual towards failure. The employee of the
organization thought that they might be lost face a lot of failure after the
implementation of that change. Also, they thought this change might harm their
personality and also their future condition of their job. Therefore, they
started to show rude behavior in the organization and also not agreed with the
term and condition of the change. In some organizations, there are such
employees that started turnover after the change in management. Many employees
leave the organization after that particular change because they don’t want to
take any kind of job stress (Frank Voehl, 2017).
Explain 3 ways that HR can
support individuals during change
There
are different ways through which the HR department of the organization is able
to help its employees to adopt these changes in a proper way. From them, these
three ways are discussed in the below section
Addressing issues
In
that case, the HR department has to listen to all issues regarding the change
in management. For that, the HR department has to create a proper paper for the
employees in which they will mention all issues. Then after this, this
department has to analyze these issues in an efficient way. When this
department is able to figure out these problems after the change, then they
must have to work on solving these issues regarding these changes. The HR
department has to work on the changes in a proper way so that there will be no
pressure on the employee regarding that change (Beerel, 2009).
Enhancing communication
The HR
department has to increase the level of communication with their employees. The
reason is that the employees are not satisfied with the change in management in
the organization. There must be a lot of problems with the employees regarding
the changes. Such problems can be minimized easily after successful
communication. This department has to communicate with each employee of the
organization and relates its main problems regarding the new system. After
listening to these issues, then this department has to solve this problem with
effective communication. If the level of communication is high, then it will be
quite easy for the organization to implement any kind of change in the
organization.
Training
This
is one of the best ways to implement any change in the organization. The HR
department must have to give proper training to their employees after the
change. The main reason is that through this training, they can easily adopt
any change in the organization.
The
main problem is that the implementation of training is not simple for this
department. The main reason is that the HR department has to plan the training
in a proper way. Then after this, the HR department has to make a proper
schedule for conducting the training by consulting the employees. Then after
this, this department must have to analyze the performance of their employees.
They have to divide this training into different parts, and according to that,
they have to check the main progress of their employees. There are some
employees that are weak in the training the HR department has to work with them
and solve their problems (Little, 2014).
References
on an
explanation of the concept of coaching and how it differs from mentoring and
other L&D methods.
Alfes, K., & Catherine Truss, a. J. (2010). The HR
manager as change agent: Evidence from the public sector. Journal of change
management .
Beerel, A. (2009). Leadership and
Change Management. SAGE.
David Megginson, D. C. (2005). Techniques
for Coaching and Mentoring. Routledge.
Frank Voehl, H. J. (2017). Change
Management: Manage the Change or It Will Manage You. CRC Press.
Little, J. (2014). Lean Change
Management: Innovative Practices for Managing Organizational Change. Amazon
Digital Services LLC - Kdp Print Us.
Millar, C., & Patricia Hind, A. v.
(2012). Change agent sensemaking for sustainability in a multinational
subsidiary. Journal of Organizational Change Management.
Parsloe, E., & Leedham, M. (2009). Coaching
and Mentoring: Practical Conversations to Improve Learning. Kogan Page
Publishers.
Reiss, M. (2012). Change Management: A
Balanced and Blended Approach. BoD – Books on Demand.
Renton, J. (2010). The Economist:
Coaching and Mentoring. Profile Books.
Western, S. (2012). Coaching and
Mentoring: A Critical Text. SAGE.