Jake Gardner and James Scurlock

Please watch both these videos and answering these questions with an MAX 350 word paragraph following this rubric

https://youtu.be/xfEgT9Z09JU

https://youtu.be/0Rg85Fz39I4

1. What was Jake Gardner trying to do?


2. What was James Surlock trying to do?


3. If Jake Gardner was overpowered, what would likely happen to him?


4. Do you think the shooting was justified?


5. Why do you think District Attorney Klein reversed his original decision not to press charges and allow a special prosecutor and and Grand Jury presentation?

OutcomeIssueDoes the student understand the issue?



5.0 ptsFull Marks

The student fully understands the issue.

2.5 ptsPartially Understands

The student does not fully understand the topic or issue

0.0 ptsNo Marks

The student does not understand the issue5.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomePositive ArgumentAre there positive supporting arguments?



5.0 ptsFull Marks

The student provided positive arguments.

0.0 ptsNo Marks

There are no positive arguments.5.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeNegative ArgumentAre there negative supporting arguments?



5.0 ptsFull Marks

There are negative arguments.

0.0 ptsNo Marks

There are no negative arguments.5.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSpelling and GrammarAre there Spelling and grammar issues?



5.0 ptsFull Marks

No grammar or spelling issues.

0.0 ptsNo Marks

Grammar and spelling issues5.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeResolution and conclusionDos the student resolve the issues between the positive and negative arguments and give a supported conclusion?



5.0 ptsFull Marks

The student considered both arguments and made a supported conclusion.

2.5 ptsConclusion without Support

The conclusion was not adequately supported.

0.0 ptsNo Marks

No conclusion or resolution of arguments.5.0 pts

Total Points: 25.0