The
goal of this report is to provide detail information regarding the significance
of Corporate Social Responsibilities and why an organization should implement
CSR for increasing their profitability. The organizations around the world are
facing many challenging due to which not only their performance gets affected
but also sustaining, in the long run, become a tough task. CSR activities can
help the organization to fight with the challenges they are facing. In the
report, Costco Corporation has selected as a case to investigate how CSR
initiatives impact their operations. Costco is an American corporation and
considers among the world largest retail corporations. The headquarter of
Costco is situated in the state of Washington, USA. Costco is a Fortune 500
organization, and over the years, the revenue of the organization has
experienced immense growth. According to 2016 statistics, the organization is
the biggest retailer of wine, organic food & rotisserie chicken.
The
paper is divided into four main sections; the first is the introduction part,
which provides a brief overview of the report. The first section discusses the
social & ethical issues which different organizations are facing today. In
the second section, an organization has selected for evaluating the impact of
CSR activities on the operations. In the third section business case is
developed which support the CSR initiatives. In the last section, the
conclusion is provided which discuss the recommendation for CSR initiatives.
Evaluation of Ethical & Social Issues Facing
Organizations
In
the 21st century, the organizations around the world are facing many
challenging due to which not only their performance gets affected but also
sustaining, in the long run, become a tough task. Following are some of the key
social and ethical issues which many organizations in the world are facing
today:
Ethical Issues of Technology usages
Usage of Technology
The
technology around the world is changing rapidly, and today, almost every
organization rely on technology so that it can perform its various activities
efficiently. However, there are many ethical concerns related to the use of
technology. Many employees who use the technology of the organization does not
know up to what extent the usage of organizations technology is considered as
fair usage. Sometimes the employees start using the technology of organizations
for their own private purpose, which might not be in the best interest of the
organization. Therefore it can be said that technology has raised many ethical
issues which should be mitigated by creating new policies.
Bad Leadership
In
various organizations, the leadership sometimes unable to play their role in
making the organization successful. The leaders are sometimes unable to
understand the actual needs & preferences of the organizations. The leaders
sometimes create rules for their employees, but they do not follow the rules by
themselves, which creates working environment issues in the organization. In
simple words, it can be said that the bad behaviour of the leaders is a major
ethical concern in many organizations of the world (Visser, Matten, Pohl, & Tolhurst, 2010).
Employee Favoritism
In
many organizations, the managers or top management of the organizations start
liking some number of employees within their organizations. The employee favouritism
is one the most common ethical issue which the organization faces. The reason
for employee favouritism might occur due to personal ling or disliking.
Sometimes the managers like those employees who come from the same background
from which they have come or both individual share the same cultural background
etc. However, favouritism can have negative consequences on the performance of
the organization because managers start giving incentives to those employees
who they like and ignore the deserving ones (AnsKolk, 2016
Accounting Practices
In
organizations, the accounts have to be maintained according to the rules &
regulations which are set by the authorities. The organizations follow
standards given by GAAP or IFRS. However, sometimes, the employees manipulate
accounting information to gain economic interests. This is a major ethical
issue because not only it affects the accounting reports, but also the
organizations might be unable to attract the investors in the future. When the
investors are not going to get clear information than they might not invest in
the organization.
Managing Cultural Diversity
Managing
cultural diversity is highly important in the organization because if the
diversity is not going to be managed appropriable than the working environment
of the organization get disturbed. Sometimes the organization give favour to
the individual who belongs to certain ethnicities and ignores the people who
belong to other cultures. This creates a major ethical issue in the
organization. It is important for the management to treat each and every
employee equally without focusing on their cultural; background. It is not
ethically correct that culturally diverse individuals in the organization do
not feel welcomed or consider the working environment inappropriate for work (Searcy, 2012).
Social Issues of health
Safety & health of employees
The
organizations today are focusing especially on the safety and health of their
employees. Society raises concerns regarding the health of the employees
because people want to work in such organizations which focus on their health.
The health and safety of the employee is a major social issue which the
organizations are facing today. If they are not going to focus on safety than
not only the employee can face injuries but also the reputation of the
organization will decline because the society will consider the organization
unsafe for workers. Despite the implementation of many safety standards,
sometimes an accident occurs on the work sites which raises questions on the
safety measures of the organizations (AnsKolk, 2016).
Environment Protection of employees
Another
major social issue which the organizations are facing today is the environment
protection. Global warming has become a major issue and organizations are
trying to eliminate their carbon footprint. The corporations today are highly
investing in environmental protection initiatives to become sustainable.
However, environment protection initiatives increase the organization's cost,
and sometimes organizations face the consequences due to high expenditures of
environment protection initiatives (McNamara, 2018).
Welfare of Society
The
customers have become quite aware of the CSR activities of the organizations.
The customers want the organizations to provide maximum benefit to society. The
organization today not only have to focus on environment protection but also on
the welfare of society. The organizations perform charity, donations and other
activities for improving the standard of living of the people. However, such
initiatives come up with high costs, which creates issues for the organization.
Costco Corporation
Costco
is an American corporation and considers among the world largest retail
corporations. The headquarter of Costco is situated in the state of Washington,
USA. Costco is a Fortune 500 organization, and over the years, the revenue of
the organization has experienced immense growth. According to 2016 statistics,
the organization is the biggest retailer of wine, organic food & rotisserie
chicken. The organization has a presence in many parts of the world, which
include Iceland, Taiwan, San Diego, Japan, UK and Canada. According to 2019
statistics, the organization has stores on 770 locations.
Financial Operations of Costco Corporation
Costco
Corporation manages its financial quite efficiently. Due to the effective
management of the operations, the financials of the organization are showing
growth in income. The revenue of the organization in the last seven years have
experience growth, which is a sign that the organization's customers are
increasing with the passage of time. The increase in revenue shows
organizations growth and significant for a higher amount of profit. The net
income of Costco has also increased in the past 5 years, which is indicating the
high financial performance of the company. Below is the income statement of
Costco for the last 5 years. Through the income statement, the management of
profitability & expenses can be analyzed critically
COSTCO WHOLESALE
CORP (COST) CashFlowFlag INCOME
STATEMENT
|
Fiscal year ends in
August. USD in millions except per share data.
|
2014-08
|
2015-08
|
2016-08
|
2017-08
|
2018-08
|
TTM
|
Revenue
|
112640
|
116199
|
118719
|
129025
|
141576
|
149616
|
Cost of revenue
|
98458
|
101065
|
102901
|
111882
|
123152
|
130247
|
Gross profit
|
14182
|
15134
|
15818
|
17143
|
18424
|
19369
|
Operating expenses
| | | | |
Sales, General and
administrative
|
10899
|
11445
|
12068
|
12950
|
13876
|
14573
|
Other operating expenses
|
63
|
65
|
78
|
82
|
68
|
76
|
Total operating expenses
|
10962
|
11510
|
12146
|
13032
|
13944
|
14649
|
Operating income
|
3220
|
3624
|
3672
|
4111
|
4480
|
4720
|
Interest Expense
|
113
|
124
|
133
|
134
|
159
|
153
|
Other income (expense)
|
90
|
104
|
80
|
62
|
121
|
155
|
Income before income
taxes
|
3197
|
3604
|
3619
|
4039
|
4442
|
4722
|
Provision for income
taxes
|
1109
|
1195
|
1243
|
1325
|
1263
|
1075
|
Minority interest
|
30
|
32
|
26
|
35
|
45
|
42
|
Other income
|
30
|
32
|
26
|
35
|
45
|
42
|
Net income from
continuing operations
|
2088
|
2409
|
2376
|
2714
|
3179
|
3647
|
Other
|
-30
|
-32
|
-26
|
-35
|
-45
|
-42
|
Net income
|
2058
|
2377
|
2350
|
2679
|
3134
|
3605
|
Net income available to
common shareholders
|
2058
|
2377
|
2350
|
2679
|
3134
|
3605
|
Earnings per share
| | | | | |
Basic
|
4.69
|
5.41
|
5.36
|
6.11
|
7.15
|
8.21
|
Diluted
|
4.65
|
5.37
|
5.33
|
6.08
|
7.09
|
8.14
|
Weighted average shares
outstanding
| | | |
Basic
|
439
|
439
|
439
|
438
|
439
|
439
|
Diluted
|
442
|
443
|
441
|
441
|
442
|
443
|
EBITDA
|
4339
|
4855
|
5007
|
5543
|
6038
|
6325
|
Source:
http://financials.morningstar.com/income-statement/is.html?t=COST®ion=usa&culture=en-US
The
higher profitability and revenue are indicating that the financial analyst or
managers are performing their duties effectively. The financial managers are
managing the financials of the organization operationally due to which the
corporation was able to achieve growth in net income. If the financial managers
were unable to manage the financials accurately, then the financial reports
might not show accurate financial results.
Impact of CSR on Financials
The
CSR activities have a huge impact on the financials of the organizations. The
CSR activities provide benefit to all the major stakeholders of the
corporations, which include investors, employees, customers and communities. When
the organization perform CSR its goodwill increase, which increases the value
of the organization. Furthermore, the sales of the organization increases,
which become the reason for an increase in the amount of profitability. However,
CSR activities have some negative impact on financial performance as well
because it increases the expenses of the company. The following are some key
positive and negative impact on the financials of Costco Corporation:
Positive Impact of CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility)
Some
major positive impact of CSR activities on the financials of the organization
are mentioned as follows:
Increase in Revenue of (Corporate Social Responsibility)
The
CSR activities increase the revenue of the organization because the customers
like such organizations who provide maximum benefit to society. Due to CSR
activities, the organization become famous and due to high popularity, the
sales of the organization experience boost. The higher sales bring a huge
amount of profit as a result. If everything goes perfectly than through high
sales, the organization can expand its business in a short amount of time (Visser, Matten, Pohl, & Tolhurst, 2010).
Increase in Goodwill
The
high goodwill means that the overall value of the organization will increase. Higher
goodwill not only creates customer loyalty but also help the organization to
sustain in the long run. The goodwill of the organization is also important for
attracting investment in the company. The investors usually invest in such
organization who have high goodwill or reputation in the market. A company with
low goodwill might be unable to attract higher investments (O'Sullivan, Smith, & Esposito, 2012).
Increase in Net Income (Corporate Social Responsibility)
As
discussed earlier, the CSR activities increase the sales of the organization,
and when sales of the organization increase the profit of the company also
experience an increase. The high profitability of the company provides many opportunities
for the company, such as expansion or improvement in the current performance.
The organization can use the amount of profit to increase shareholder wealth as
well. In short for profit maximization, the CSR initiatives can play a significant
role.
Negative Impact of CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility)
The
negative impact of CASR activities on financials are explained as follows:
Increase in expenses (Corporate Social Responsibility)
Although
CSR nativities increase the sales & profit of the company, they are also a
reason for the high amount of expenses. The CSR initiatives are expenses and
can cause huge financial Burdon on the organization. If the CSR initiatives are
not planned wisely than it can lead to financial loss, and ultimately, the
efficiency and performance of the organization will suffer. That is why it is
important to invest wisely in CSR activities. The organization should analyze
its financial condition before taking any major decision regarding CSR activities.
Otherwise, the organization might experience a financial problem in the
upcoming years.
Divert from profit maximization goal of
every organization
The
main aim of every organization is to maximize its profit. This goal, however,
gets seriously affected when the organization started focusing on CSR
activities. The organization then focus more on the initiatives through which
it can provide, maximum benefit to the society. The attention of the company
diverts from its operations toward the activities which it performs for
increasing its profit and sales. Due to diversion, the company might be unable
to perform its operations more effectively, which leads to a decline in
performance & efficiency. The ultimate result of this scenario would be of
low profitability. That is why the organization should not divert from its key
operations for performing CSR (Spender, 2014).
Negative impact on Goodwill
As CSR activities
increase the goodwill of the organization, the CSR activities can also become
the reason for the decline in the goodwill as well. The CSR policies ask the
organizations to provide maximum detail to the customers about their products.
It means that if any product as negative aspects than the organization would
have to provide this information as well to its customers. After hearing the
negative impacts of the products, the customers might lose confidence in the
organization's products, and in the worst case scenario, the reputation of the
organization might decline (Epstein, 2018).
CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility)
Initiatives of Costco
In
order to achieve success in the competitive market, the organization have to
look for various activities through which it can get a competitive edge over
the competitors. Costco runs in the retail sector, which has high competition.
The CSR initiatives of Costco can help the corporation to standout in the
market. Costco’s CSR initiatives revolve around its key stakeholders, which are
discussed below:
Employees of Costco corporations
Costco
corporations’ top priority is its employees. Costco gives special attention to
its employees because the organization knows that the employees are the one who
performs the business activities. Due to the employee's performance, the
organization experience growth. By keeping the importance of its employees in
mind, Costco has many CSR initiatives for its employees which include
leadership development programs, health benefit programs, life insurance, and
reimbursement for elderly & childcare and lots of other CSR initiatives for
the employees. With such initiatives, the motivational level of the employee's
increases and they provide their best performance.
Customers of Costco corporations
The
customers are the second priority of the organization. Costco tries its best to
meet the expectation of its customers. The organizations understand the needs
& preferences of their customers so that best customer services can be
given. Costco meets the interests of its customers by providing them with high-quality
products at low costs. Through affordability, the corporation has gained the
trust of its customers, which have become the reason for higher revenue. In
other words, through CSR activities, the company have not only increased sales
bit have also created customer loyalty, trust and goodwill (Economist & Kourdi, 2015).
Investors of Costco corporations
The
investors are second last priority of the corporation. The corporations know
the importance of its investors because if investors are not going to invest in
the organization than the availability of funds will decrease, which is
important for running the operations of the business. The investors invest in
the organization when they know that the organization I am meeting their
interests. Costco meets the interest of its investors by keeping its
profitability high. Due to high profitability, the organization expand its
business in another part of the world. The investors attract the corporation by
seeing the growth of the organization (Spender, 2014).
Communities of Costco corporations
The communities
are the last priority of the Costco organization. For communities, Costco has
taken many initiatives like donations & charities. The organization not
only protect the environment but also improves the standard of living of the
people.
4. Conclusion
on Business Case to Support CSR (Corporate
Social Responsibility) Initiatives
It
is concluded that The CSR activities increase the revenue of the organization
because the customers like such organizations who provide maximum benefit to
society. Due to CSR activities, the organization become famous and due to high
popularity, the sales of the organization experience boost. The higher sales
bring a huge amount of profit as a result. The high profitability of the
company provides many opportunities for the company, such as expansion or
improvement in the current performance. The organization can use the amount of profit
to increasing shareholder wealth as well. In short for profit maximization, the
CSR initiatives can play a significant role.
Costco already has taken many CSR initiatives which
revolve around its major stakeholders. The CSR initiatives of Costco has
allowed it to increase its profitability and proved successful for the
organization. It is recommended that the organization to continue its CSR initiatives
because they are playing a key role in the success and growth of the
organization. Without CSR initiatives, the company might be unable to increase
its revenue.
References of Business Case to Support CSR
(Corporate Social Responsibility) Initiatives
AnsKolk. (2016). The social responsibility of
international business: From ethics and the environment to CSR and sustainable
development. 51, 23-34.
Economist, T., & Kourdi, J. (2015). Business Strategy:
A guide to effective decision-making. PublicAffairs.
Epstein, M. J. (2018). Making sustainability work. Best
practices in managing and measuring corporate social, environmental and
economic impacts., 282.
McNamara, C. (2018). Business Ethics and Social Responsibility.
Retrieved from https://managementhelp.org/businessethics/index.htm
O'Sullivan, P., Smith, M., & Esposito, M. (Eds.). (2012).
Business Ethics: A Critical Approach: Integrating Ethics Across the Business
World. Routledge.
Searcy, C. (2012). Corporate sustainability performance
measurement systems: A review and research agenda. Journal of business
ethics, 239-253.
Spender, J.-C. (2014). Business Strategy: Managing
Uncertainty, Opportunity, and Enterprise. OUP Oxford.
Visser, W., Matten, D., Pohl, M., & Tolhurst, N. (2010). The
A to Z of Corporate Social Responsibility . John Wiley & Sons.