Loading...

Messages

Proposals

Stuck in your homework and missing deadline? Get urgent help in $10/Page with 24 hours deadline

Get Urgent Writing Help In Your Essays, Assignments, Homeworks, Dissertation, Thesis Or Coursework & Achieve A+ Grades.

Privacy Guaranteed - 100% Plagiarism Free Writing - Free Turnitin Report - Professional And Experienced Writers - 24/7 Online Support

Fallacies and Judging Arguments

30/10/2020 Client: saeed Deadline: 3 days

  


Homework Assignment 3 on Fallacies and Judging Arguments- Chapter 5 Faulty


Reasoning Thinking Critically: Should DUI Homicide Be Prosecuted as Murder? (60 Minutes) A prosecuting attorney in New York is bringing charges of murder against individuals who have killed other people while driving under the influence. The attorney argues that everyone understands that driving while under the influence poses risks for the driver and for other people, including the risk of a fatal accident. The statutes provide for charges of 'depraved indifference' when one's behavior results in the unintended but foreseeable death of another human being.


More to read: Essay on Enforcement of Public and Community Safety Laws


Defense attorneys argue, among other things, that the laws pertaining to murder were never intended to be applied in this way. The debate was captured by CBS's 60 Minutes in a segment that aired on August 2, 2009. Review the 60 Minute Segment.


Assignment: Create a list of Fallacies you encountered while viewing the 60 Minute segment and reading “When Murder loses it Meaning”. You will need Fallacies for both sides of the argument. Explain each fallacy, and how it pertains to the video. Please address them as follows:


1. DUI Homicide should be Prosecuted as Murder – List Fallacies Found by name, and describe


2. DUI Homicide Should not be Prosecuted as Murder – List Fallacies Found by name, and describe


3. Which Argument had the least Fallacies? 4. After completing your evaluation, using the Critical Thinking skills


learned so far in evaluating Claims, what is your opinion on the Prosecutor Claims below. Do not allow your emotions to dictate your evaluation. Do not allow the fact that he had no intentions to kill, change your thinking. Evaluate strictly by the law. If you were presented with this case and had to decide if he can be prosecuted for Murder, do you believe “Depraved Indifference” applies in this specific case? Has your opinion changed, since the first viewing of this video during class? Has your first reaction changed after looking at additional facts? Example: Limo’s do not have seatbelts, could the Limo be a contributing factor to the little girl’s death. Was the Limo speeding? Are there any other factors that are not being considered? As a Judge, how would you have ruled to the charge?


• Everyone understands that driving while under the influence poses risks for the driver and for other people, including the risk of a fatal accident. The statutes provide for charges of 'depraved indifference' when one's behavior results in the unintended but foreseeable death of another human being.


Also read: Death Penalty Argumentative Essay Sample


IS 100 Fall 2020: Homework Assignment 3 on Fallacies and Judging Arguments- Chapter 5 Faulty Reasoning


Background information: To Convict a person of 2nd degree: The basis for the second-degree murder charge was the "depraved indifference" theory: Penal Law Section 125.25(2) states that a person is guilty of depraved indifference murder, when 'under circumstances evincing a depraved indifference to human life, he recklessly engages in conduct which creates a grave risk of death to another person, and thereby causes the death of another person.'


For many years, this language confused almost everyone and led to prosecutors commonly charging murders as both intentional and depraved indifference, under the theory that if it wasn't the first, it had to be the second, hoping that if they threw both at the wall, something would stick. This changed with the Court of Appeals decision in People v. Payne, where the Court held that depraved indifference referred to the defendant's state of mind, not to an external view of how horrible his conduct was.


The defendant must have known and appreciated the potentially fatal consequences of his action and made the active decision to engage in the conduct nonetheless.


Click on: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuac5zZ1gqk


Go to Youtube And search for 60 minutes DWR is it Murder


The suggested approach, use your internet search skills to find out more on this topic and the law’s intent.


Article on Next Page.


http://www.law.cornell.edu/nyctap/I04_0125.htm


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuac5zZ1gqk


IS 100 Fall 2020: Homework Assignment 3 on Fallacies and Judging Arguments- Chapter 5 Faulty Reasoning


When Murder Loses its Meaning


First, it was Robert Heidgen. Now, Franklin McPherson, who was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison upon his Nassau County conviction for murder. That's the maximum sentence, which was imposed yesterday by Judge George Peck. A jury convicted McPherson, 21, of Deer Park, of second-degree murder in June for killing Leslie Burgess, 44, of Amityville.


McPherson drove his Lexus 5 miles in the wrong direction and killed Burgess when he crashed into his eastbound Jeep last October. He broke his legs in the crash. It's not to say that McPherson was an innocent man. He was not. It's not to say that McPherson's conduct was excusable. It was not.


But Franklin McPherson did not commit murder. To say he did cheapens the crime for the victims of real murders, and subjects it to the transitory whims of the prosecutor. McPherson was drunk. According to his lawyer, Dennis Lemke, he was far drunker than the .19 claimed by the prosecution. Dennis is a good trial lawyer, but he's not really a "law man," as they say. Neither was Steve LaMagna, Heidgen's lawyer. It's unclear whether a good "law man" would have had any impact on the trial court. Most of the judges aren't "law men" either.


The basis for the second-degree murder charge was the "depraved indifference" theory: Penal Law Section 125.25(2) states that a person is guilty of depraved indifference murder, when 'under circumstances evincing a depraved indifference to human life, he recklessly engages in conduct which creates a grave risk of death to another person, and thereby causes the death of another person.' For many years, this language confused almost everyone in New York, and led to prosecutors commonly charging murders as both intentional and depraved indifference, under the theory that if it wasn't the first, it had to be the second, hoping that if they threw both at the wall, something would stick. This changed with the Court of Appeals decision in People v. Payne, where the Court held that depraved indifference referred to the defendant's state of mind, not to an external view of how horrible his conduct was.


The defendant must have known and appreciated the potentially fatal consequences of his action and made the active decision to engage in the conduct nonetheless.


The conduct engaged in by McPherson, as well as Heidgen, was drinking alcohol. It was drinking to excess. And then driving a car in this drunken state. But neither the Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice, nor the assistant who tried both the Heidgen and McPherson cases, Maureen McCormick, will say


http://blog.simplejustice.us/2007/03/01/murder-in-a-martini.aspx


http://www.newsday.com/news/local/nassau/ny-limurd0917%2C0%2C5148647.story


http://www.law.cornell.edu/nyctap/I04_0125.htm


IS 100 Fall 2020: Homework Assignment 3 on Fallacies and Judging Arguments- Chapter 5 Faulty Reasoning


this.


Instead, the explanation goes like this: After the McPherson verdict, Nassau District Attorney Kathleen Rice said he, like Heidgen, acted in a way that showed he was guilty of depraved-indifference murder, meaning he acted recklessly, knew the risks of his actions and ignored them.


"This defendant's preventable actions led to this inevitable tragedy," Rice said. Who, amongst the public, would disagree with Rice? But that doesn't make this a murder. And notice how nobody mentions that it's not like McPherson walks free if he's not charged with murder. There's always a 10 year sentence for manslaughter available. Or criminally negligent homicide, though that crime doesn't have that cool, violent ring to it, and "reckless" isn't as nasty as "depraved".


Depraved is perhaps one of the smartest words a legislator every approved. It immediately evokes an image of Freddy Kruger, evil personified. What good is a crime if it doesn't evoke an image of evil? That's why misprision of felony is so rarely charged. No visceral reaction. No mental image. It's boring.


McCormick's explanation doesn't add much to the public's understanding either: Maureen McCormick, the prosecutor who won both convictions, said, "The Heidgen case was not a fluke or a political stunt, and it was not because it was an adorable little girl who was killed." She was referring to 7-year-old Katie Flynn, a victim in that crash. "The facts are what made these cases murder." As has become so very popular, an appeal to emotion is hidden behind vague things that seem to make sense, provided one doesn't let things like the law get in the way. This has long been the push by advocacy groups such as MADD to create a growing public intolerance for drunk driving, and create the impression that ever-increasingly harsh charges and punishments are the only way to stop this plague.


The problem is that these groups have been so successful, and politicians have basked in the reflected glow of this success, that when reality gets in the way of these PR campaigns (meaning when convictions for murder do nothing to stem the tide of drunk driving), they need to find yet a deeper, harsher, more horrific penalty to impose. Yeah, if only they got the death penalty, that would fix the problem!


The reason why they are slaying imaginary dragons is that this is not the crime of murder. It never was, and never will be. Drinking too much and getting drunk is not something that one contemplates as part of a violent crime. Driving home drunk, every stinking drunk, isn't meant to cause harm. It's meant to get home.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Misprision_of_felony


IS 100 Fall 2020: Homework Assignment 3 on Fallacies and Judging Arguments- Chapter 5 Faulty Reasoning


There are no real similarities between shooting a gun into a crowd and driving home drunk. The former serves no purpose other than to cause harm. There is no harmful purpose in the latter. The former has a high likelihood of killing someone. The latter could well kill someone but has only a minute probability of occurrence. The former is murder. The latter is not.


The forces against drunk driving are empowered by these convictions and the public appreciation of what a wonderful job they are doing to protect their children from death at the hands of these vicious drunks. I'm no apologist for drunk driving. I think it's an incredibly wrong thing to do. But I'm also no fan of overcharging, of taking a lesser crime and making it greater to curry ignorant public favor.


No doubt Dennis Lemke will be filing a notice of appeal shortly, and I hope that the lawyer assigned to do the appeal will do an exceptional job. The appeal in Heidgen is still pending. As of now, there's nothing to suggest that an appellant's brief has been filed with the Second Department. In all likelihood, this issue won't be resolved until it reaches the Court of Appeals.


There is absolutely no question that the convictions for murder must be reversed. And this reversal will not be a slap in the face of society, or the prosecution, or the Mothers against Whatever, but return to grounding convictions in the law rather than the appeal to raw emotion.


Get drunk, turn onto the off-ramp instead of the on-ramp, and get convicted of murder. Is this really what you want?


· IS 100 Fall 2019: Homework Assignment 3 on Fallacies and Judging Arguments- Chapter 5 Faulty Reasoning


· IS 100 Fall 2017: Homework Assignment 3 on Fallacies and Judging Arguments- Chapter 5 Faulty Reasoning

Homework is Completed By:

Writer Writer Name Amount Client Comments & Rating
Instant Homework Helper

ONLINE

Instant Homework Helper

$36

She helped me in last minute in a very reasonable price. She is a lifesaver, I got A+ grade in my homework, I will surely hire her again for my next assignments, Thumbs Up!

Order & Get This Solution Within 3 Hours in $25/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 3 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 6 Hours in $20/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 6 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 12 Hours in $15/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 12 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

6 writers have sent their proposals to do this homework:

Innovative Writer
Top Grade Essay
Helping Hand
Essay Writing Help
Essay & Assignment Help
Coursework Assignment Help
Writer Writer Name Offer Chat
Innovative Writer

ONLINE

Innovative Writer

I have read and understood all your initial requirements, and I am very professional in this task, I would be the best choice for this project, I am a PhD writer with 6-7 years of experience and can deliver quality notes to tight deadlines. I can generally compile up to 10 pages of lecture notes per day. I am known as Unrivaled Quality, Written to Standard, providing Plagiarism-free woork, and Always on Time

$55 Chat With Writer
Top Grade Essay

ONLINE

Top Grade Essay

Working on this platform from a couple of time with exposure of dynamic writing skills gathered with years experience on different other websites.

$62 Chat With Writer
Helping Hand

ONLINE

Helping Hand

Hello, I an ranked top 10 freelancers in academic and contents writing. I can write and updated your personal statement with great quality and free of plagiarism as I am a master writer with 5 years experience in similar ps and research writing projects. Kindly send me more information about your project. You can award me any time as I am ready to start your project curiously. Waiting for your positive response. Thank you!

$55 Chat With Writer
Essay Writing Help

ONLINE

Essay Writing Help

I am a qualified and experienced Writer, Researcher, Tutor, analyst and Consultant. I hold MBA (Strategic Management) (Finance and Marketing) & CPA.K (Accounting and Finance.)

$62 Chat With Writer
Essay & Assignment Help

ONLINE

Essay & Assignment Help

I have a Master’s degree and experience of more than 5 years in this industry, I have worked on several similar projects of Research writing, Academic writing & Business writing and can deliver A+ quality writing even to Short Deadlines. I have successfully completed more than 2100+ projects on different websites for respective clients. I can generally write 10-15 pages daily. I am interested to hear more about the project and about the subject matter of the writing. I will deliver Premium quality work without Plagiarism at less price and time. Get quality work by awarding this project to me, I look forward to getting started for you as soon as possible. Thanks!

$55 Chat With Writer
Coursework Assignment Help

ONLINE

Coursework Assignment Help

Hey, I have gone through your job posting and become very much interested in working with you.I can deliver professional content as per your requirements. I am a multi-skilled person with sound proficiency in the English language for being a native writer who worked on several similar projects of content writing and can deliver quality content to tight deadlines. I am available for both online and offline writing jobs with the promise of offering an incredibly responsive and supreme level of customer service. Thanks!

$55 Chat With Writer

Let our expert academic writers to help you in achieving a+ grades in your homework, assignment, quiz or exam.

Similar Homework Questions

Network management advantages and disadvantages - Practical aviation and aerospace law workbook answer key - Emerging Threats counterness - The new colossus lazarus analysis - Food lab report - Bituthene 4000 data sheet - Soap note - Mentor 1 - Problem 4 2a fundamental accounting principles - Bay hopper bus timetable tauranga - Solid footing accounting cycle project 12e - Chaucer uses the pilgrimage primarily as a device to - Transform the age to a z score - Two drivers tom and jerry - Duvall and hill family development theory - Alibaba case study harvard - Starbucks eastern shore center - CJ 3200 MOD 4 DB 1 - 8st 9lbs in kg - Nissan case study total quality management - Redox reaction examples everyday life - One sentence summary examples - Boykin and schoenhofer nursing theory - Body fortress shred abolic igniter reviews - The production budget for manner company - Southwestern university traffic problems case study solution - Nursing pediatrics case study - Practice management software does all of the following except - Writing for the mass media 9th edition pdf free - Why was john bender in detention - Memo - Apt 9 lisa indexer wallet - Acro criminal records office - Data analysis investigatory project - Sheffield city council job vacancies - 4.1 compute gross profit for april - Https www google com images cleardot gif - Aat anti money laundering toolkit - The biology of osmosis jones answer key the zit explodes - Brisbane city council outlook - Optimal olefins m sdn bhd - Section 248b corporations act - Research paper - Vroom yetton jago model pdf - The "sacred experiment" carried out near present-day san diego - Drac and the gremlin teaching notes - Vita vacumat 6000 m service manual - Middle ground argument essay - Interval level of measurement example questions - Third order rate constant units - ¿qué le vas a ____ a la quinceañera? - Should you do if your lender rejects your loan application - Week 2 - Organizational behavior a practical problem solving approach - Institute of medicine report the future of nursing - Dupont case study analysis - Lawn mower shop penrith - Fons international telecom equipment trading - Andrew danks neurosurgeon frankston - HSE 8 - Quba sails st ives - Social purpose english language - Drag the labels onto the diagram to identify the parts of a knee-jerk reflex. - Trigonometry - Roles of the Court Paper - Why do good managers sometimes make bad decisions - Differences between aquatic and terrestrial environments - Millionaire cake alpine bakery - Need 1 page discussion - 01.10 macbeth: the power of words worksheet - The road to winter 2 - Taming the anger monster anne davidson - Pestel analysis of kfc - I need 2 assignments: 1 Quantitative & another Qualitative (I attached both chosen articles for the papers) - Clc development powerpoint presentation - Thomas kratzer is the purchasing manager for the headquarters - How to calculate capacity cushion - WK11 ASSIGN 6051 - Case Study - Seminar Reaction Paper - The President, the Congress, and the Economy - Business Plan - Looking for Embroidered Custom Patches in the UK – Any Suggestions? - Estée lauder beyond the magic an unauthorized biography - Advantages and disadvantages of multidivisional structure - Tell the story of a significant experience that contributed to your current relationship with learning something new in a particular context. - Cyber Law - assignment 1 - X treme vitamin company is considering two investments - Week 1 discussion - Jessica gutierrez 30th ward - Thomas coupling series 52 - The flowers by alice walker worksheet answers - Provide services to customers on account - Rick stein shanghai pork belly - Goldhawks scooter club liverpool - Four components of an information system - Strategic marketing multiple choice questions - Criticism of structuralism in psychology - Critiquing Research Articles - Blackadders property for sale broughty ferry