In this paper, both secondary and
primary research approaches have been considered for collecting the information
and answering the research questions. Secondary methods include literature
reviews while primary research approaches include the implementation of tools
such as SWOT and Fishbone analysis. The fishbone diagram will be utilized for
analyzing the organization and determining the root causes of the issue faced
by the firm. In addition to the use of fishbone analysis, SWOT analysis will
also be utilized. This analysis will help in determining the strengths,
threats, opportunities, and weaknesses which might be faced by the institute (Gray, 2014).
3.1 Research Philosophy of Oman College of Health
Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
In this paper,
interpretivism philosophy has been considered because it helps in analyzing an
issue in the light of existing information and concepts. In addition to it,
interpretivism is considered the most suitable approach for secondary research.
Although primary research is also considered, it doesn’t include statistics
which means that positivism wouldn’t be appropriate for this research (Davoudi, 2012).
3.2 Research Approach of Oman College of Health
Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
In this paper,
inductive research approach has been considered because it is the most
appropriate research approach for supporting qualitative research. Considering
the fact that deductive research approach wouldn’t have been more suitable for
this research because it is used for qualitative researches, this approach has been
utilized (Soiferman, 2010).
3.3 SWOT Analysis of Oman College of Health
Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
SWOT analysis is
considered one of the most important and simple techniques which can help in
analyzing the environment of an organization. It can help in determining the
internal issues which are faced by the organization. Even though there are many
other tools which can be considered in conducting the research, most of the
tools can only help in identifying the external issues while other tools are
excessively time-consuming. SWOT is one of the simplest and less time-consuming
tools or methods for identifying the issues and opportunities which might be faced
by a firm. One of the most important reasons for choosing this tool is that it
is quite simple and consumes only a little time to determine the issues which
are being experienced by an organization (Phadermrod, Crowder, & Wills, 2016).
3.4 Fishbone Analysis of Oman College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Fishbone analysis is
concerned with drawing the fishbone diagram while analyzing different aspects
of the business for identifying the underlying reasons of a specific problem.
For instance, at the moment, the Oman College of Health Sciences has been
determined to face the issue of employee dissatisfaction and this is
influencing the performance of the institute. Fishbone diagram or Ishikawa
diagram is one of the most simples and time-efficient methods of identifying
the reasons due to which issues are being encountered by organizations. In the
fishbone analysis, there are different sections for different organizational
aspects. Generally, there are six sections in the fishbone analysis and these
sections include machines, methods, environment, personnel, materials, and
measurements. (Venkateswaran, 2018)
These categories have
different processes and functions which are classified under these sections and
it helps in not only analyzing different organizational aspects but also
classifying them in such a way that it becomes easier for the management to identify
the issues and categorizing it. As explained above, simplicity is one of the
most important reasons due to which this tool has been considered in this
research. (Ali Suba'a Al-sadi, 2018)
For instance, if there
is an issue with the evaluation of different processes. If it has been
determined that employees have been underperforming, there are two
possibilities which stem from this situation. It is possible that employees are
not satisfied with their job, similar to the situation which is being faced by
the Oman College of Health Sciences. In such a situation, the issue will be
classified under the category of personnel because the problem is associated
with employees. There is also a significant possibility that maybe employees
are performing properly and it is the measurement method which is not efficient
enough. In such a case, the issue will be classified under the category of
methods because the issue exists with how a process is being carried out.
If there is an issue with
how different machines are operating in the organization, the issue will be
categorized under machines because it is a technical issue and involves
machines. In most of the organizations which produce different products, there
is always a possibility that an issue might occur in the part of machinery
because one cannot predict when an issue or fault might occur. In such a case,
the identified issue will be classified under the heading of machines. It will
help in differentiating the issue from other issues in the organization. It
will also help in customizing the approach in such a manner that t addresses
only this issue and not the other issue which is not considered important.
If there is an issue
with the raw materials of a product then the issue will be classified under
materials. (Alhatmi, 2010)Let’s consider a situation when a
company is unable to meet the quality standards What
because of faulty raw materials. In such a situation, the issue lies in
the raw materials and it will be categorized under the materials. This is one
of the most important issues for all those organizations which specialize in
producing different types of products, especially bakery items.
There are two types of
environments to which an organization is exposed including internal environment
and external environment. Both of these environments are capable of influencing
the organization and its operations. If there is an issue in the working
environment of the firm then it will be considered a problem with the internal
environment. However, if there is an issue with the legal policies then it will
be considered a problem with the external environment of the organization. (Cheng, 2011)
Once the issues have
been classified, it allows the management to take effective measures against
the issues and resolve them. Thus, it wouldn’t be wrong to say that the most
important reason why this tool has been chosen for problem analysis is its
time-efficiency and simplicity (Coccia, 2018).
4.0 Discussions of
Oman College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Fishbone diagram of Oman College of Health Sciences
and Job Dissatisfaction
Figure.1
Strength
|
Weaknesses
|
Oman College of Health Sciences works understand the Ministry of
Health. It provides the institute with a clear vision, objectives, and legal
protection. Some other benefits are also offered to it.
|
There is a lack of motivation of employees.
In addition to it, training is insufficient and some policies need to be
improved. The last weakness of the institute is that it doesn’t involve
employees in making decisions.
|
Opportunity
|
Threats
|
There is a plan for expanding the structure
of the institute which can help in providing a better working environment to
employees and the staff. It can serve to create new employment opportunities
and financial incentives. Ultimately, it can positively influence the
satisfaction of employees.
|
Sultan Qaboos University which operates
under the Ministry of Higher Education poses a threat to the Oman College of
Health Sciences. Some other private health colleges also pose a threat to the
institution. Therefore, effective measures have to be taken to ensure that
the institute is profitable and feasible in the market.
|
Table 1
From the analyses and literature, following causes of
job dissatisfaction have been identified in the Oman College of Health Sciences:
Bad Working condition of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
One of the most important things
which cause employees to be dissatisfied is the inadequate working space for
employees. If employees are not comfortable while working, it means that they
are certainly not satisfied with the job. For instance, in a single office, if
eight or more than eight employees are present, it will cause them discomfort.
It is also possible that they might lose their motivation to work. It has been determined
inconvenient working conditions can cause an employee to be dissatisfied with
his job because he wouldn’t be able to work in an efficient manner (Shrm.org, 2015).
Inadequate Space Utilization
It has been determined that when each and every
employee has sufficient enough space to work efficiently, employees not only
feed satisfied but they are able to work effectively. If an organization wants
to utilize the talents of employee in the most optimum manner, it is important
for the firm to ensure that sufficient enough space is provided to employees in
which they can perform their tasks without experiencing inconvenience (Kansaigaidai.ac.jp, 2018).
Poor
Lighting of Oman College of Health Sciences and Job
Dissatisfaction
When it comes to working conditions, an
important aspect is lighting. For instance, lighting in workplace can both
increase the efficiency of employees and decrease it as well. The right
intensity of lighting is capable of making employees perform their tasks in an
optimum manner. For instance, it is possible that if there is insufficient
lighting or excessive lighting in the workplace, employees might not be able to
work efficiently. Thus, it is important for the organization to choose the most
comfortable and suitable lighting intensity. If Oman College of Health Sciences
is considered, the electrical infrastructure was developed approximately
twenty-five years ago. It means that it should be replaced and lighting
intensity should be made suitable for the staff (Garrick, 2012).
Inefficient Workplace Processes
Another
important issue that causes the employees to be dissatisfied with their job is
because of the constant workplace processes. With time, there is a significant
need of change or evolution in the processes and procedures of how a specific
work is performed. There has to be innovation in a workplace with time as it
helps in keeping employees interested in performing their tasks. However, there
has been no innovation in Oman College of Health Sciences due to which the
staff is not satisfied (Jeon & Choi, 2012).
A Lack of Workplace Flexibility and Balance
Another important reason why employees might
not be satisfied with the job is because of lack of flexible within the
workplace. For instance, employees have to perform their tasks within the time
limit of 7am to 2pm on a daily basis. In addition to following the same routine
on a daily basis, employees don’t get the opportunity to spend some time to
themselves. They are not offered holidays and due to it, their motivation is
low. It has been determined that when employee motivation is low, it adversely
influences their job satisfaction (Kabungaidze, Mahlatshana, & Ngirande, 2013).
Discrimination of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Another important and one of the common causes
of job dissatisfaction is discrimination at the workplace. It has a significant
negative effect on the job satisfaction of an employee. In some severe cases,
it can even cause the employee to leave the job permanently. In general,
workplace discrimination is the process of treating an employee in a different
manner from others. It can be based on the race of the employee and it can
adversely influence the job satisfaction of a person. Although it is a common reason
of job dissatisfaction, it hasn’t been identified to exist in Oman College of
Health Sciences. (Fevre, Grainger and Brewer,
2010).
Age Discrimination of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
In age, discrimination
restriction would be made when an employee croos the age above from 45 years;
at this stage, a person has to lose his right to apply for scholarships that
were guranted by government or any institution (Kansaigaidai.ac.jp, 2018).
Gender Discrimination of
Oman College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Gender Discrimination can be made
for females instead of males because this would meet the demands of females
more than males.
National Origin of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
National Origin has also existed,
but in a weak situation, the owners of the homeland had the precedence in the
progress of higher studies (Kazmi & Ahmad, 2001).
2Nepotism of Oman College of
Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
The problem can also be occur and
compounded by the institutions where the office workers of the institute favor
an employee because the reason is they were friends.
Low Motivation of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Low motivation would have
occurred when employees lose the hope and desire to do work or to complete the
given task, and then they felt that they no more belonged to any institution
where they were working, and they show a lack of interest in their work. It can
be determined as awful for institute, and this would result in negative aspects
and negative behaviors, low performances with lower productivity, contempt
comments and warnings (Lee, Lee, & Kang, 2012).
Public criticism of employees of
Oman College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
The condemnation of the one
employee in front of other workers would be counterproductive, and this has
antagonistic behavior to some of the managers’ trust that identification of
errors averts the reappearance of the previous mistake, but frequently given in
the state of disinclination and defeat to work (Mello, 2014).
Non-Hounring Creative thinking of
Oman College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
When an employee provides his
idea related to any project in the company and organization refuses or rejected
by the institution or ignored by official of the organization, this will damage
the thinking of the employee, and the employee may feel frustrated, and this
will help lad to the employee toward lowest-productivity.
Not granting powers of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Non-grating powers can restrict
the employee, to limit their abilities, intrusive with all tasks which were
assigned to him, without giving any space to handle these mistakes, and limited
the possibility of creative thinking to the employees (Mukherjee, 2012).
Lack of financial incentives of
Oman College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Financial inducements were the
most important motivation which encourages the system, absence of incentives
harmed employees And lack of financial resources can lead an institution toward
failure. And non-reward of employees for clean effort done and stay ay rewarded
to solve their problem. All these problems can lead to an unwilling initiative
for the future (Naseem, Sheikh, & Malik, 2011).
Lack of training of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
The deficiency of staff’s
training can cause lower production, disappointment, defficency of creative
thinking, and absence of self-development can lead an institution toward lower
productivity of the organization, to enhance the productivity employees need
training in specific to improve their abilities (Sageer, Rafat, & Agarwal, 2012).
Lack of awareness of the
importance of staff training of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Deficiency of management
awareness is quite an essential part of the training, and this could weaken the
progress of human resource development strategy in the average to long term
strategy, and this will lead to a lack of preparation.
Employees not insured by training of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Another important
factor due to which employees experience job dissatisfaction is concerned with
their disinterest in training. The staff doesn’t want to be trained because
they are not aware of the benefits which they might obtain by undergoing the
programs which are aimed at enhancing their skills and capabilities.
Lack of parallel training for staff of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Parallel training is not provided to employees
and that is another important factor due to which employees are not satisfied
with their job. This policy has to be improved for ensuring that employees
develop an interest in training and become active in participating in such
programs.
Lack of specialized training programs in some
areas
There are some specific areas which require
some specific skills. For instance, there might be a task which can be
performed only by some specific employees. In order to make employees acquire
the required skills for performing such tasks, specialized training has to be
provided to employees. However, they are not being provided such training
programs due to which they are not learning significantly (Sheehan, Garavan, & Carbery, 2014).
Lack of Appreciation of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
In the workplace or organization, performance
appraisal and its appreciation play an important role in not only motivating
employees but enhancing their efficiency. After all, motivation are job
satisfaction are associated directly with each other. It means that if
employees are appraised for their work, they will not only feel motivated but
they will be satisfied with their job as well. However, at the moment,
employees are not being appraised in the Oman College of Health Sciences (Chapman and White, 2012).
Overload of Work of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Even though employees are expected to fulfill
their responsibilities, managers shouldn’t make them work overtime because it
not only demotivates them but also tires them. When employees work beyond their
limits, they are both tired and demotivated. Gradually, it serves to decrease
their job satisfaction as well because employees believe that they are taken
advantage of and not compensated in return.
Lack of Employee Appraisal of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
It is quite important for the managers to
ensure that they appreciate the efforts of employees on a regular basis. If they
believe it is not feasible to appraise employees on a daily basis, they should
choose a routine according to which they should appraise the employees. It will
help in not only satisfying the employees but will also let them know that
their efforts are considered important in the organization or institute.
Inefficient Relationship with the Manager
of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Inefficient relationship with the manager is
another important factor due to which employee demotivation and job
dissatisfaction are caused. When employees cannot communicate with the managers
in an efficient manner and convey their expectations, it becomes difficult for
the employees to cope up with the work processes. With time, it becomes to the
reason of job dissatisfaction because their requirements are not fulfilled and
expectations are not met.
Promotion of Non-Eligible employees of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
When those employees are promoted within the
organization who don’t deserve the promotion, it causes other eligible
employees to be frustrated because they deserve it but are not promoted. In
addition to frustration, it also causes them to be dissatisfied with their job (Shriar, 2017).
Lack of Employee Engagement of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Employee engagement has been recognized as one
of the most important factors which contribute to the satisfaction of
employees. If employee engagement is considered important within firms, it
becomes easier for such firms to ensure that employees are satisfied with their
job and tasks. Employee engagement also contributes to the innovation and
creativity of employees. Insufficient employee engagement doesn’t only have an
adverse impact on the satisfaction of an employee but also on the performance
of a firm (Bridger, 2015).
Lack of
top management's t rust on employees of Oman College of Health Sciences and Job
Dissatisfaction
When the top management doesn’t show confidence
in the abilities or skills of the employees, it influences them in an adverse
manner. Lack of trust and confidence in the skills of employees is similar to
not appreciating the efforts of employees. Due to it, employees are not
motivated and they feel dissatisfaction with their job (Jafari, n.d.).
Bureaucracy on top management of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
If top management doesn’t involve employees in
the process of decision making, it causes employees to be demotivated with
their job and it is because they don’t feel as if their efforts are appreciated
or considered important in the organization. It is important for the top
management to ensure that employees are involved in different processes as it
can serve to enhance their motivation and satisfaction with their job (Next Level Work, 2019).
The
absence common of vision of Oman College of Health Sciences and Job
Dissatisfaction
When employees and the management have
different objectives to pursue, it causes the organization to be unstable. For
instance, if the management works towards something different while the
employees have a completely different foal in their mind, it causes the firm to
be inefficient in the market because there is no common or mutual objective. It
is important for the top management to communicate the goals of the firm with
the employees as it can not only make them feel appreciated but develop a
mutual objective to be accomplished (Smallbusiness.chron.com,
2019).
Lack of
employees trust on management of Oman College of Health Sciences and Job
Dissatisfaction
When employees don’t trust the management to
guide them in a proper manner, they lose their interest in asking management to
assist them. Similarly, they don’t feel that they are a part of the
organization due to which they don’t invest efforts in contributing to the
organization. It causes the organization to face issues in meeting the expected
performance standards. Gradually, it becomes difficult for the organization to
be efficient in the market.
Overall, these are some of the most important
and common factors which contribute to the employee job dissatisfaction. Due to
these reasons, employees are not only dissatisfied but also demotivated. And if
an effective measure or solution is not implemented as soon as possible, it
causes the organization to lose its competitive edge in the market (Thunnissen, Boselie, & Fruytier, 2013).
4.1
Impact of Job Dissatisfaction of Oman
College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
It has been determined that there are a number
of organizational aspects which are affected by employee dissatisfaction.
Following are the organizational aspects which are adversely influenced by this
issue:
·
Organizational Performance: One of the most important aspect of an
organization is its performance in the market and when employees don’t perform
to the expected standards, it will gradually influence the overall performance
of the firm. The same can be said about the Oman College of Health Sciences. It
will gradually begin to lose efficiency in the market if this issue is not
resolved as soon as possible.
·
Sales: Another
important aspect of the organization is its sales. It wouldn’t be wrong to say
that at the end of the day, the aim of every organization is to increase sales.
If employees fail in meeting the performance standards, it would cause the firm
to stop operating in an effective manner and it would decrease the sales of the
firm as well.
·
Customer Base: When employees don’t perform in an effective
manner, it is obvious that the expectations of customers wouldn’t be met and it
would cause them to be dissatisfied with the serves that they get from the
organization. Thus, they would change their preferences and leave the firm for
the other. The same applies to the Oman College of Health Sciences. If other
processes fail to be efficient, it will adversely influence the students and
its targeted audience (Topolosky, 2014).
5.0 Conclusion and
Recommendations of Oman College of Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Overall, it wouldn’t be wrong to
say that employee satisfaction is quite an important concept and it has been
researched for a long time now. Different researchers have contributed to the
existing research base with their own studies on the issue of employee
satisfaction and its effects on other processes. This study aimed to analyze
the concept of employee dissatisfaction in the context of Oman College of
Health Sciences. In order to analyze the institution and identify the
underlying reasons of the issue, two analyses were utilized. These analyses
included the SWOT and the Fishbone analyses. With these analyses, a number of
issues have been identified to exist in the institute which contribute to the
job dissatisfaction such as inefficient working condition and lack of employee
training and appraisal. All the research objectives have been accomplished in
this study and some recommendations will also be provided for resolving the
issue of job dissatisfaction among the employees of Oman College of Health Sciences.
5.
1 Recommendations of Oman College of
Health Sciences and Job Dissatisfaction
Following are the recommendations which should
be considered for resolving the issue of job dissatisfaction among the
employees:
·
A
healthy working environment should be provided to employees.
·
Different
programs aimed at motivating the employees should be considered.
·
Employees
should be involved in the decision making process as well.
·
The
performance of employees should be appraised.
·
Effective
communication with the employees should be established by the management.
·
Different
training programs should be implemented within the institution for enhancing
the skills of employees.
·
Strict
policies against discrimination should also be implemented.