The independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

Introduction of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

Audit has been explained financial process of investigating company’s or personal financial records to identify that they are perfect and in accord with any of the implemented rules, laws and regulations. 

There are two types of auditors has been presented one is external audit and the other one is internal audit. The external audit has been described as it has been come from the outward to the company to investigate the financial and accounting records and this will also give the independent vision related to these records. in this regard (Robert, Thomas, & Driskill, 2020) some of the legislation has been needed that all of the public firms which have their financial statements externally audited. As well as internal audit has been explained as the auditors work which has been done for the enterprises as an internal worker to evaluate the records and also help the company to enhance their internal procedures like operations, risk management, internal control and governance as well. 

There are some of the standards has been set by the public company accounting oversight board they maintain external audit standards for public organizations and their issues can be registered along with the securities and exchange commission. In this regard the oversight board holds 15 permanent standards which has been approved by SEC the number of provisional standards which reflects the overall accepted auditing standards and it has also been explained in standards which has been issued by auditing board of standards which is the part of American institute of CPAs. In this it has also been mentioned that Audit planning also involve deciding on the general audit strategy and the formation of an audit plan.   

Internal Audit of The independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

The word internal audit may take as the invoke a sense of fear, time consuming and frustration as well. it has been done even in best consequences, and most of them will found in having someone to review their activities unsetting and unapproachable.  Holding and understanding of the role an internal audit and getting aware about what to suppose during an internal audit. internal audit has been explained as the auditors work which has been done for the enterprises as an internal worker to evaluate the records and also help the company to enhance their internal procedures like operations, (Tânia, Pedrosa, & Costa, 2019)risk management, internal control and governance as well. Internal audit has a department of individuals within the firm which is tasked with giving dispassionate and some of the independent reviews of systems, business, company and procedures. As well as the role of internal audit is to give senior leader and authoritative bodies of company and purposeful source of knowledge which is related with the company’s threat, control of environment and managerial efficiency and adherence with the implemented laws, rules and regulations. 

 As an internal audit report of senior leadership and it is specifically which is its activities and has been directed by the director and CEO of the company through their audit committee. The staff of internal audit should be independent from internal politics and has been unbiased to give leadership with the purposeful source of knowledge. The main purpose of internal audits has to assess weaknesses within the firm’s procedure and control the environment inwardly so they would be fixed as soon as possible to avoid risk to the company or their stakeholders. 

The study of auditing has been now become significant to check persons and daily transference of companies, and some of the business had to record the receipt and expenditure of money on the behalf of others. (Mihret, Getie, & Grant, 2017)There are some of the standards has been set by the public company accounting oversight board they maintain external audit standards for public organizations and their issues can be registered along with the securities and exchange commission. In this regard the oversight board holds 15 permanent standards which has been approved by SEC the number of provisional standards which reflects the overall accepted auditing standards and it has also been explained in standards which has been issued by auditing board of standards which is the part of American institute of CPAs. Moreover, it can also be said that in the ancient Greek and Egypt who used this system of efficiency of internal control system to hold out check and counter among different financial officers. Moreover, auditing has been taking the latest dimensions in our community nowadays and then it would be move forward to be enhanced upon outcomes of development and enhancement of business mainly in the private sector. (Marc, Henseler, & Köhler, 2017)Furthermore, the significance of auditing in business of world of recent requirements no focus as the resolution of issue of reliability in study and accounts dishonesties in meeting an independent person which has been known as an auditor to investigate and explain on his outcomes. The procedure of investigation and reviewing the accounting transference in order to provide declaration that the financial statement which gives the financial places of the company honestly as at specific time period. 

As it has been mentioned above description of the meaning and area of audit and it is the great psychological effect on some of the officers and workers commended along with money and goods and some of their workers. The significance with which private sectors and the business society which has been connected with the practice of auditing in various country where has been engendered the federal government to review some of the charted institute. Moreover, it can also be said that some of the accounting parties which had been needed to attend before investigate the prepared account to make sure the perfection of fundamental records.

Background of the Study of The independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

In the previous, there had been what it has been known as counter check, which is utilized as financial check-up. This system had been for on until one individual whose responsibility and had to develop and identification of books and accounts of business which has been called auditor. As well as it is the person’s duty that they had to take record of the receipts and some of the disbursement of money which can be taken on the behalf of other individuals. When it as been coming to pass then they become an auditor for checking balance sheets and books of organization as well. moreover, (Murad , Kathar, & Rathi, 2016) it is required for effective accounting records and efficiency of internal control system to able them and get aware about some of the financial situation and control. 

Furthermore, it has been stated that internal control system is the main and important part in any of the company. as well as it can also be said that in most of the private sectors and it the most unique area of economy. It also gives various services to consumer and balance the great amount of funds which s ben achieved in their daily routine. Whereas, main activities which has been presented in the economy has been based on empowerment and consistency of private sectors. Just because of these factors the requirement of internal audit system within the private sector can not be destabilize. On the basis of safe and healthy private sector tasks in this regard internal audit is quite significant. As well as it has also been mentioned that internal audit plays the significant role in enhancing the performance of organization. Moreover, some of the internal auditors evaluate organizations in finding main threatening factors. (Lourens & Coetzee, 2018) It will also able the firm to antedate probable for forthcoming account as well as also investigates the latest weaknesses. 

It will also allow enterprises to investigate procedure and controls that has not been working properly and efficiently and this will also sanctions the opportunity to enhance on these. Moreover, it is necessary for internal auditor to be independent from the operations they assess and report the biggest level with in the firm. As well as some of the internal auditors assess the controls a firm has in place.  Holding and understanding of the role an internal audit and getting aware about what to suppose during an internal audit. internal audit has been explained as the auditors work which has been done for the enterprises as an internal worker to evaluate the records and also help the company to enhance their internal procedures like operations, risk management, internal control and governance as well. 

Internal audit has a department of individuals within the firm which is tasked with giving dispassionate and some of the independent reviews of systems, business, company and procedures.  Initially the two main terms have been explained and then the conceptual framework has been introduced in order reveal the interference between them and has been stand as the reference point which has been come from all the stake holders. Despite from this it can also be said that internal audit can also be take place in banking sectors and it mainly be involved in bank as a department along with the independent management line.

Definition of terms of The independence and performance of internal audit in private sector:

Auditing – In order to set norms and standards of business, the third parties examine systematically the proves for the sustainability of some practices. Auditing is thus the collection and evaluation of the provided information and the procedure of establishing criteria Zhou and

Zinyama (2012).

Internal auditor – the member of the organization whose objective is to examine the organization position about the financial transactions. The one who is employed as auditor is permanent and has the lifetime profession in the same organization and earn stipulated salary each month, Brody and Lowe (2000).

Independence – a virtue where the judgment of someone is not affected through the conditions or relationships, Mallin (2009).

Corruption – abusing the resources of public just for personal and no public benefits, Network (2004).

Stakeholder – the fraction of corporate that can get effected by the actions of the organization overall, without the support of stakeholders, the organization can not stand out and exit. Dankovetal (2004)

Risk – some negative potential anticipation that lead to unfavorable loss of the organization, Matzenbaum

(2002)

Problem statement:

There is a a bundle of literature that explain the operation and functions of internal audit. In order to set norms and standards of business, the third parties examine systematically the proves for the sustainability of some practices. Auditing is thus the collection and evaluation of the provided information and the procedure of establishing criteria. The need for establishing an independent department for internal audit in any private or public sector is to be ensure that there is reasonable effectiveness and efficiency in delivery of the products or the services because the problems related to service delivery is center of good governance now a days.

Just because of this problem, many public or private sectors management do not give the sufficient documents. Members of the department of internal audit is nor well remunerated and this thing make them lose interest in their work. Many complain that, being an employee of the department of internal audit mean you do not have liberty to exercise the independent behavior that is the requirement for being an auditor.

Other concepts of The independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

The main purpose of internal audits has to assess weaknesses within the firm’s procedure and control the environment inwardly so they would be fixed as soon as possible to avoid risk to the company or their stakeholders. 

The study of auditing has been now become significant to check persons and daily transference of companies, and some of the business had to record the receipt and expenditure of money on the behalf of others. The profession of internal auditing is becoming crucial in good governance especially in private sectors. But there is a great credit for the external auditing which eventually left the importance and liberty of the internal auditing that create a question in minds of many people. Independence is the core foundation of the profession of internal auditing. The qualified and professional auditors expect their importance and credibility from the perception of independence in their attitudes, mentality, functionality and appearance. From the context of external auditing. The research on auditing and its aims from many years has been established. Beside this, there are countless records of errors, asset misuses and fraud cases has provided the need for the impartiality and autonomy of internal audit. The motivation in this study is continuously changing duties, performance and growing responsibilities of internal audit in private sectors. The main corporate governance transport and accountability process is the establishment of internal audit. The major function of internal audit includes the safe guarding of funds and assets internally, risk management, financial controlling and internal consulting services.

The profession of internal auditing is becoming crucial in good governance especially in private sectors. But there is a great credit for the external auditing which eventually left the importance and liberty of the internal auditing that create a question in minds of many people. Effective powers and authority have been mandated to external auditors than internal auditors. Furthermore, according to Stewart and Subramaniam (2009) the main rationale why internal auditors have grown in importance is that they reduce self-review, social pressure, economic interest, personal relationship and familiarity, cultural and cognitive biases. Against these issues of the threats they also develop and identify various safeguards. The present situation of the world has its full pressure on private and public sectors and their finance and resources. All this require public and local authorities to manipulate the resources of the public effectively and objectively along with the establishment of vision. The major pressure is from the area of corruption, fraud and misuse of the public resources and has been proved through the workshop of Public Internal Control Systems worldwide for instance, the European Union compendium

which was initiated by 27 countries in order to refurbish internal audit operations in public sector

organizations.

Research Objectives of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

General Objectives of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

In god governance particularly in the private sectors the internal auditing is considered as the critical profession and it has become crucial elements and profession. Therefore, on the external auditing much emphasis has been credited by which the significance and independence of the internal audit becomes more critical and nagging questions for the mind of the person. For the profession of the internal audit the independences are considered as the cornerstone. Much importance has been paid for the effective components of the private good governance that are related to the internal audit. The external auditors are mandated as compare to the internal auditors by the effective authorities and powers.     

Specific Objectives of The independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

• To evaluate the association among the management in all council operations and internal audit

• To investigates the efficiency and effectiveness of internal audit control for both functions as proposed and existing 

• To identify the challenges and issues that are occur due to IFO municipality in accountability and upholding independence of internal audit by observing the behavior of manager.

• To examine the kinds of the internal audits for private sectors along with theirs subsequent efficient methods that is using in private sectors 

• To assess how objective and efficiency affected by the resourcing and size of the internal audit.

• To offer the various strategies in order to establish the independent and effective audit

• To examine the impacts of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sectors

Research Questions of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

• What is the association among the management in all council operations and internal audit?

• What are the ways to investigate the efficiency and effectiveness of internal audit control for both functions as proposed and existing?

• What are the challenges and issues that are occur due to IFO municipality in accountability and upholding independence of internal audit by observing the behavior of manager?

• What are the kinds of the internal audits for private sectors along with theirs subsequent efficient methods that is using in private sectors 

• How objective and efficiency affected by the resourcing and size of the internal audit in private sectors?

• What are the major the various strategies in order to establish the independent and effective audit in private sectors?

Literature review of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sectors

One of the four foundations is an effective IAF in the corporate governance sideways with the management (IIA, 2005). In the paste literature, like , Paape et  al. (2003), Carcello  et  al. (2005), Sarens (2009) and Soh and Mortinov-Bennie (2011) also state that IAF as a device that is important for corporate governance that perform on of the important roles in the private and public sectors through techniques of risk management, evaluating and assessing the control mechanisms. But there is some existence of dissimilarity between internal audit functions of public and private sectors, according to the previous literature functions (Carhill & Kincail 1989; Goodwin 2004). Barac and Steden (2014) found that by the comparison of private and public sectors IAF in South Africa, the internal audit control is well developed and is effective in corporate governance mechanism but it is still not well establishing in public sectors. Holding and understanding of the role an internal audit and getting aware about what to suppose during an internal audit. internal audit has been explained as the auditors work which has been done for the enterprises as an internal worker to evaluate the records and also help the company to enhance their internal procedures like operations, risk management, internal control and governance as well. The present situation of the world has its full pressure on private and public sectors and their finance and resources. All this require public and local authorities to manipulate the resources of the public effectively and objectively along with the establishment of vision.

Quality of internal audit recommendation of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector:

It was asserting by Cohen & Sayag (2014) that recommendation that internal auditor will make for the implementation should be of the good quality. Internal auditor is the member of the organization whose objective is to examine the organization position about the financial transactions. The one who is employed as auditor is permanent and has the lifetime profession in the same organization and earn stipulated salary each month. They should work according to the standards because in order to increase the quality of the internal auditing, compliance with internal auditing standards is the major contributor that can add value to the work. The decision of the course is directly impacted by the audit report for the action to take place through the management. Thus, we can say that the good quality of the work on internal audit report along with terms of the compliance with standard can greatly improve the process of implementing the recommendation that is made through the internal auditor. The recommendation of the audit should be clear, understandable, convincing and should state and understandable approach of the work for the implementation of the recommendation. The decision of the course is directly impacted by the audit report for the action to take place through the management. Hutchings (2014). Wadesango et al. (2018) state that the internal auditor should be able to give useful finding on audit and good recommendations that cause the management to improve and interested. On the other hand, Hoos (2018) argues that if the work on internal audit is according to the professional standards of internal auditing than it can contribute a lot on the effectiveness of auditing. There is another postulate by Pizzin (2015) that the most important contributor to internal auditing value addition is to comply with the professional standards.

There are standards for audit and the services that are related to audit which are published by IIA and it also include the performance, implementation as well as attributes standards. Moreover, internal standards of auditing identify that internal auditors also give services that are the information other than the financial reports. They want auditors to play their role with the motive of some objective and in compliance with the standards criteria in order to have the professional practice, so that the activities of the internal audit will evaluate and contribute in the improvement of managing risks, control and governance through the approach that will be systematic and disciplined.  All this is important not only for the legal requirement compliance but also because of the scope of the performances of the auditor duties which also involve the areas where the evaluation require high level of judgment skills and thus the audit report that will be generated willmhave the great impact  on the decision of action that will be adopted by the management of the private sector (Wadesango & Mhaka, 2017). Thus, we can say that a good quality of internal auditing work along with the compliance with standards forms, along with the Hugh level of audit planning efficiency and execution, all this can improve the effectiveness of audits.

Independency and objectivity of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector:

Independency as well as the objectivity are some of the properties that the auditor should require where the auditing is carried out without creeping his/her mind, Baharud-den et al. (2014).  This is a very important part while conducting the audit as the auditors can give their judgment without any bias that could contribute in final judgement in the evidence of audit but rather the audit will come with those recommendation from the proves that they obtain themselves in carrying the independent and objective containing audit. There is a postulate by Wadesango et al. (2017) that the internal audit is somewhat independent and appraisal activity. The work ‘independent’ has a lot importance here, even it has come up with the limitation that we are talking about independence with in the organization, but still it holds the meaning of internal auditing for being able to report on facts and figures, with out the influence of any favor or frown. The function of internal audit is the part of entity and without the level of degree of its autonomy and objectivity can not be the main criteria for independence. Because the outside influence in reporting can affect the decision and pattern of reporting (Zulkiyah, 2014). Endaya & Hanefah (2015) also argue on this issue by stating that objectivity is the requirement of any profession who are able to give the professional judgement by himself or with the help of others with out the loss of its judgement who can loss the value and them will become meaningless to the users decision and opinion.

In the environment of business, the requirement of objectivity is obvious, generally most of the times with the auditors where the members of management and stakeholder all depend on the opinion of the auditor. Internal auditor should be free from all kinds of the external influence or pressure and interference and the auditors should have unbiased and impartial behavior, and he/she should avoid all kind of conflicts of interest so that they can make a report for the recommendation that is worth reliable by the management team of the organization that will eventually make it easier for the management to implement the recommendation that s made by the internal auditor. Zakari (2014) shows that management will not give any respect to the recommendation or opinion of the internal auditor who is not independent because it will seem like he is doing deals with the influence of something that can ultimately cripple the organization. Internal auditor should act like the position of advisor, specialist as well as the consultant who can have number of qualities in one position and one of the qualities that is very important is independency, Fenton & Neil (2014). Throughout the course of internal auditing, the auditor should show the independency as well as the objectivity to the management and the organization (Goleman, 2016). The efficiency came up when the auditor is independent from the management of the organization which can then approve the objective assessments to be audited. According to Abuazza (2015) it is independency and objectivity of the internal auditing phenomenon that allow the activity of auditing work to be done without any interference at any part of auditing task.

But implementation is not guaranteed when follow ups are done but rather when management appreciate the internal audit team, they can implement without follow up action, MacRae & Gills (2014).

Contribution to the risk management of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector:

In order to improve the risk profile of the company, internal auditing has its major role (Stewart & Kent, 2015). According to Lee & Park (2016) risk management is actually a vulnerability of the organization on the risk that can be faced by the organization as a whole. Risk is some negative potential anticipation that lead to unfavorable loss of the organization. Risk management can be done by the recommendation report made by internal auditor who can identify and evaluate the risks to which the organization can get into and the internal auditor is the one who gave the best way to manage that risk. The other major goal if the internal auditor is to improve the risk management activities through belong the management of the organization in an identifying, assessing and finding way to get rid of the issues and risks. Contribution is risk management can contain number of different aspects like helping managers in identifying and mitigating the business risks, helping the organization to cope up with enterprises risks management activities, and also giving assurance about the risk management system adequacy. It is stated by Cioban et al. (2016) that the risk management is the assistance of the organization along with the help of internal audit performances, in order to identify and evaluate the risks that the organization is exposed to. So basically, it is the role of internal audit department to help in improving the system of risk management and control.

The assessing and monitoring the risks that are coming in way of the organization is the role of internal auditor, it also involve the recommendations to control so that management can mitigate the risk, and can evaluate the trade-off that are required for the success of some strategy and operational objective of the company or the organization, Hutching (2014). Rehman et al. (2016) stated that there also exist affirmative associations linking non-implementation of audit recommendations and the financial performance of the organization as non-implementation of the recommendations results in poor business processes which result in reduced production and revenue. Paape (2014) said that those organization that do not give any intentions for implanting audit recommendation have more inefficient and outdated business processes that meanwhile decrease the productivity and revenue of the organization and the organization can not stand out. Wadesango et al. (2017) outlined that if the audit recommendation is nit implanted that can lead to the increase in risk of fraud which eventually cause the organization to fall. But the recommendation that is made by the internal auditor who is not independent, will term as non-qualified report and will not get any value in front of management of the organization. Recommendation should be of the greater quality so it can be able to deal as a great solution to the problem, Cohen & Sayag (2014) so if the audit work is done according to the standards of internal auditing then the recommendation will get the great value in front of the management of the organization.

Improvement in internal control system and compliance:

Internal auditors are responsible for assessing and monitoring the internal control system of the organization and should develop significant internal control improvement so that there will be short fall in internal control system of the organization, Fenton & Neil (2014). Reviewing the compliance with both rules and regulation internally as well externally is the role of internal auditor. Recommendation that are made by the internal auditor are valuable to the management and also for the member of the organization. The conventional role of the internal auditor is to monitor and improve the internal system of the organization by contributing the material weakness in the information system of the organization that can cause the financial disturbance. 

According to Abuazza et al. (2015) it is the role of internal auditor to monitor the internal control system. Development of the internal control is the role of management but they take help from the internal audit department for monitoring the internal control and wait for their recommendation in order to improve the issue and risks. It is the duty of internal audit to report to senior manager on performance of internal control systems and recommend for the improvement wherever necessary and applicable.

Holding and understanding of the role an internal audit and getting aware about what to suppose during an internal audit. internal audit has been explained as the auditors work which has been done for the enterprises as an internal worker to evaluate the records and also help the company to enhance their internal procedures like operations, risk management, internal control and governance as well. Internal audit has a department of individuals within the firm which is tasked with giving dispassionate and some of the independent reviews of systems, business, company and procedures. As well as the role of internal audit is to give senior leader and authoritative bodies of company and purposeful source of knowledge which is related with the company’s threat, control of environment and managerial efficiency and adherence with the implemented laws, rules and regulations. 

having digital audit system and in this regard some of the challenges has been faced by the staff of internal audit and their work as well and to updating of their information to cope with some of the challenges as in the phase of manipulation of some of the frauds which is wanted. More, the obligation of recent auditing standards would create the staff of internal audit to inform their information and regulate to the existing rehearsal. furthermore, internal auditing attain mainly enhancement in position in the preceding years, specifically in its referring role within the organizational risk management. adopting to the extensive secretarial disgraces, and also the insolvency of company, the internal audit (IA) function mainly pay emphasis on researchers and consultants similar as a momentous funder of organizational efficiency.

Conceptual framework

As it has been suggested by Vousinas, Georgios (2016) that in the recent universal crisis, which had been playing the role of roots within the banking area and has been enlighten despite form the presenting regulatory gaps as well s deficiency of appropriate and effective internal audit functions which has been done in some of the banking institutions order to alleviate some of the consequences and also the negative effects. However, it has been stated that internal audit is the main role player while addressing bank fraud and their importance in the task of latest difficult financial foundations has been taken for granted. Despite from this the fact that frequently it is not appropriately oppressed. (Georgios, 2016) Initially the two main terms have been explained and then the conceptual framework has been introduced in order reveal the interference between them and has been stand as the reference point which has been come from all the stake holders. Despite from this it can also be said that internal audit can also be take place in banking sectors and it mainly be involved in bank as a department along with the independent management line. current internal audit function autonomously and accurately assesses the excellence and efficiency of a bank’s internal control, risk administration and ascendency procedures. 

In this it has been stated Andersson, Tuulikki (2016) that some of the previous studies did not gives the deep information. As well as study also investigates about how internal audit observe their role in both situations as referring and declaring providers. The role of inters audit has been changed during some of the previous years. In some of the recent years internal audit play the significant role in any of the firm or in the governance infrastructure. In this regard some of the previous studies reveals that there is a gap has been presented among internal auditors and which hold their own vision of the role which has been contrasted with some of the stakeholders. The broader scope of the extensive opportunity of internal auditors’ character hazards introduction internal auditors in a state of struggle, (Andreson & Vilo, 2016)where referring facilities impend their delivery of declaration services. In order to deliver amplification to the role, the studies show that how internal auditors become contented in their role, as both guarantee and referring benefactors and what apprehensions internal auditors face in their effort. the main objective of the internal audit function (IAF) has to assess and enhance the efficiency of administrations’ risk management, regulator, and domination procedures, which has been completed through declaration and referring services. 

Bazmi, Nisar (2017) mentioned that it is mainly be said that in the modern era of technology and computerized year and in this regard, organizations also take their system by having digital audit system and in this regard some of the challenges has been faced by the staff of internal audit and their work as well and to updating of their information to cope with some of the challenges as in the phase of manipulation of some of the frauds which is wanted. More, the obligation of recent auditing standards would create the staff of internal audit to inform their information and regulate to the existing rehearsal. (Ahmad, Bazmi, & Rehman, 2017) Auditing as a main factor in supervisory every kind of association with monetary and economic approaches helps as a category of checks and balances in the financial and managerial process of any enterprise’s setup. Apart from describing the phenomenon of auditing and operations, focus will move toward the problem areas in the explanation of governance, accounts preserved by the administration and measures elaborate in auditing administration accounts.

Theoretical framework of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

Shbail, Metlib (2017), has been said that in some of the previous decades, internal audit departments hold expressively underwritten to administrative infrastructure which as been done through value supplementary services and so, it has been become one of the most critical part. furthermore, internal auditing attain mainly enhancement in position in the preceding years, specifically in its referring role within the organizational risk management. adopting to the extensive secretarial disgraces, and also the insolvency of company, the internal audit (IA) function mainly pay emphasis on researchers and consultants similar as a momentous funder of organizational efficiency. struggled that IA would be donate company’s value through the establishment of field services involving effective audits and accessing management on numerous problems. given below the universal financial crisis in (Shbail, Metlib, & Turki, 2017), IA were changed into a specific personal usage to safe the rate of reappearance on money and to avert missed or diminished capital.  However, some researches in prose reveals that the efficiency of IA purpose might not permanently be reliable. This is predominantly factual in emerging countries, likewise where organization might not be attentive how much the IA thoughts and performs have value as recognized in the West. 

As it has been stated Bednarek, Piotr (2017) that many of the researches has been viewed. Because of the fact which has been included in internal audit has a substantial level of individuality which is related with the expansion of yearly plan of its presentation. As well as all investigators decide as to the fact that the internal audit efficiency would not be tacit exclusively as directing planned or unplanned declaration and referring actions. Moreover, one should have to refer and perhaps most unbiassed standards for fundamental the substances of internal audit movement. Furthermore, internal auditors, being the part of team of company, main purpose is to substantial their customers. (Piotr, 2017)Audit committee and some of the senior organization sometimes expect audit actions to be held out to a significant standard, involving excellent quality of audit reports, however, despite from this, they worth also the high-quality of audit activities that would enhance value to the association and the annual audit outcomes. the article antedates that the relationship among association size and IA efficiency would be predisposed by whether the company is private or public. This variable would be preserved here as a diminishing variable. That’s why, it was needed to investigate the opportunity as well as to its major consequence, this variable would be interrelate with the enterprises size in how it distresses the efficiency of internal auditing.

Methodology of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

Introduction of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

Under this section the particular material and methods are discuses in effective manners that are utilized for conducting the research. Under this section the design methodology is explores that has been used for conducting the said study. It offers the knowledge in the terms that how this study will be conducted. This section also explores that how the data will be collected in order to answers the research questions and test the hypothesis. It also explores the plans and structure of investigation that is particularly uses for answering the research questions.  It provides theoretical support to understand that which set of the methods or method can be proved as the best practices that can be implemented for the particular case; for instance for calculating the various results. The process of the research design is also explained as the set of systematic techniques that are using in the research. Simply it can be said that the research design can explore the guide to research along with the process of how it will be conducted. 

Research Philosophy of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

On the basis of the previous realities that have been explained and observed the predictions can be easily made and it also includes their interrelationship of the variables. The various rich and long historical traditions are also included in the positivism research philosophy. In our society, it has been so embedded by which the knowledge can be claimed that it cannot ground in the various positivist thoughts that have been simply dismissed as scientifically. It has been observed that experimental and empirical research always conducted by following the positivism paradigm. There is a particular successful association existing among natural and physical sciences due to the positivism research paradigm. The current study is conducted by using the positivism research philosophy because it is the good source to test the hypothesis.

Research Classification and Approach of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

The deductive research approach is adopted in order to conduct this study and this is the good approach. By the means of the hypothesis, the deductive research can be explained that can be easily retrieved from the theory proposition. In another case; it can be said that the deductive approach is linked with the process of deducting the conclusion from the numerous propositions and premises. These deductions are initiates with an expected pattern which has been tested against the various observation meanwhile induction starts with the observation that is required to find a pattern within them. When the premises are accurate in the deductive inferences than the conclusion will always be true. It always generalizes from general to specific. In order to evaluate the proposition data collection is utilized; it is related to an existing theory. Theory verification and falsification are also included in this.

Research Strategy of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

The research is conducted by using the both kinds of the research methods qualitative and quantitative. Therefore, this study is conducted by using the mixed method approach. It is concerned with the behaviors of the human and the people's acts. There several common methods of data collection that are used under the qualitative research; it includes interviews, for instance, focus group interviews and interviews. By using both of these methods the researcher can be able to explore the topic in detail and depth within a small group. From the various interactions, qualitative data can be collected in good ways.   The quantitative research methods lead towards the facts and figures that are using in the study. It also explores the tables, charts and graphs for evaluation of the data.  

Nature and Sources of Data of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

The current study is conducted by using the bity kinds and sources of the data collection as primary and secondary source of data. The primary source of data collection is included as the unvarnished data which cannot be manipulated in any kind. So, in any research, the primary data can be preferred. Even the authenticity and reliability of the research can be increases by using the primary data. Several experimental studies are based upon the primary source of data collection. Usually, it is known as the data that will be gathered specifically along with the end goals of the research venture. The primary data can be favorable for the various conditions as it can particularly be customized according to the needs of the analysis. Meanwhile the secondary source of data collection leads towards the existing and required data on the project or topic which is not directly or current application for the required chosen evaluation questions. It also includes the information which has already been protected, collected and processed another entity or researchers. It will disclose easily that which kinds of questions still required that is needed to be addressed; for this process, data has been yet collected.

Theoretical Framework of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

The key objective of this study is to evaluate the independence and performance fir the internal audit in private sectors and it is possible by creating the relationship among independence and performance and internal audit in private sectors. Hence, the dependent and independent variables are indicated in the below given figure.

Primary Framework

In order to measures the independence performance of the internal audit in private sectors the various ways and strategies has been adopted in which the operations of the managements are incudes. It shows the management is free or independents to conducts its operation and perform their duties. Effective working is another variable that has impacts on the internal audit in private sectors.  It represents that by offering the independence performance management can perform its functions effectively and they can work efficiently for the internal audit. In order to evaluate the effects of the independence for the internal audit is not such as an easy task. To explores this impacts and relationship it is necessary to measure the operations of the management and working efficiency.  

Hypotheses Development of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

H1: Independence and performance is necessity for efficient operations of the management in order to conduct internal audit

H0: Independence and performance is necessity for efficient operations of the management in order to conduct internal audit

H1: Independence and performance is necessity for effective working in order to conduct internal audit

H0: Independence and performance is necessity for effective working in order to conduct internal audit

Sampling technique and size

In the sampling survey, the weights or means are particularly applied for adjusting the data into the design sample. It is particularly observed as stratified or simple random sampling. In order to guide the practice the results from statistical theory and probability theory have been implied. Sampling is widely used for collecting information related to the population in the entire field of research. The simple random sampling techniques have been used in this study. In which the data is collected from the 150 employees of two different industries. The population is the employees of two industries that are financial industry and manufacturing industry. Data is collected from the five companies of the financial industry meanwhile remaining five companies are from the manufacturing industry and these are operating their functions in the manufacturing on the clothing and apparels.   

Research Instrument of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

There are the various tools and instruments that can use to conducting the research study. It includes observation, interviews and survey. The survey method is particularly used in this study in which the questionnaire is used as the research instrument. The self-administrated questionnaire is the good tool to explores the various views of the respondents.  The questionnaire is designed by considering the five point Likert ranging scale from strongly disagree to strongly agree. The questionnaire is contains on the major two sections from which the first section will explains the demographic profile of the respondents and in the second section the question will developed according to the constructs of the study. 

Data Analysis of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

Data will be analyzed by using the SPSS. All the above-given parameters are evaluated by using the SPSS that is the best software for measuring the impacts of the independent variable on the dependent variable. The more the data analysis tools of the SPSS is used efficiently, the easier it is to evaluate the productivity of the said company under consideration. The data analysis tools and the techniques are about making the efficient use of the programming of the SPSS.

Ethical Considerations of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

There are the several ethical considerations that can be used for resolving the various ethical issues of the study. 

• The sample members have been asked for filling the questioner with a similar period.

• The confidential statements have been designed on the top of the questioner for ensuring the details of the respondents.

• The respondents are committed or promised for not disclosing their information for any purpose. 

• The major objective for the survey questioner has reassured the participants for their participation. 

• The reference letter has been assigned from the department of the University for ensuring the respondents about the authenticity of the research.

Conclusion of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector

The entire discussion related to methods and methodology of the research can be summed up in such manners that the methods that are used to attain the research objectives, answers the research questions and test the research hypotheses is based using the mixed method as qualitative and quanititauve research methods. Both sources of the data collection are utilized as primary and secondary source of data collection. The research study based upon the positivism paradigm. The inductive research approach is used by using the questionnaire. The sample size is 150 respondents of the manufacturing and financial industries. The simple random sampling technique is used to conducting this study.    

References of the independence and performance of internal audit in private sector:

Abbott,  L.J.,  Parker,  S.,  &  Rama,  D.V.  (2007).  Corporate  governance,  audit  quality,  and  the Sarbanes- Oxley Act: Evidence from internal audit outsourcing. The Accounting Review, 82(4): 803-835.  

Adams, M.B. (1994). Agency theory and internal audit. Managerial Auditing Journal, 9(8): 8-12 

Al-Twaijry, A.A., Brierley, J.A., & Gwilliam, D.R. (2004). An examination of the relationship between internal and external audit in the Saudi Arabian corporate sector. Managerial Auditing Journal, 19(7), 929-944

Ahmad, N., Bazmi, & Rehman, M. (2017). ISSUES AND CHALLENGES FACED BY INTERNAL AUDITORS OF PRIVATE SECTOR ORGANIZATIONS. springer .

Andreson, J., & Vilo, T. (2016). How do Internal Auditors become Comfortable in their role within Risk Management?: An Empirical Study of Internal Auditors in Private Sector Companies. springer.

Carcello, J. V., Hermanson, D. R., & Raghunandan, K. (2005). Changes in internal auditing during the time of the major US accounting scandals. International Journal of Auditing. 9(2), 117–27

Ahmad, N., Bazmi, & Rehman, M. (2017). ISSUES AND CHALLENGES FACED BY INTERNAL AUDITORS OF PRIVATE SECTOR ORGANIZATIONS. springer .

Andreson, J., & Vilo, T. (2016). How do Internal Auditors become Comfortable in their role within Risk Management?: An Empirical Study of Internal Auditors in Private Sector Companies. springer.

Georgios, V. (2016). The critical role of Internal Auditing in addressing bank fraud: A conceptual framework. Case Studies Journal ISSN .

Lourens, E., & Coetzee, P. (2018). Drivers of stakeholders’ view of internal audit effectiveness. Managerial Auditing Journal.

Marc, E., Henseler, J., & Köhler, A. G. (2017). The internal audit dilemma–the impact of executive directors versus audit committees on internal auditing work. Managerial Auditing Journal.

Mihret, Getie, D., & Grant, B. (2017). The role of internal auditing in corporate governance: a Foucauldian analysis. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal.

Murad , S., Kathar, & Rathi. (2016). The Compliance with the Performance Standards of Internal Audit in Private Sector Companies in Yemen. International Journal in Management & Social Science , 305-309.

Piotr, B. (2017). THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ORGANISATIONAL ATTRIBUTES AND INTERNAL AUDIT EFFECTIVENESS. Research Papers of the Wroclaw University of Economics/Prace Naukowe Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego we Wroclawiu, 474.

Robert, K. w., Thomas, E., & Driskill, M. (2020). Understanding financial auditing from a service perspective. Accounting, Organizations and Society .

Shbail, A., Metlib, A., & Turki, A. (2017). A theoretical discussion of internal audit effectiveness in Kuwaiti industrial SMEs. International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management Sciences , 107-116.

Tânia, C., Pedrosa, I., & Costa, C. J. (2019). Open Source Software in Financial Auditing. In Organizational Auditing and Assurance in the Digital Age, 188-202.

Paape, L., Scheffe,  J., & Snoep,  P. (2003). The relationship between the  Internal Audit function 

and corporate governance in the EU – a survey. International Journal of Auditing, 7(3), 247–

62.

Sarens, G., & De Beelde (2006). The relationship between internal audit and senior management: 

A qualitative analysis of  expectations and perceptions. International Journal of  Auditing, 10, 

219-214 

Lee, H., & Yand Park, H.Y. (2016). Characteristics of the internal audit and external audit hours: Evidence from S. Korea. Managerial Auditing Journal, 31(6/67), 629-654.

Cohen, A., & Gabriel, S.  (2014). The effectiveness of internal auditing. Australian Accounting Review, 20(54), 45-65.

Pizzini, M., & Douglas, E. (2015). The impact of internal audit function quality and contribution on audit delay. A Journal of Practice and Theory, 34(1), 25-58.

Zakari, E. (2014). Basic Research methods for librarians: California, California press.