Hyperbole in i have a dream speech

Chapter 8

Sierra wants to give a speech about sports. She has some great ideas about the role of sports in modern society and has done the research to make her points. But she has a problem: There is serious competition for her speech—sports! Sports, in-person and televised, are exciting, and she knows that 's why people like sports so much. But that means they won't be interested in a bunch of dry arguments and data about sports. So Sierra has a public speaking challenge: How can she give a sports talk that will be nearly as exciting as the real thing? Sierra has to make the right choices about verbal style.

Overview

Speakers often worry about the way they say words— which is important (note that delivery is the subject of the next chapter). But the words you choose to say are just as, or more, important. In ordinary life, we don't think about our words too much; we just talk. Yet, when we want our words to have impact, we should choose them carefully. In addition, we have to take responsibility for our words, and words sometimes can be hurtful or offensive. In a public speaking situation, when we expect people to remember our words and take them seriously, we will have to spend more time thinking about them and choosing them.

MindTap®

Start with a warm-up activity about Sierra 's speech, and review the chapter 's Learning Objectives.

INTRODUCTION: WHAT IS STYLE, AND WHY DOES IT MATTER?

Now that you have figured out the basic thrust of what you want to say and how you want to organize and support it, the next challenge is to figure out exactly how to express the ideas you want to convey—in other words, the considerations of Style , the wording choices you will make to achieve the goals of your speech.

________

style Word choices made to achieve the goals of a speech.

________

MindTap®

Read, highlight, and take notes online.

This chapter will give you a set of stylistic techniques for making word choices that you can integrate into your speeches. We can't tell you how to phrase everything in your speech, because so much about phrasing is unique to you as a speaker and to the audience you are addressing. But we can offer a number of tried-and-true stylistic forms that have been used effectively in great speeches. In the next chapter, we'll complete our discussion of delivery by discussing the nonverbal parts of speaking; of course, there is sense in which that is a kind of “style,” but for this chapter (and this book), “style” means the choice of words and use of language.

Style exploits one of the most powerful features of language—that there are many different ways of saying the same thing. For instance, you could say, “It 's hot outside, and I'm tired.” Or you might say, “It 's an oven outside, and I'm beat.” Or perhaps you like more formal expressions: “Oh, this insufferable heat—it 's left me feeling fatigued.” If you try, you probably could come up with dozens of different ways of saying the same thing.

Expressing your thoughts in words is an art of making choices. You have choices about how you say what you want to say, and these choices are important because different choices can convey different impressions about your topic. Striking just the right verbal style for your topic and the occasion will help you achieve your speaking goals. Perhaps you want to evoke a straightforward informational tone; perhaps you want to convey some particularly significant material in a playful and even artful way. Whatever you want to achieve, the style you choose matters. 1

CHARACTERISTICS OF EFFECTIVE STYLE

No matter how wonderful a speaker 's delivery may be, if she begins her speech, “La oss taler i dag om problemet med nettkriminalitet,” you won't have any idea that this is a speech about cybercrime—unless you speak Norwegian. No amount of work on topic choice, organizational patterns, or delivery can make up that gap: Language matters. Language matters in another important respect: The word choices that you make in expressing yourself also define the character of your ideas for your audience. Language matters not only in being understood, but also in being interesting, compelling, and in convincing your audience that you're worth listening to.

The study of verbal style, how to choose and use the right words, is central to communicating effectively. The second part of this chapter will discuss how you can choose words to achieve your communication goals, but, first, we will cover the basics. To be an effective speaker, you will have to use language that is concrete and lively, reduces abstraction and makes ideas come alive for listeners, and is respectful and doesn't unintentionally exclude some audience members. We'll talk about each of these characteristics in turn.

Speaking in Images

Evoking strong images is a crucial persuasive technique. Why say, “It was hot outside” when you can say, “It was like an oven outside—if you cracked an egg on the pavement, you could stand there and watch it sizzle on the hot asphalt.” New evidence in cognitive science gives us reason to prefer the second formulation over the first. When you describe a vivid visually rich image, your audience will be able to literally imagine seeing the egg frying on the pavement, and this is much more effective than saying that it 's hot outside. Why? Well, studies in cognition now say that when people can call up a visual image of a thing, they are engaging your content in two distinct ways: They're both calling up the idea of “hot” (they can recall a time when they were hot), and they can picture the egg frying on the pavement.

This is what cognitive scientists call “multi-modal” engagement. Instead of just relying on the concept “hot,” your audience can recall both the physical sensation of being extremely hot, and can call up the visual image of the egg frying on the pavement. This multi-modal engagement, which activates more parts of the brain than just the idea of “hot,” helps your audience to engage your content in at least three distinct ways: the idea, the feeling, and the visual image. Engaging lots of different brain functions is a good way to get your audience to bring to bear ideas, images, and experiences, to really experience an idea in more direct ways than just the concept. If you want to create conditions for maximum persuasion, think about the ways that what you are saying can evoke ideas, experiences, and images that engage the audience with your content.

For more information see:

Elizabeth El Refaie, Reconsidering “image metaphor” in the light of perceptual simulation theory. Metaphor and Symbol, 30(1), 2015.

Concrete and Lively Language

Holding the interest of the audience and making yourself understood depends, to a large extent, on making abstract ideas and relationships concrete so the audience can more clearly imagine what you're talking about. When people complain that a speech was “dry,” they usually mean that the material was presented in a way that was abstract and theoretical rather than concrete and vivid. Concepts, numbers, ideas, and arguments couched in language that creates a picture in audience members' mind become almost as visual as a movie, and the speech, in turn, is more interesting.

Painting images with words—detailed, three-dimensional, persuasively real images—is a skill you can learn. For instance, compare these two sentences. Which one creates a picture in your mind?

1. He cut it up.

2. Swiftly and silently, Jim hacked the watermelon into small pieces.

Clearly, sentence 2 provides much more detail than sentence 1 does. The mental images that audience members construct from sentence 2 would be more similar than their mental images from sentence 1.

If you want to get people 's attention about sports, you might try:

Sports are very exciting, with competition as well as highs and lows.

This isn't really interesting. You might think you knew it already, so what 's the point? Sierra faces this problem at the beginning of her speech, and here 's how she solves it:

It 's full of adrenaline rushes, blood, sweat, tears, cheers, pain, pleasure, joy, and everything in between. Whether it 's the roar of the crowd, the swish of the basket, the crack of the bat, or the sound of the buzzer, it 's something that we're all familiar with despite the heartbreaks and gut-wrenching defeats. We can never let go of one of the greatest things in the world: sports.

This language is exciting, full of images, motion, and a pleasing rhythm. This is the start to a speech that the audience will want to continue to hear. The language of public speaking is not the same as the language of everyday chitchat. Using language that departs somewhat from everyday speech, while remaining appropriate to your audience, makes the occasion special and can inspire listeners to pay closer attention.

Language that is interesting and lively is also easier to remember. Because self-persuasion is the best persuasion, the audience members must remember what you've said so they can mull it over later. Dry and abstract language won't help them do this. You must turn people 's ears into eyes so they will “see” what they're hearing.

TRY IT! MAKING LANGUAGE LIVELY

How could you make each of the following sentences more concrete and vivid?

• We should do something about immigration.

• U.S. consumers have a responsibility to reduce their environmental impact.

• Better nutrition is in everyone 's best interest.

Respectful Language

Because public speaking is designed with an audience—and a public—in mind, you have to speak in way that includes as many people as possible. You shouldn't, deliberately or acci-dently, make any audience members feel excluded by using language they find disrespectful. Off-color language and sexist and racist language can create disrespect and exclusion.

Off-Color Language Is it ever OK to use foul language? Of course, you can legally say whatever you like. But is it rhetorically smart to do so? In the vast majority of cases, you should avoid it.

The usual argument offered for using off-color language is that it helps speakers to convey the depth of emotion they feel about a topic or to bring in a bit of pathos they wouldn't be able to convey otherwise. It 's true that using, say, a four-letter word to describe a bad situation conveys a very different meaning than saying that it 's “disappointing.” But swearing almost always is a bad choice, for three reasons.

First, you can't know in advance the extent to which rude epithets might undermine your credibility with your audience members or get in the way of their hearing your argument. In general, the more you deviate from the speaking norms your specific audience expects, the more likely you will be to create unintended resistance.

Second, when we speak in public, we model how we think people ought to speak in public. What if audience members were to go away from your speech persuaded that foul language was the best way to convey the emotional frame of your topic? If they did, they might not all use the same careful judgments that you did in coming to your word choices, and the quality of public discourse would decline.

Third, many people see the use of foul language as a sign of disrespect toward the audience. As a result, it might make it difficult for you to build the kind of ethical relationship with your audience that you would like to have.

Sexist and Racist Language Our language carries assumptions and implications. We have to be sensitive to whether the assumptions of the words we use are respectful to everyone in our audience. For example, if you talk about “manpower” in your speech, it seems to imply that women aren't able to work or be productive, whereas talking about the “labor force” carries no such implication. Why not skip the implication? You don't believe it anyway The same reasoning applies to outdated terms such as fireman and policeman, for which you should substitute firefighter and police officer. Just as you wouldn't use hoys to refer to a group of college men, you shouldn't refer to female adults as girls. In some parts of the United States, guys is used in a gender-neutral way, so “you guys” can refer to both men and women, but you probably should avoid it in a speech, to avoid any misunderstanding.

Racist language includes disrespectful terms for races or ethnicities and common expressions that use the name of an ethnic or racial group in a derogatory way. Generalizations about a group of people also are unacceptable. When a speaker says, “All____people are talented in music,” the speaker may mean it to be a compliment, but this statement stereotypes people and denies their individuality.

Language that reduces individuals to a single characteristic is also disrespectful. When you talk about “the deaf” or “the blind” or “AIDS victims,” you've taken one characteristic and the essence of a group of people. Perhaps that characteristic is relevant to your speech, but people are much more than their disabilities or illnesses, and most prefer to be acknowledged as “people who are blind or have a visual impairment” rather than just “the blind.” Although some people believe that referring to “the gays” is acceptable, talking about the “gay community” is a more inclusive and respectful choice.

Chris Rock is one of the comedians who use four-letter words for humor, but what works late at night in a comedy club isn't appropriate in public speaking situations.

However, you use the techniques of verbal style discussed below to make your speech exciting and memorable, begin by striving to use language that is concrete, lively, and respectful to your audience.

CLASSIFYING VERBAL STYLE: FIGURES AND TROPES

Rhetoricians and linguists have proposed many theories of verbal style and many different systems for categorizing its elements. In this chapter, however, we'll cover just two special forms of speech that are especially useful for public speaking: the figure , or a change in the structure of a phrase or sentence that lends an ear-catching quality, and the trope , or a change in the way words and concepts are used that give them a new meaning.

________

figure An ear-catching change in the structure of a phrase or sentence.

________

________

trope A figure of speech that gives a new meaning for a word or concept.

________

You probably already use some figures and tropes in your everyday speech. For instance, only animals have legs and feet, but we routinely refer to “the foot of a mountain” and “the leg of a chair.” These common metaphors are a kind of linguistic trope (sometimes called “dead” metaphors because they no longer strike us as metaphors). Some turns of speech, like these familiar images, pass by in conversation without drawing attention to their form, whereas others are uncommon and artful uses of language. This second group is what is important to public speakers.

FIGURES

Your goal in choosing figures for your speech is to use them deliberately to highlight noteworthy content. If you use a figure too frequently, it begins to draw attention to itself rather than to your content, and then it becomes only a distraction for your listeners. But with careful use, figural language can add significant persuasive value to your speech. Two useful types of figures are of repetition and of contrast.

Figures of Repetition

From our earliest days as conversationalists, we learn to avoid structured repetition of words or phrases. If we tell a friend that we're going shopping, for instance, we don't say, “I'm going to buy eggs. I'm going to buy milk. I'm going to buy ketchup.” We say, “I'm going to buy eggs, milk, and ketchup.” Yet, in public speaking, such repetition, even though it seems redundant, can be used to create structure, lend emphasis, and make words more memorable. A Roman rhetoric textbook, Rhetorica ad Herennium, noted that speakers who repeat words and phrases do so not because they are at a loss for words; instead, they are creating something powerful and beautiful: “For there inheres in the repetition an elegance which the ear can distinguish more easily than words can explain.” 2

The following example repeats the phrase, “It takes...,” giving both emphasis and structure to the passage:

It takes no compromising to give people their rights. It takes no money to respect the individual.

It takes no survey to remove repressions.

—Harvey Milk, campaign speech for San Francisco Board of Supervisors, 1973. The works of Harvey Milk are owned by L. Stuart Milk and are used for the benefit of the Harvey Milk Foundation.

FAQ Can I use too much repetition?

Some of the most memorable speeches in U.S. history rely on repetition. For example, Martin Luther King 's “I Have a Dream” speech uses the word dream at least eight times. But one of the keys to effective repetition is to cluster repetitions in specific parts of the speech. Such a cluster, which may draw on a theme from earlier in the speech, gives the word or phrase more impact than if it were repeated throughout the whole speech.

You can repeat words, phrases, or sounds effectively, and at the beginning, middle, or end of sentences. Repeating initial sounds is called alliteration (“Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers”). Repeating final sounds is called rhyme (“Hickory, dickory dock, the mouse ran up the clock”). Both of these repetitions of sounds are more common in poetry and song than in public speaking, which more often uses repeated words and phrases. Let 's look at a couple figures of repetition.

Grammatical Repetition Almost everyone knows the final words of President Abraham Lincoln 's Gettysburg Address:

… this government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.

Because the phrases in italics have the same grammatical structure (in this case, preposition + definite article + noun), we call this grammatical repetition .

________

grammatical repetition The use of two or more phrases with the same grammatical structure.

________

Another famous example of grammatical repetition is the message Julius Caesar sent to the Roman Senate (in Latin, of course) in 47 BC to announce the results of a battle he fought in Turkey:

Veni, vidi, vici. (“I came, I saw, I conquered.”)

Here, Caesar gave us three complete sentences with the structure of I + verb. It not only is an economical expression but also a memorable one (in the original Latin, it also is an alliteration).

Another example, this time from Martin Luther King, Jr., is:

You have been the veterans of creative suffering. Continue to work with the faith that unearned suffering is redemptive. Go back to Mississippi, go back to Alabama, go back to South Carolina, go back to Georgia, go back to Louisiana, go back to the slums and ghettos of our northern cities, knowing that somehow this situation can and will be changed.

Martin Luther King Jr. 's famous 1963 “Address to the March on Washington” speech is commonly known as the “I Have a Dream” speech because of his repeated use of that phrase. Why does Dr. King use so much repetition in this speech?

Go back to + (place) is repeated six times, creating speed and force to King 's call for civil rights workers to take action, and the emotion is impossible to ignore if you listen to a recording of the “I Have a Dream” speech. This type of repetition is powerful and allows you to focus on either the phrase that is repeated or the complement to that phrase.

Progression Progression uses repetition to create a sense of movement. The effect of progression should be that of moving, rung by rung, up a ladder, drawing the listener forward to a conclusion. The following progression became popular during the 2008 U.S. presidential election: 3

________

progression Grammatical repetition that creates a sense of movement.

________

Rosa sat so that Martin could walk,

Martin walked so that Barack could run,

Barack ran so that our children could fly.

Generally, progression leaves the most important item until the end and builds to the word or point you want the audience to remember.

All this will not be finished in the first 100 days. Nor will it be finished in the first 1,000 days, nor in the life of this administration, nor perhaps in our lifetime on this planet.

—John E Kennedy, inaugural address, January 20, 1961

Some possible progressions include the following:

Minutes → hours → days

Great → greater → greatest

Local → state → Federal

Low → middle → high

Bad → worse → worst

Legendary primatologist Jane Goodall said, “Only if we understand, can we care. Only if we care, we will help. Only if we help, we shall be saved.”

You also can use progression to structure the points of your speech, so the preview itself will be a progression. For example, if your thesis were “Taxation is unjust,” structuring your argument as a progression might yield this argument:

If taxation is unjust for the federal government, it is unjust for a state, and if unjust for a state, it is unjust for our town.

Like repetition, progression uses ordinary words and their normal meanings, but it arranges them to create a striking and memorable effect. You can use these figures to create emphasis for points you are trying to make.

Figures of Contrast

Think about the difference between these two sentences:

It 's often hard for people to change their cultural assumptions, even when they make major geographical and sociological moves.

You can take the boy out of the country, but you can't take the country out of the boy.

These two sentences have much the same meaning; the difference is in the choice and arrangement of the words. The second version makes the contrast clear and memorable. You can use contrast in several different ways. Let 's look at antithesis and a couple of its variations.

Antithesis Antithesis means putting opposites together by creating a sentence with two contrasting or opposing parts. Here 's a famous example:

________

antithesis The use of two contrasting or opposing words or meanings.

________

One small step for a man; one giant leap for mankind.

—Neil Armstrong, as he set foot on the moon, July 21, 1969

By putting the contrast of ideas into the structure of the sentence, antithesis makes the point in more than one dimension. Consider this example from Richard Nixon 's eulogy for Senator Everett Dirksen in 1969; it 's part of Nixon 's argument that Dirksen was an outstanding politician:

FIGURE 8.1 Constructing an antithesis on a scale

A politician knows how to make the process of democracy work and loves the intricate workings of the democratic system. A politician knows not only how to count votes but how to make his vote____.

Because you can easily guess what the last word of this passage must have been, you know that you, like the audience, were following the structure of the sentences, and listening/ reading closely.

Consider the final sentence of this passage from a speech by Carrie Chapman Catt, a leading advocate of women 's suffrage, to Congress in 1917 on why women should have the vote:

If parties prefer to postpone action longer and thus do battle with this idea, they challenge the inevitable. The idea will not perish; the party which opposes it may.

The antithesis fills out the meaning of inevitable from the previous sentence in a clear and compelling way.

You might think that only someone with poetic abilities could write this way. Not true. Anyone can come up with effective antitheses in a few minutes. When you compose an antithesis, don't try to write it from beginning to end. Instead, start by thinking about a couple of ideas that are crucial to the argument or point you're trying to make. Then try this: Draw a line, and put an arrow in the middle to serve as the fulcrum of your scale (see Figure 8.1 ).

If your ideas were about trust and money, think about their opposites: trust/betrayal and wealth/poverty Put the opposing words on either side of the fulcrum in Figure 8.1 . Then play around with the words to shape them into phrases. In Figure 8.1 , it seemed that reversing the order of the concepts worked better. In a speech whose theme is “money can't buy happiness,” this might be an effective way to make the point.

Try to keep about the same number of words and syllables on each side of the fulcrum. Charles Dickens did this in a famous antithesis that begins A Tale of Two Cities (see Figure 8.2 ).

FIGURE 8.2 Antithesis from A Tale of Two Cities

The basic way to create the opposition in an antithesis is to use words with opposite meanings, such as best and worst. The plain double antithesis and the double-reverse antithesis are slightly more complex ways to structure an antithesis.

FAQ How can I use contrast effectively?

Figures of contrast work best if you stick to a few rules:

• Keep the contrasting figures compact—that is, relatively close together and preferably in the same phrase.

• Use contrast sparingly—saving it for important points. You wouldn't, for example, use a contrasting construction in a transition (“Now, the first point, as opposed to the second…”).

• Look for real opposites—contrast works best when it is stark. Don't try to force an opposition between things that are not actually opposites.

Plain Double Antithesis In plain double antithesis , the contrast is double, between two or more pairs of terms, such as between all and none, between virtues and vices, and between dislike and admire in this example:

________

plain double antithesis Two pairs of contrasting words.

________

He has all the virtues I dislike and none of the vices I admire.

—Winston Churchill, describing a political opponent

Here are a couple of other examples:

[We have] made the most difference in people 's lives when we've led not by polls, but by principle; not by calculation, but by conviction.

—Barack Obama, op-ed, Des Moines Register, November 27, 2007

Extremism in defense of liberty is no vice, moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue.

—Barry Goldwater, accepting the Republican Party 's nomination for president, 1964

The double-antithesis has all the virtues of the simple antithesis, but it allows you to put more ideas in play.

Double-Reverse Antithesis A double-reverse antithesis achieves opposition by reversing the order of key words to create the opposite meaning, and has an AB-BA structure.

________

double-reverse antithesis Key words repeated in reverse order.

________

Let us never negotiate out of fear, but let us never fear to negotiate.

—John F. Kennedy, inaugural address, January 20, 1961

A pessimist sees the difficulty in every opportunity; an optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty.

—Winston Churchill

When the going gets tough, the tough get going.

—Joseph P. Kennedy

Double-reverse antitheses are somewhat more difficult to compose than the other types, but they are memorable. This is why they get used in advertising jingles.

Aristotle claimed that “popularity of style is mainly due to antithesis,” and he was certainly right that antitheses are impressive and memorable. They are especially useful in your peroration (see Chapter 7 ), where they can help you end your speech clearly and definitely Because you, as a listener, usually can predict the end of an antithesis after hearing the first half, you're anticipating the end, and it 's clear that the speaker means to be absolutely done.

TRY IT! RECOGNIZING FIGURES OF REPETITION AND CONTRAST

Almost everyone knows about Abraham Lincoln 's Gettysburg Address, delivered on a battlefield in Pennsylvania after a Civil War battle in which many thousands of soldiers died. Most people find the speech to be powerful, but they're not sure why. The reason might be Lincoln 's skill with figures of speech. Find out for yourself. Here 's the text of Lincoln 's speech. See how many figures of repetition and contrast you can find in it.

Fourscore and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent a new nation, conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.