THE
MAKING
OF A
POEM
A Norton Anthology of
Poetic Forms
E D I T E D B Y
Mark Strand A N D
Eavan Boland
W. W. NORTON & COMPANY
NEW YORK • LONDON
Table of Contents
Introductory Statement xiii
On Becoming a Poet by Mark Strand xvii
Poetic Form: A Personal Encounter by Eavan Boland xxv
Acknowledgments xxxi
I VERSE FORMS
Overview 3
THE VILLANELLE
The Villanelle at a Glance 5
The History of the Form 6
The Contemporary Context 8
Ernest Downson: Villanelle of His Lady's Treasures 9
Edwin Arlington Robinson: The House on the Hill 9
William Etnpson: Missing Dates 10
Theodore Roeth^e: The Waging 11
Elizabeth Bishop: One Art 11
Dylan Thomas: Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night 12
James Merrill: The World and the Child 13
Mona Van Duyn: Condemned Site 13
John Hollander: By the Sound 14
Hay den Carruth: Saturday at the Border 15
Daryl Hine: Under the Hill 16
Marilyn Hacker: Villanelle 16
Wendy Cope: Reading Scheme 17
Jacqueline Osherow: Villanelle for the Middle of the Night 18
Close-Up of a Villanelle: "One Art" by Elizabeth Bishop 19
THE SESTINA
The Sestina at a Glance 21
The History of the Form 22
The Contemporary Context 24
Edmund Spenser: Ye wastefull woodes, bear witness of my woe 25
vi • Table of Contents
Philip Sidney: from Old Arcadia Barnabe Barnes: Sestine 4 from Parthenophil and Parthenophe
Dante Gabriel Rossetti: Sestina: Of the Lady Pietra degli Scrovigni
Algernon Charles Swinburne: Sestina
Sir Edmund Gosse: Sestina
Rudyard Kipling: Sestina of the Tramp-Royal
Ezra Pound: Sestina: Altaforte
Weldon Kees: After the Trial
Anthony Hecht: The Boo\ ofYole\
Miller Williams: The Shrinking Lonesome Sestina
Alberto Rios: Nani
Close-Up of a Sestina: "Sestina: Altaforte" by Ezra Pound
THE PANTOUM
The Pantoum at a Glance 43
The History of the Form 44
The Contemporary Context 45
Austin Dobson: In Town 45
Donald Justice: Pantoum of the Great Depression 47
Carolyn Kizer: Parents' Pantoum 48
John Ashbery: Pantoum 49
Nellie Wong: Grandmothers's Song 50
/ . D. McClatchy: The Method 51
Close-Up of a Pantoum: "Pantoum of the Great Depression"
by Donald Justice 53
THE SONNET
The Sonnet at a Glance 55
The History of the Form 56
The Contemporary Context 58
William Shakespeare: Shall I compare thee to a summer's day? 59
Michael Drayton: Farewell to Love 59
Mary Wroth: from Pamphilia to Amphilanthus 60
John Milton: Sonnet XXIII: Methought I saw my late
espoused saint 60
John Donne: Holy Sonnet: At the round earth s imagined corners 61
William Wordsworth: Composed upon Westminster Bridge,
September 3, 1802 .61
Table of Contents • vii
Percy Bysshe Shelley: Ozymandias 62 John Keats: Bright Star 62
Christina Rossetti: from Monna Innominata 63
Elizabeth Barrett Browning: from Sonnets from the
Portuguese (XLIII) 63
Gerard Manley Hopkins: Carrion Comfort 64
Edna St. Vincent Millay: What lips my lips have kissed,
and where, and why 64
Countee Cullen: From the Dar\ Tower 65
Patrick, Kavanagh: Epic 65
E. E. Cummings: from "Tulips and Chimneys" 66
George Barker: To My Mother 66
Jane Cooper: After the Bomb Tests 67
Gwen Harwood: A Game of Chess 67
Seamus Heaney: The Haw Lantern 68
Denis Johnson: Heat 68
Henri Cole: The Roman Baths at Nimes 69
Mary Jo Salter: Haifa Double Sonnet 69
Michael Palmer: Sonnet 70
Close-Up of a Sonnet: "What lips my lips have kissed, and
where, and why" by Edna St. Vincent Millay 71
THE BALLAD
The Ballad at a Glance 73
The History of the Form 74
The Contemporary Context 77
Anonymous: The Cherry-tree Carol 78
Anonymous: Sir Patrick Spens 79
Anonymous: The Wife of Usher's Well 81
Anonymous: My Boy Willie 82
John GreenleafWhittier: The Changeling 83
Oscar Wilde: from The Ballad of Reading Gaol 86
Elinor Wylie: Peter and John 88
Louis MacNeice: Bagpipe Music 90
John Betjeman: Death in Leamington 91
Ogden Nash: The Tale of Custard the Dragon 92
Gwendolyn Brooks: We Real Cool " 94
viii • Table of Contents
Sterling A. Brown: Riverbank Blues 94
W. S. Merwin: Ballad of John Cable and Three Gentlemen 95
Close-Up of a Ballad: "We Real Cool" by Gwendolyn Brooks 99
BLANK VERSE
Blank Verse at a Glance 101
The History of the Form 102
The Contemporary Context 104
Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey: from his translation of
The Aeneid 105
Christopher Marlowe: from Tamburlaine the Great 105
William Shakespeare: from Julius Caesar 106
John Milton: from Paradise Lost 107
Charlotte Smith: from Beachy Head 108
William Wordsworth: from The Prelude 109
Alfred, Lord Tennyson: Ulysses 110
Edward Thomas: Rain 112
Robert Frost: Directive 113
Richard Wilbur: Lying 114
Richard Howard: Stanzas in Bloomsbury 117
Close-Up of Blank Verse: "Directive" by Robert Frost 119
THE HEROIC COUPLET
The Heroic Couplet at a Glance 121
The History of the Form 122
Aemilia Lanyer: from The Description of Cooke-ham 123
Anne Bradstreet: The Author to Her Book 123
Anne Finch: A Letter to Daphnis, April 2, 1685 124
John Dryden.from Absalom and Achitophel 125
Samuel Johnson: from The Vanity of Human Wishes 126
Phillis Wheatley: To S. M., a Young African Painter,
on Seeing His Works 127
Oliver Goldsmith: from The Deserted Village 128
Alexander Pope: from An Essay on Criticism 129
Robert Browning: My Last Duchess 130
Wilfred Owen: Strange Meeting 132
Thorn Gunn: The J Car 133
Close-Up of the Heroic Couplet: "My Last Duchess" by Robert
Browning 135
Table of Contents • ix
THE STANZA
The Stanza at a Glance 136
The History of the Form 137
The Contemporary Context 139
Geoffrey Chaucer: from Troilus and Criseyde 140
Edmund Spenser: from The Faerie Queene 141
Thomas Wyatt: They Flee from Me 142
George Herbert: Easter Wings 143
William Blake: The Tyger 143
George Gordon, Lord Byron: So We'll Go No More A-Roving 144
Emily Dickinson: I died for Beauty—but was scarce 145
Thomas Hardy: The Convergence of the Twain 145
Walter de la Mare: The Song of the Mad Prince 146
Charlotte Mew: A Quoi Bon Dire 147
Jean Toomer: Song of the Son 147
Claude McKay: The Tropics in New York 148
Sara Teasdale: Night Song at Amalfi 149
Stevie Smith: Not Waving but Drowning 149
Yvor Winters: On Teaching the Young 149
Robert Hayden: Those Winter Sundays 150
Muriel Rukeyser: Yes 150
Carol Ann Duffy: Warming Her Pearls 151
Carol Muske: Epith 152
Close-Up of a Stanza: "I died for Beauty—but was scarce"
by Emily Dickinson 154
II METER
Meter at a Glance 159
A Brief Checklist of Further Reading on Meter 161
III S H A P I N G FORMS
Overview 165
THE ELEGY
Overview 167
William Dunbar: Lament for the Makaris 168
Mary Sidney Herbert, Countess of Pembroke: If Ever Hapless
Woman Had a Cause 171
x • Table of Contents
Ben Jonson: On My First Son 172
Katherine Philips: Epitaph. On her Son H.P. at St. Syth's Church
where her body also lies Interred 172
John Milton: Lycidas 173
Anne Bradstreet: Here Follows Some Verses upon the Burning of
Our House July 10th, 1666. Copied out of a Loose Paper 178
Thomas Gray: Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard 180
Emily Bronte: R. Alcona to J. Brenzaida 184
Walt Whitman: O Captain! My Captain! 185
Matthew Arnold: Dover Beach 185
Ivor Gurney: To His Love 187
John Crowe Ransom: Bells for John Whiteside's Daughter 187
Louise Bogan: Tears in Sleep 188
W. H. Auden: In Memory of W. B. Yeats 188
Robert Lowell: from The Quaker Graveyard in Nantucket 191
John Berryman: Dream Song 324 194
Frank Bidart: To the Dead 194
Edward Hirsch: In Memoriam Paul Celan 196
Garrett Hongo: The Legend 197
Douglas Crase: The Elegy for New York 198
Mark Doty :Tiara 1 9 9
Gjertrud Schnackenberg: Supernatural Love 200
Thomas Kinsella: Mirror in February 202
David St. John: Iris 203
Paula Meehan: Child Burial 204
Rosanna Warren: Song 205
THE PASTORAL
Overview 207
Christopher Marlowe: The Passionate Shepherd to
His Love 209
William Shakespeare: from Love's Labor's Lost 210
Andrew Marvell: The Garden 210
William Wordsworth: To My Sister 213
John Keats: Ode on a Grecian Urn 214
A. E. Housman: Loveliest of Trees 215
Francis Ledwidge: The Wife ofLlew 216
Babette Deutsch: Urban Pastoral 216
Table of Contents • xi
Janet Lewis: Remembered Morning
Ted Hughes: The Thought-Fox
Philip Larkjn: The Explosion
James Wright: Lying in a Hammock at William Duffy's Farm
in Pine Island, Minnesota
Derek Walcott: Midsummer, Tobago
Galway Kinnell: The Bear
Amy Clampitt: Fog
Jane Kenyan: Let Evening Come
Philip Levine: Smoke
Robert Hass: Meditation at Lagunitas
John Koethe: From the Porch
Alfred Corn: A Walrus Tuskjrom Alaska
Charles Wright: Looking West from Laguna Beach at
Night
Les Murray: The Broad Bean Sermon
Lucie Broc\-Broido: Of the Finished World
Thylias Moss: Tornados
C. K. Williams: Loss
Timothy Steele: Waiting for the Storm
Mary Kinzie: An Engraving of Blake
Eilean Ni Chuilleandin: Pygmalion's Image
Louise Gliick: Mock Orange
Mary Oliver: The Black Walnut Tree
Medbh McGuckian: Gateposts
Susan Prospere: Heart of the Matter
Mary O'Malley: Shoeing the Currach
THE ODE
Overview
Percy Bysshe Shelley: Ode to the West Wind
John Keats: To Autumn
Henry Timrod: Ode
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow: The Fire of Driftwood
Hart Crane: from The Bridge
Marianne Moore: The Paper Nautilus
Judith Wright: Australia 1970
Charles Simic: Miracle Glass Co.
217
217
218
219
220
220
223
224
224
226
227
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
233
233
234
235
236
236
238
240
241
243
244
245
247
248
249
250
xii • Table of Contents
Howard Nemerov: The Blue Swallows 250 Robert Creeley: America 252
Robert Pinsky: Ode to Meaning 252
Joy Harjo: Perhaps the World Ends Here 254
IV OPEN FORMS
Overview 259
W. B. Yeats: The Circus Animals' Desertion 260
T. S. Eliot: The Love Song ofj. Alfred Prufrock 262
Langston Hughes: I, Too 266
Wallace Stevens: The Idea of Order at Key West 266
William Carlos Williams: Spring and All 268
Allen Ginsberg: America 269
Frank O'Hara: Ave Maria 272
Denise Levertov: Uncertain Oneiromancy 273
Sylvia Plath: Daddy 274
Adrienne Rich: Diving into the Wreck 276
Lucille Clifton: move 279
Sharon Olds: The Language of the Brag 280
Carolyn Forche: The Colonel 281
Ai: The German Army, Russia, 1943 282
Yusef Komunyakaa: Starlight Scope Myopia 282
Jorie Graham: Reading Plato 284
Close-Up of Open Forms: "Diving into the Wreck" by
Adrienne Rich 287
A Brief Glossary 289
Biographies and Further Reading 293
Suggested Reading 335
Credits 337
General Index 349
Index of Authors, Titles, and First Lines 357