Loading...

Messages

Proposals

Stuck in your homework and missing deadline? Get urgent help in $10/Page with 24 hours deadline

Get Urgent Writing Help In Your Essays, Assignments, Homeworks, Dissertation, Thesis Or Coursework & Achieve A+ Grades.

Privacy Guaranteed - 100% Plagiarism Free Writing - Free Turnitin Report - Professional And Experienced Writers - 24/7 Online Support

From cruelty to goodness by philip hallie

17/03/2021 Client: saad24vbs Deadline: 3 days

C H A P T E R 1GOOD AND EVIL

Almost no one doubts that cruelty is wrong. But philosophers differ on how to explain what is wrong about acting cruelly and even about the meaning of right and wrong. So we have various systems of moral theory. Inevitably we have the possibility that a philosopher may devise a pseudo-ethical doctrine that loses sight of basic intuitions about human dignity and elementary decency. When such a doctrine achieves currency and popular respectability, it becomes a powerful force for evil. For then, what passes as conventional wisdom allows the average person to behave in reprehensible but conventionally acceptable ways.

In Chapter One we find examples of the ways the moral intuitions of the indi- vidual may conflict with publicly accepted principles that are not grounded in re- spect for human dignity. In the first two selections, “From Cruelty to Goodness” by Philip Hallie and “The Conscience of Huckleberry Finn” by Jonathan Bennett, the moral failure of principle is easy to diagnose. A dominant group adopts a phi- losophy that permits it to confine its moral concern to those inside the group, treat- ing outsiders as beyond the moral pale; their pain, their dignity, even their very lives merit no moral consideration. Huckleberry Finn, being white, is within the moral domain. His mentors have taught him that he does not owe moral behavior to slaves. Yet Huck treats Jim, the runaway slave, as if he too deserves the respect due a white person. And therein lies Huck’s conflict. Everything he conventionally believes tells him he is doing wrong in helping Jim elude his pursuers.

Mark Twain’s account of the conflict between official “book” morality and the ground-level morality of an innately decent and sympathetic person is one of the best in literature. Usually the conflict is embodied in two protagonists (Victor Hugo’s novel Les Misérables is an example), but Huck Finn’s conflict is within himself. And we are glad that his decency is stronger than his book morality. Both Jonathan Bennett and Philip Hallie quote the Nazi officer Heinrich Himmler, one of the fathers of the “final solution,” as a spokesman for those who advocate suspend- ing all moral feeling toward a particular group. Interestingly, Himmler considered

1

© C

en ga

ge L

ea rn

in g.

A ll

rig ht

s r es

er ve

d. N

o di

st rib

ut io

n al

lo w

ed w

ith ou

t e xp

re ss

a ut

ho riz

at io

n.

himself all the more moral for being above pitying the children and other innocent victims outside the domain of moral consideration. Indeed, we hear stories of Germans who were conscience-stricken because—against their principles—they allowed some Jews to escape.

Our dismay at man’s inhumanity to man is qualified by the inspiring example of the residents of the French village Le Chambon-sur-Lignon who acted together to care for and save 6,000 Jews, mostly children, from the Nazis. Le Chambon is said to have been the safest place in Europe for a Jew during World War II. From his studies of the village, Hallie concludes that Le Chambon residents successfully com- bated evil because they never allowed themselves to be blind to the victim’s point of view. “When we are blind to that point of view we can countenance and perpetrate cruelty with impunity.” The true morality of Le Chambon drives out false and hyp- ocritical Nazi “decencies” that ignore the most elementary moral intuitions and that permit and encourage the horrors of Himmler’s and Hitler’s Germany.

The advent of totalitarianisms in the twentieth century has given rise to large concentration camps in which millions of innocents were incarcerated, tormented, and murdered. Moral philosophers have written much about the amorality of the people who planned, built, and administered these camps. Tzvetan Todorov and Anne Applebaum, in the selections we have chosen, focus their attention on the morale of those who lived in conditions of unspeakable horror but who managed to survive to tell their stories. Experiments such as those conducted by Yale Univer- sity Psychologist Stanley Milgram in the 1960s dramatically suggest that even ordi- nary men and women living in ordinary times can be moved to inflict grave harm on hapless innocents.

In his selection, Josiah Royce defends a morality that respects human dignity. Beginning from the axiom that we owe respect and decency to our neighbor, Royce confronts the question that the Nazis and all those who ignore the humanity of spe- cial groups pervert: Who, then, are our neighbors? Royce answers that our neigh- bors include anyone with feelings: “Pain is pain, joy is joy, everywhere even as in thee.” Royce calls this the moral insight. He points out that treating strangers with care and solicitude is hardly unnatural; for each of us, our future self is like a stranger to us, yet we are naturally concerned with the welfare of that stranger.

The moral blindness that is the opposite of Royce’s moral insight has tragic consequences for the victims whose humanity is ignored. The point is taken up by Hallie, who complains that some moral philosophers who concentrate on the motives and character of evildoers often fail to attend to the suffering of the victims. Hallie argues that it is not the character of evildoers that is the crucial element of evil, but rather that evil mainly consists in the suffering caused by the perpetrators of evil. For Hallie, evil is what evil does. He therefore takes sharp issue with Bennett for saying that the Nazi who professes to be affected by the suffering he causes is in some respects morally superior to theologians like Jonathan Edwards who never actually harmed anyone but who claim to have no pity for the sinner who would suffer the torments of the damned.

Do we punish people for the evil they do or for what they are? Herman Mel- ville’s Billy Budd is a classic on this question. Billy Budd is an exceptionally pure and good person who has committed a crime. We are tempted to say that Budd’s fine character exculpates his crime. But this could be a dangerous doctrine if

Homework is Completed By:

Writer Writer Name Amount Client Comments & Rating
Instant Homework Helper

ONLINE

Instant Homework Helper

$36

She helped me in last minute in a very reasonable price. She is a lifesaver, I got A+ grade in my homework, I will surely hire her again for my next assignments, Thumbs Up!

Order & Get This Solution Within 3 Hours in $25/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 3 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 6 Hours in $20/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 6 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 12 Hours in $15/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 12 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

6 writers have sent their proposals to do this homework:

Instant Assignment Writer
Quick Mentor
Professional Coursework Help
Solutions Store
Top Class Engineers
Homework Guru
Writer Writer Name Offer Chat
Instant Assignment Writer

ONLINE

Instant Assignment Writer

I have read and understood all your initial requirements, and I am very professional in this task.

$19 Chat With Writer
Quick Mentor

ONLINE

Quick Mentor

Give me a chance, i will do this with my best efforts

$20 Chat With Writer
Professional Coursework Help

ONLINE

Professional Coursework Help

I will cover all the points which you have mentioned in your project details.

$27 Chat With Writer
Solutions Store

ONLINE

Solutions Store

Hello, I an ranked top 10 freelancers in academic and contents writing. I can write and updated your personal statement with great quality and free of plagiarism

$26 Chat With Writer
Top Class Engineers

ONLINE

Top Class Engineers

I have read and understood all your initial requirements, and I am very professional in this task.

$15 Chat With Writer
Homework Guru

ONLINE

Homework Guru

I have read your project details. I can do this within your deadline.

$27 Chat With Writer

Let our expert academic writers to help you in achieving a+ grades in your homework, assignment, quiz or exam.

Similar Homework Questions

Metric hi lo screws - Isaac rosenberg poem dead man's dump - ACCOUNTING - Dan john mass made simple pdf - Some lessons from the assembly line andrew braaksma - Sas graph symbols list - What is the cost for the 3% highest domestic airfares? - World History to 1500 - A manager of an investment center can improve roi by - Fellow craft square and compass - Stewie don t forget the taint - Digital capacitance meter using 555 timer - How does lowest tco differ from lowest purchase price - How to create a climate graph in excel - Www rgc aberdeen sch uk - Solving exponential equations with ln - Sinusoidal functions as mathematical models ferris wheel problem - Strayer university computer science - Case study - Quiz 1 discovering the foundations of effective communication - Difference between triangle and quadrilateral - Employ: Research Process Evaluation Title: Research - Wgu leadership principles - 2.7 cm equals how many inches - Discussion Board Questions - Adeline yen mah siblings now - 21st century interdisciplinary themes - Merge sort pros and cons - Marketing plan presentation - Marginal rate of technical substitution ppt - Business and Society 400 word essay - Paper - Monitoring employees on networks unethical or good business - Simnet office 2016 integrated applications project 3 - Axe detailer ball cleaner - Spatial organization presentation - Https openstax org details books american government - Compensation adequate problem sleuth book one - Accounting cycle project - Ethanol to ethanal equation - +91-8306951337 get your love back by vashikaran IN Erode - Casio fx 82 normal distribution - Estimate the quotient 555 divided by 8 - 34 graham road gooseberry hill - Route 121 bus schedule - What caused claire's miscarriage - 2 - Heart of darkness kurtz mistress - Order 2286141: Summarize - Sustainbility Essay - Explain nitration of benzene with mechanism - Drafting legal documents principles and practices - Nursing diagnosis for tourette syndrome - Ff k 24s twsh - Bpi philam life tower - How to do a cost benefit analysis excel - Overview of Public Health Nursing - Year 6 sats 2014 - Writing assignment - Movie rental project in java - Pick one of the following terms for your research: collaboration, divisional structure, functional structure, horizontal structure, matrix structure, outsourcing, reengineering, teams, vertical linkages, or virtual team. - Super simple songs numbers to 20 - Probability distribution ti 84 - Why are information systems vulnerable to destruction error and abuse - Ethical issues in health professional - Computer networking textbook free download - Excel Work for tomorrow!!! - Paul hynes sr7 for sale - The adept mind is one that - Toyota weaknesses 2018 - 2015 methods exam 2 solutions - 01.11 macbeth observation interpretation and critique - Social psychology aronson 6th edition pdf - Being a chink by christine leong full text - Write a essay - What Are The Drawbacks Of Employing A Write My Assignment For Me Service? - Hw - Types of international capital market - French role play script - Social order crimes - Essay guru only 1 - Keune colour numbering system - Notice of address for service federal circuit court - Naoh and vinegar titration lab - Mcconnell brue flynn microeconomics 19e answers - John gray bought a basic car - Unique variance multiple regression spss - Coca cola brand ambassador program - Using microsoft access 2016 independent project 1 5 - Organisational structure of kfc india - Research paper 3-4 pages not including cover and title page due in 3 days. Possible? - Schroder investment management ltd - Bobby rydell shows spotlight 29 casino february 4 - A dream deferred poem - Sir gawain and the green knight answer key - International Communications Paper - Think safe work safe home safe - CASE STUDY - Cube root of 999 - Longchamp hong kong price 2018