Risk analysis and financial ratio
analysis are highly important analysis for an investor while deciding about
buying or selling shares in the stock markets. Company's risk analysis enables
the investors to select a secure investment product with lower chances of loss
in investment. While on the other hand, financial ratio analysis represents a
big picture of overall companies performance in a fiscal year or more than one
fiscal year. Considering this importance, risk analysis and financial analysis
are taken for two famous companies Apple Inc. and Nokia. Both of these
companies are working in the same industry therefore comparative analysis can be
helpful to understand the overall behaviour of offered stock by these companies
(Finance.yahoo.com, 2020).
Financial and risk analysis of Apple
Inc. includes information about profit margin, return on assets, return on
equity, beta, price to book ratio, and current ratio. Following analysis, the
profit margin of Apple Inc. (21.49%) is higher than Nokia (0.03%). Moreover,
ratios of the return on assets and return on equity (11.58% and 55.47%) are
also higher than the ratios of (ROA 1.68% and ROE 0.12%) Nokia. Somehow,
according to analysis beta value of Nokia (0.01) is lower than the beta value
of Apple Inc. (1.29%) which indicate that investors investing in Apple will
have a greater risk on return as compared to investors of Nokia Company (Finance.yahoo.com, 2020).
Moreover, price to book ratio is also
an important financial indicator which is also supportive of the investors of
Nokia. Apart from all these, liquidity analysis taken with the current ratio of
both companies indicates the strength of Nokia Company to meet its short term
obligations easily as compared to Apple Inc. Thus, conclusively Apple Inc.
seemed riskier.
Historical Standard Deviation and Stock
Volatility
The historical standard deviation of
stock returns represents the actual risk factor hidden behind the fluctuation
of share prices. Share prices never remain static. It fluctuates based upon
changes in the market demand for shares or supply of shares in the market. Analysis
of standard deviation can help us understand which stock has more risk or price
stability. To calculate standard deviation and volatility, we have taken
closing prices of both stocks from yahoo finance. According to the analysis of
historical standard deviation and stock volatility on an annual basis, we can
say that Apple Inc. has more volatility as compared to Nokia company.
Comparative Analysis of Historical Volatility
|
Daily
|
Values
|
Company
|
Higher
|
0.0493
|
Apple
Inc.
|
Lower
|
0.0481
|
Nokia
|
Difference
|
0.0011
|
|
|
|
|
Annual
|
|
|
Higher
|
0.9409
|
Apple
Inc.
|
Lower
|
0.919
|
Nokia
|
Difference
|
0.0219
|
|
According to the above mentioned table,
the standard deviation value of Nokia company is 0.0481 daily. While daily
volatility (SD) of Apple Inc. is 0.0493 which is a little bit greater than the
Nokia Company. The values of annual volatility are calculated by using 365 days
as the whole duration. Again difference of 0.0219 represents more volatility in
the annual stock return of Apple Inc.
Implied Volatility of Options
Implied
volatility is calculated for six different trading options available for Apple
Inc. and Nokia (3 and 3 respectively). A call option provides the opportunity
to the buyers to buy shares at strike prices if it seems beneficial to them. In
this analysis, three kinds of money options are selected to buy a stock of
Apple Inc. and Nokia Company. Three options of money are known as "In the
Money", "Out the Money" and "At the Money". An
exercise price of stock higher than strike value represent Out the Money call
option. While exercise price less than or equal to strike price represents
"In the Money" and "At the Money" trading options
respectively. Considering these basic rules some options are selected for Apple
Inc. and Nokia Company.
Apple Inc.
|
Nokia
|
Option 1
|
|
Option 2
|
Option 3
|
Option 1
|
Option 2
|
Option 3
|
Strike Value
|
125.4
|
225
|
300
|
2.5
|
4
|
3.9
|
Last Price
|
124.4
|
26.3
|
290
|
0.55
|
|
3.9
|
Implied Volatility
|
261.13
|
93.09
|
4.9043
|
-0.278
|
-0.083
|
0.086
|
Money
|
In the Money
|
In the Money
|
Out the Money
|
In the Money
|
Out of the Money
|
At The Money
|
According to
the above-presented table, Apple Inc. has implied volatility of 261, 13, 93.09,
and 4.904 for 20 days the same duration with different strike values, last
prices, and trading volume. While on the other hand, Nokia has -0.27, -0.083,
and 0.086 implied volatility values with a minimum of 2% and a maximum 3%
risk-free investment products. Nokia options are purchased based upon the
various types of money In the Money”, “Out the Money” and “At the Money”.
Conclusion of Stock Return
The whole
discussion concludes that Apple Inc. has a higher profit margin and return for
its investors as compared to Nokia Company. However, at the same time, Apple
has greater risk factor regarding investment returns and liquidity conditions
which makes Nokia a better and secure investment company.
References of Stock Return
Finance.yahoo.com. (2020). Apple Inc. (AAPL).
Retrieved from finance.yahoo.com: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL/options?date=1585872000&p=AAPL
Finance.yahoo.com. (2020). Nokia Corporation
(NOK). Retrieved from finance.yahoo.com:
https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/NOK/history?p=NOK