INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING
S e v e n t h E d i t i o n
Frederick D. S. Choi New York University
Gary K. Meek Oklahoma State University
Prentice Hall Boston Columbus Indianapolis New York San Francisco Upper Saddle River
Amsterdam Cape Town Dubai London Madrid Milan Munich Paris Montreal Toronto Delhi Mexico City Sao Paulo Sydney Hong Kong
Seoul Singapore Taipei Tokyo
Credits and acknowledgments borrowed from other sources and reproduced, with permission, in this textbook appear on appropriate page within text.
Editorial Director: Sally Yagan Editor in Chief: Donna Battista Acquisitions Editor: Julie Broich Director Editorial Services: Ashley Santora Editorial Project Manager: Karen Kirincich Editorial Assistant: Brian Reilly Director of Marketing: Patrice Lumumba Jones Senior Managing Editor: Cynthia Zonneveld Project Manager: Lynne Breitfeller Operations Specialist: Clara Bartunek Creative Art Director: Jayne Conte
Cover Designer: Bruce Kenselaar Manager, Visual Research: Beth Brenzel Manager, Cover Visual Research & Permissions:
Karen Sanatar Cover Art: Fotolia Full-Service Project Management: Hemalatha /
Integra Printer/Binder: Courier/Westford Cover Printer: Lehigh-Phoenix Color/Hagerstown Text Font: 10/12 Palatino
Copyright © 2011, 2008, 2005, 2002, 1999. Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Prentice Hall, One Lake Street, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458. All rights reserved. Manufactured in the United States of America. This publication is protected by Copyright, and permission should be obtained from the publisher prior to any prohibited reproduction, storage in a retrieval system, or transmission in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or likewise. To obtain permission(s) to use material from this work, please submit a written request to Pearson Education, Inc., Permissions Department, One Lake Street, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458.
Many of the designations by manufacturers and seller to distinguish their products are claimed as trademarks. Where those designations appear in this book, and the publisher was aware of a trademark claim, the designations have been printed in initial caps or all caps.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Choi, Frederick D. S., International accounting / Frederick D.S. Choi, Gary K. Meek.—7th ed.
p. cm. Includes index. ISBN-13: 978-0-13-611147-4 (alk. paper) ISBN-10: 0-13-611147-5 (alk. paper) 1. International business enterprises––Accounting. I. Meek, Gary K., II. Title. HF5686.I56C53 2011 657'.96—dc22
2010014971
ISBN 10: 0-13-611147-5 ISBN 13: 978-0-13-611147-4
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
To our families
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Preface xv
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION 1 Historical Perspective 2
Contemporary Perspective 3
Growth and Spread of Multinational Operations 4
Financial Innovation 10
Global Competition 11
Cross-Border Mergers and Acquisitions 12
Internationalization of Capital Markets 13
Americas 15
Western Europe 16
Asia 17
Cross-Border Equity Listing and Issuance 18
Where Are We? 19
Learning Objectives 20 Appendix 1-1: Stock Exchange Web Sites 24 Appendix 1-2: Financial Statements and Selected Notes from
the Annual Report of INFOSYS 25 Discussion Questions 26 • Exercises 26
� CASE 1-1: E-centives, Inc.—Raising Capital in Switzerland 28 � CASE 1-2: Global Benchmarks: Infosys Technologies Limited 29
Chapter 2 DEVELOPMENT AND CLASSIFICATION 30 Development 31
Classification 37
Four Approaches to Accounting Development 37
Legal Systems: Common Law vs. Code Law Accounting 38
Practice Systems: Fair Presentation vs. Legal Compliance Accounting 39 Discussion Questions 41 • Exercises 42
� CASE 2-1: Are Classifications of Accounting Outmoded? 44 � CASE 2-2: Volkswagen Group 45
Chapter 3 COMPARATIVE ACCOUNTING: EUROPE 49 Some Observations about Accounting Standards and Practice 51
IFRS in the European Union 52
v
Five National Financial Accounting Systems 54
France 54
Germany 60
Czech Republic 65
The Netherlands 68
United Kingdom 73 Discussion Questions 79 • Exercises 79
� CASE 3-1: Old Habits Die Hard 81 � CASE 3-2a: What Difference Does It Really Make? 82 � CASE 3-2b: Do the Differences Really Matter? 83
Chapter 4 COMPARATIVE ACCOUNTING: THE AMERICAS AND ASIA 84 Five National Financial Accounting Systems 86
United States 86
Mexico 91
Japan 96
China 101
India 106 Discussion Questions 112 • Exercises 112
� CASE 4-1: Standing on Principles 115 � CASE 4-2: Casino Capital 116
Chapter 5 REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE 119 Development of Disclosure 119
Voluntary Disclosure 120
Regulatory Disclosure Requirements 121
The U.S. SEC Financial Reporting Debate 122
Reporting and Disclosure Practices 124
Disclosures of Forward-Looking Information 124
Segment Disclosures 125
Social Responsibility Reporting 130
Corporate Governance Disclosures 132
Internet Business Reporting and XBRL 157
Annual Report Disclosures in Emerging-Market Countries 158
Implications for Financial Statement Users and Managers 159
Discussion Questions 160 • Exercises 160 � CASE 5-1: In the Green 162 � CASE 5-2: Seeing Is Believing 162
vi Contents
Chapter 6 FOREIGN CURRENCY TRANSLATION 164 Reasons for Translation 168
Background and Terminology 169
The Problem 172
Financial Statement Effects of Alternative Translation Rates 172
Foreign Currency Transactions 174
Single-Transaction Perspective 176
Two-Transaction Perspective 177
Foreign Currency Translation 178
Single Rate Method 178
Multiple Rate Methods 179
Financial Statement Effects 181
Which Is Best? 183
Appropriate Current Rate 185
Translation Gains and Losses 185
Deferral 186
Deferral and Amortization 186
Partial Deferral 187
No Deferral 187
Where Are We? 187
Translation Accounting Development 188
Pre-1965 188
1965–1975 188
1975–1981 188
1981–Present 189
Features of Standard No. 52/International Accounting Standard 21 189
Translation When Local Currency Is the Functional Currency 190
Translation When the Parent Currency Is the Functional Currency 190
Translation When Foreign Currency Is the Functional Currency 190
Measurement Issues 192
Reporting Perspective 192
What Happened to Historical Cost? 193
Concept of Income 193
Managed Earnings 193
Contents vii
Foreign Currency Translation and Inflation 194
Foreign Currency Translation Elsewhere 195 Appendix 6-1: Translation and Remeasurement Under
FAS No. 52 196 Discussion Questions 200 • Exercises 201
� CASE 6-1: Regents Corporation 204 � CASE 6-2: Managing Offshore Investments: Whose Currency? 206
Chapter 7 FINANCIAL REPORTING AND CHANGING PRICES 210 Changing Prices Defined 214
Why are Financial Statements Potentially Misleading During Periods of Changing Prices? 216
Types of Inflation Adjustments 217
General Price-Level Adjustments 218
Price Indexes 218
Use of Price Indexes 218
Object of General Price-Level Adjustments 219
Current-Cost Adjustments 222
General Price-Level Adjusted Current Costs 225
National Perspectives on Inflation Accounting 227
United States 227
United Kingdom 229
Brazil 230
International Accounting Standards Board 233
Inflation Issues 234
Inflation Gains and Losses 234
Holding Gains and Losses 235
Foreign Inflation 235
Avoiding the Double-Dip 236 Appendix 7-1: Accounting for Foreign Inflation: A Case Analysis 238 Discussion Questions 241 • Exercises 242
� CASE 7-1: Kashmir Enterprises 245 � CASE 7-2: Icelandic Enterprises, Inc. 246
Chapter 8 GLOBAL ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING STANDARDS 249 A Survey of International Convergence 250
Advantages of International Convergence 250
Criticisms of International Standards 252
Reconciliation and Mutual Recognition 252
Evaluation 253
viii Contents
Some Significant Events in the History of International Accounting Standard Setting 253
Overview of Major International Organizations Promoting Accounting Convergence 255
International Accounting Standards Board 256
IASC’s Core Standards and the IOSCO Agreement 261
The IASB Structure 262
Recognition and Support for the IASB 264
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Response to IFRS 264
European Union (EU) 265
Fourth, Seventh, and Eighth Directives 266
Transparency Directive 266
Have EU Harmonization Efforts Been Successful? 267
The EU’s New Approach and the Integration of European Financial Markets 268
International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) 269
International Federation of Accountants (IFAC) 272
United Nations Intergovernmental Working Group of Experts on International Standards of Accounting and Reporting (ISAR) 275
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) 275
Conclusion 275 Discussion Questions 276 • Exercises 276
� CASE 8-1: PetroChina Company Limited 279 � CASE 8-2: Whither The Withering Standard Setters? 280
Chapter 9 INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS 281 Introduction 281
Challenges and Opportunities in Cross-Border Analysis 281
Business Analysis Framework 283
International Business Strategy Analysis 283
Information Availability 284
Recommendations for Analysis 285
Accounting Analysis 285
Suggestions for the Analyst 287
Contents ix
International Financial Analysis 288
Ratio Analysis 288
Cash Flow Analysis 291
Coping Mechanisms 291
International Prospective Analysis 292
Further Issues 295
Information Access 295
Foreign Currency Considerations 298
Differences in Statement Format 302
Language and Terminology Barriers 303
Financial Statement Analysis and Auditing 303
The Attest Function 304
The Audit Report 304
Auditing and Credibility 307
Coping Mechanisms 309
Internal Auditing 310
Professional Organization 312
Evolving Role of Internal Auditing 315 Appendix 9-1: Illustration of Restatement of Japanese
GAAP Financial Statements to a U.S. GAAP Basis 316
Appendix 9-2: International Ratio Analysis 320 Discussion Questions 322 • Exercises 322
� CASE 9-1: Sandvik 325 � CASE 9-2: Continental A.G. 331
Chapter 10 MANAGERIAL PLANNING AND CONTROL 340 Business Modeling 341
Planning Tools 341
Capital Budgeting 343
Financial Return Perspectives 344
Measuring Expected Returns 345
Multinational Cost of Capital 348
Management Information Systems 350
Systems Issues 350
Information Issues 352
Management Information and Hyperinflation 353
Sales Revenue 354
x Contents
Issues in Financial Control 357
Domestic Versus Multinational Control System 358
Operational Budgeting 360
Analysis of Exchange Rate Changes 364
Strategic Costing 367
Performance Evaluation of Foreign Operations 369
Consistency 369
Unit Versus Managerial Performance 370
Performance Criteria 372
Measurement Issues and Changing Prices in Evaluation 374
Performance Evaluation Practices: ICI 374
Foreign Currency Effects 376
Performance Standards 377
Value Reporting 379 Discussion Questions 380 • Exercises 380
� CASE 10-1: Foreign Investment Analysis: A Tangled Affair 384 � CASE 10-2: Assessing Foreign Subsidiary Performance in a World of Floating
Exchange Rates 386
Chapter 11 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT 388 Essentials 391
Why Manange Financial Risks? 391
Role of Accounting 392
Identifying Market Risks 392
Quantify Trade-offs 394
Risk Management in a World of Floating Exchange Rates 394
Forecasting Exchange Rate Changes 394
Translation Exposure 396
Transaction Exposure 400
Accounting Versus Economic Exposure 401
Accounting for Hedge Products 407
Practice Issues 413
Hedge of a Recognized Asset, Liability, or an Unrecognized Firm Commitment 414
Hedge of a Net Investment in a Foreign Operation 416
Speculating in Foreign Currency 417
Disclosure 418
Financial Control 422
Contents xi
Appropriate Benchmarks 422 Discussion Questions 423 • Exercises 424
� CASE 11-1: Exposure Identification 426 � CASE 11-2: Value at Risk: What Are Our Options? 426
Chapter 12 INTERNATIONAL TAXATION AND TRANSFER PRICING 431 Initial Concepts 432
Diversity of National Tax Systems 432
Types of Taxes 432
Tax Burdens 435
Tax Administration Systems 436
Foreign Tax Incentives 437
Tax Havens and Harmful Tax Competition 438
International Harmonization 438
Taxation of Foreign-Source Income and Double Taxation 439
Foreign Tax Credit 439
Limits to Tax Credits 441
Tax Treaties 442
Foreign Exchange Considerations 443
Tax-Planning Dimensions 443
Organizational Considerations 444
Controlled Foreign Corporations and Subpart F Income 444
Offshore Holding Companies 445
Financing Decisions 445
Pooling of Tax Credits 446
Cost Accounting Allocations 446
Location and Transfer Pricing 447
Integrating International Tax Planning 447
International Transfer Pricing: Complicating Variables 448
Tax Considerations 448
Tariff Considerations 450
Competitive Factors 450
Environmental Risks 451
Performance Evaluation Considerations 452
Resolving Trade-offs 452
Transfer Pricing Methodology 453
Market vs. Cost vs. . . . ? 453
Arm’s-Length Principle 453
xii Contents
Comparable Uncontrolled Price Method 454
Comparable Uncontrolled Transaction Method 454
Resale Price Method 454
Cost-Plus Pricing Method 455
Comparable Profits Method 457
Profit-Split Methods 457
Other Pricing Methods 458
Advance Pricing Agreements 459
Transfer Pricing Practices 460
The Future 460 Discussion Questions 462 • Exercises 462
� CASE 12-1: The Shirts Off Their Backs 465 � CASE 12-2: Muscle Max: Your Very Own Personal Trainer 467
Index 469
Contents xiii
This page intentionally left blank
PREFACE
This book is written with the express purpose of introducing students to the interna- tional dimensions of accounting, financial reporting and financial control. The world in which they will pursue their professional careers is a world dominated by global business and cross-border investing. As these activities require decisions premised on financial data, a knowledge of international accounting is crucial for achieving proper understanding in external and internal financial communications. While ideal for upper division undergraduate students and masters students, we are pleased that the contents of this award-winning effort have also benefited practicing accountants, financial executives, investment managers, university educators and professional administrators around the world.
This revision of a work that has spanned four decades features a number of enhancements. These include:
• Updated coverage of corporate governance and related legislation. See Chapters 4, 5, 8 and 9.
• Examination of international auditing, both external and internal. See Chapters 8 and 9.
• Current discussion of comparative accounting emphasizing developments in Europe, the Americas and Asia in Chapters 3 and 4.
• Capital market, managerial, taxation and institutional updates reflective of current trends and issues throughout most chapters.
• Discussion of international accounting convergence and the major players in this important effort. See Chapters 3, 5 and 8.
• Examination of reporting and disclosure practices spanning both developed and emerging market countries. See Chapters 4, 5 and 7.
• Expanded listings of relevant international Web site addresses and data sources. • Updated discussion questions, exercises and cases.
We have benefited from the professional literature and from many of our students and faculty colleagues whose thoughtful comments have triggered new ideas for us to consider. We are in their debt. In addition, many individuals furnished able assistance in producing the manuscript. We especially thank Julie Broich, Karen Kirincich and Christina Rumbaugh at Prentice Hall for their encouragement and editorial support.
However hard one tries to avoid them, errors are bound to occur in a work of this type. As authors, we accept full responsibility for all errors and omissions in the manuscript. As always we welcome constructive comments from all who use this book as students are the ultimate beneficiaries of your thoughtfulness.
F. D. S. Choi New York, N.Y.
G. K. Meek Stillwater, OK
xv
This page intentionally left blank
1
Accounting plays a vital role in society. As a branch of economics, it provides information about a firm and its transactions to facilitate resource allocation decisions by users of that information. If the information reported is reliable and useful, scarce resources are allocated in an optimal fashion, and conversely, resource allocations are less than optimal when information is less reliable and useful.
International accounting, the subject of this text, is no different in its intended role. What makes its study distinctive is that the entity being reported on is either a multinational company (MNC) with operations and transactions that cross national boundaries, or an entity with reporting obligations to users who are located in a country other than that of the reporting entity.
Recall that accounting entails several broad processes: measurement, disclosure, and auditing. Measurement is the process of identifying, categorizing, and quantifying economic activities or transactions. These measurements provide insights into the profitability of a firm’s operations and the strength of its financial position. Disclosure is the process by which accounting measurements are communicated to their intended users. This area focuses on issues such as what is to be reported, when, by what means, and to whom. Auditing is the process by which specialized accounting professionals (auditors) attest to the reliability of the measurement and communication process. Whereas internal auditors are company employees who answer to management, exter- nal auditors are nonemployees who are responsible for attesting that the company’s financial statements are prepared in accordance with generally accepted standards.
An understanding of the international dimensions of the accounting processes that were just described is important to those engaged in importing or exporting activities, as well as those seeking to manage a business, or obtain or supply financing across national borders. Even a company operating solely within the confines of a single country is no longer insulated from the international aspects of accounting as reliance on international vendors to contain production costs and remain globally competitive is a common feature of contemporary business. Accounting amounts may vary significantly according to the principles that govern them. Differences in culture, business practices, political and regulatory structures, legal systems, currency values, local inflation rates, business risks,
C H A P T E R 1
Introduction
2 Chapter 1 • Introduction
and tax codes all affect how the MNC conducts its operations and financial reporting around the world. Financial statements and other disclosures are impossible to understand without an awareness of the underlying accounting principles and business culture.
The importance of studying international accounting has grown over the years. We begin with a brief history of this subject.
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
The history of accounting is an international history. The following chronology demon- strates that accounting has been remarkably successful in its ability to be transplanted from one national setting to another while allowing for continued development in theory and practice worldwide.
To begin, double-entry bookkeeping, generally thought of as the genesis of accounting as we know it today, emanated from the Italian city states of the 14th and 15th centuries. Its development was spurred by the growth of international commerce in northern Italy during the late Middle Ages and the desire of government to find ways to tax commercial transactions. “Bookkeeping in the Italian fashion” then migrated to Germany to assist the merchants of the Fugger era and the Hanseatic league. At about the same time, business philosophers in the Netherlands sharpened ways of calculating periodic income, and government officials in France found it advantageous to apply the whole system to governmental planning and accountability.
In due course, double-entry accounting ideas reached the British Isles. The devel- opment of the British Empire created unprecedented needs for British commercial inter- ests to manage and control enterprises in the colonies, and for the records of their colonial enterprises to be reviewed and verified. These needs led to the emergence of accounting societies in the 1850s and an organized public accounting profession in Scotland and England during the 1870s. British accounting practices spread not only throughout North America but also throughout the British Commonwealth as it then existed.
Parallel developments occurred elsewhere. The Dutch accounting model was exported to Indonesia, among other places. The French accounting system found a home in Polynesia and French-administered territories in Africa while the reporting framework of the Germans proved influential in Japan, Sweden, and czarist Russia.
As the economic might of the United States grew during the first half of the 20th century, its sophistication in matters of accounting grew in tandem. Business schools assisted in this development by conceptualizing the subject matter and eventually having it recognized as an academic discipline in its own right on college and univer- sity campuses. After World War II, U.S. accounting influence made itself felt throughout the Western world, particularly in Germany and Japan. To a lesser extent, similar factors are directly observable in countries like Brazil, Israel, Mexico, the Philippines, Sweden, and Taiwan.
Despite this international heritage, in most countries accounting remained a nationalistic affair, with national standards and practices deeply anchored into national laws and professional regulations. (Examples of comparative accounting practices are provided in Chapters 3 and 4.) There was little understanding of parallel requirements in other countries. Yet, accounting increasingly serveed people and organizations whose decisions were increasingly international in scope.
Chapter 1 • Introduction 3
Resolving the historical paradox of accounting has long been a concern of both users and preparers of accounting information. In recent years, institutional efforts to narrow differences in measurement, disclosure, and auditing processes around the world have intensified. A description of this effort and the major players with an important stake in attaining convergence of global accounting systems is the focus of Chapter 8.
CONTEMPORARY PERSPECTIVE
While the effort to reduce international accounting diversity is important in its own right, there are today a number of additional factors that are contributing to the growing importance of studying international accounting. These factors stem from significant and continuing reductions in national trade barriers and capital controls together with advances in information technology.
National controls on capital flows, foreign exchange, foreign direct investment, and related transactions have been dramatically liberalized in recent years, reducing the barriers to international business. Changes in financial sector policy in both devel- oped and developing countries reflect the growing realization that information and financial technolgy render capital controls ineffective. National governments also real- ize that financial market liberaliztion affords them access to international funds with which to finance national debts. As accounting is the language of business, cross-border economic interactions mean that accounting reports prepared in one country must increasingly be used and understood by users in another.
Advances in information technology are also causing a radical change in the economics of production and distribution. Vertically integrated production is no longer proving an efficient mode of operation. Real-time global information linkages mean that production, including accounting services, is increasingly being outsourced, or offshored, to whomever in the world can do the job, or portions of the job, best.1 Leading locations for offshore services today include Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Costs Rica, Mexico, and Panama in the Americas; Australia, China, India, Malaysia, New Zealand, Pakistan, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam in Asia Pacific; and the Czech Republic, Egypt, Hungary, Ireland, Israel, Morocco, Poland, Romania, Russia, Slovakia, South Africa, Spain and the Ukraine in Europe, the Middle East, and Africa.2 Adversarial, arm’s- length relationships that have characterized companies’ relations with their suppliers, middle persons, and customers are being replaced by cooperative global linkages with suppliers, suppliers’ suppliers, middle persons, customers, and customers’ customers.
Exhibit 1-1 provides an illustration of the outsourcing phenomenon. In producing the ProLiant ML150, a small box that helps companies manage customer databases and run e-mail systems, among other things, Hewlett-Packard (H-P) turned to the usual sources of low-cost labor: China and India. However, it also decided to make some ML150s in higher-cost locations such as Singapore and Australia, which were closer to targeted customers. Initial design for the ML150 was done in Singapore and then handed off to an outside contractor in Taiwan. Although China possesses the lowest wage rates, it is but one part of a highly specialized manufacturing system.
1 For example, see Arie Lewin, Silvia Massini, and Carine Peters, “Why Are Companies Offshoring Innovation? The Emerging Global Race for Talent,” Journal of International Business Studies 40 (2009): 901–925. 2 Robert Kennedy, “The Tough Game You Have to Play,” Financial Executive, May 2009, pp. 23–25.
4 Chapter 1 • Introduction
EXHIBIT 1-1 Outsourcing Process for Hewlett-Packard’s ProLiant 150
India ; 5
China ; Taiwan 5 4
Australia ; T c 5 Singapore : Houston
5 3 1 ; 2 H-P’s Path to Market 1. Idea for ML150 spawned in Singapore 2. Concept approved in Houston 3. Concept design performed in Singapore 4. Engineering design and initial manufacture in Taiwan 5. Final assembly in Australia, China, India, and Singapore. Machines produced in Australia,
China, and India sold in local markets; machines assembled in Singapore marketed to Southeast Asia.
Considerations ranging from logistics to tariff policies reportedly kept H-P from put- ting all of its production lines in China. It would take too long for machines manufac- tured in China to reach customers in other Asian markets. Moreover, shipping goods to India triggered steep tariffs, so it made sense to produce some ML150s in India with imported parts for the local market. All of the links in this outsourcing example are associated with accounting issues discussed in the following pages of this chapter.
Spurred by the twin developments we have just described, there are several factors that are contributing to the growing importance of the subject matter of this text. We describe each in turn.
GROWTH AND SPREAD OF MULTINATIONAL OPERATIONS
International business has traditionally been associated with foreign trade. This activity, rooted in antiquity, continues unabated. While trade in services has tradition- ally paled in comparison to trade in merchandise, the former is gaining in signifi- cance and growing at a faster rate than the latter. Current trends in exports and imports of both goods and services by region and selected economy are depicted in Exhibit 1-2.
What is not shown in Exhibit 1-2 is the composition of each region’s exports and imports. To obtain a better picture of the pattern of global trade at the micro level, one could examine the foreign operations disclosures of any major MNC. Exhibit 1-3 contains the geographic distribution of sales of AKZO Nobel, a multina- tional company headquartered in the Netherlands and concentrating on healthcare products, coatings, and chemicals. As can be seen, the company’s sales literally blan- ket every continent in the world. Unisys, the U.S.-based information technology services company, provides its expertise to clients in over 100 countries, while
Chapter 1 • Introduction 5
EXHIBIT 1-2 World Trade by Region
Total Merchandise Trade Unit: U.S. dollar at current prices (millions)
Region Activity Partner Stet 1990 1995 2000 2005 2007 Africa Exports World 106,000 112,000 147,800 297,700 424,100 Africa Imports World 99,600 126,700 129,400 249,300 358,900 Asia Exports World 792,400 1,446,800 1,836,200 3,050,900 4,131,000 Asia Imports World 761,500 1,403,300 1,677,100 2,871,000 3,804,300 Europe Exports World 1,684,940 2,335,635 2,633,930 4,371,915 5,722,205 Europe Imports World 1,750,925 2,334,760 2,774,755 4,542,675 6,060,845 Mid. East Exports World 138,400 151,000 268,000 538,000 759,900 Mid. East Imports World 101,300 132,500 167,400 322,100 479,300 N. America Exports World 562,035 856,550 1,224,975 1,477,530 1,853,500 N. America Imports World 684,460 1,015,760 1,687,580 2,284,735 2,707,460 S./C. America Exports World 106,000 148,900 195,800 354,900 499,200 S./C. America Imports World 85,900 176,900 206,300 297,600 456,000 World Exports World 3,449,000 5,164,000 6,452,000 10,431,000 13,950,000 World Imports World 3,550,000 5,284,000 6,724,000 10,783,000 14,244,000
Total Trade in Commercial Services Unit: U.S. dollar at current prices (millions)
Region Activity Partner 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2007 Africa Exports World 18,600 25,700 31,300 56,900 78,400
Africa Imports World 26,500 34,400 37,400 69,300 102,100 Asia Exports World 131,500 257,800 309,500 525,300 739,600 Asia Imports World 178,800 328,100 367,900 573,500 760,000 Europe Exports World 597,100 721,900 1,244,800 1,703,200 Europe Imports World 560,200 674,100 1,120,100 1,461,300 Mid. East Exports World 33,100 54,900 76,900 Mid. East Imports World 48,800 85,400 132,900 N. America Exports World 135,500 171,200 268,200 366,300 535,600 N. America Imports World 135,500 171,200 268,200 366,300 440,100 S./C. America Exports World 22,400 34,600 47,100 68,200 92,200 S./C. America Imports World 24,900 45,300 54,600 70,500 98,600 World Exports World 780,500 1,185,100 1,491,000 2,414,300 3,291,500 World Imports World 820,500 1,200,700 1,474,600 2,347,400 3,085,900
Source: World Trade Organization, International Trade Statistics, 2008.
Japan’s Cannon Inc. sells cameras and other professional and consumer imaging equipment in virtually every country of the world. An aggregation of such disclo- sures for all MNCs in all countries would confirm that trade today is neither bilateral nor regional, but truly global.
6 Chapter 1 • Introduction
EXHIBIT 1-3 Selected 2008 Foreign Operations Data for AKZO Nobel (Euro millions)
Net Sales By Destination
Capital Expenditures
Invested Capital
Number of Employees
The Netherlands 867 86 2,007 5,000
Germany 1,141 25 1,006 3,600 Sweden 478 50 557 3,800 U.K. 1,093 31 1,324 4,200 Other Europe 3,666 81 2,359 3,666 U.S./Canada 3,330 94 3,250 12,000 Latin America 1,306 49 776 4,800 China 1,054 67 861 6,300 Other Asia 1,866 43 1,030 7,800 Other regions 614 8 174 2,400
A major accounting issue associated with export and import activities relates to accounting for foreign currency transactions. Assume, for example, that Heineken exports a certain quantity of beer to a Brazilian importer and invoices the sale in Brazilian reals. Should the real devalue relative to the euro prior to collection, Heineken will experience a foreign exchange loss as reals will yield less euros upon conversion after the devaluation than before. The measurement of this transaction loss is not straightforward and is a subject that is dealt with in Chapter 6.
Today, international business transcends foreign trade and is increasingly associ- ated with foreign direct investments, which involve operating production or distribu- tion systems abroad by way of a wholly or majority-owned affiliate, a joint venture, or a strategic alliance.
While there is clearly a developed country bias of foreign direct investors, the boom of foreign direct investment flows to developing countries since the early 1990s indicates that MNCs are increasingly finding these host countries to be attractive investment locations.3
At the level of the firm, foreign direct investment activities are captured by a com- pany’s segmental disclosures and its roster of shareholdings in affiliated companies. Exhibit 1-3 also provides operating statistics by region for AKZO Nobel.
Exhibit 1-4 illustrates the extensive holdings in operating group companies of Nestle, one of the world’s largest food and beverage companies headquartered in Vevy, Switzerland. While both AKZO and Nestle’s foreign operations are extensive, the numbers relating to capital expenditures, invested capital, production sold locally, and number of foreign employees understate the extent of their foreign operations. They do not reflect the extent of either company’s joint venture, strategic alliance, or other coop- erative arrangements.
3 World Bank Chief Economist, Francois Bourguignon, predicts that over the next 25 years, developing countries will move to the center stage in the global economy, “Global Economic Prospects 2007: Managing the Next Wave of Globalization,” World Bank Panel Discussion sponsored by the Global Business Institute, NYU Stern School of Business, December 12, 2006.
Chapter 1 • Introduction 7
EXHIBIT 1-4 Countries in Which Nestle Owns One or More Majority-Owned Companies
Europe
Germany Austria Belgium Bulgaria Crotia Denmark Spain Finland France Greece Hungary Italy Lithuania Malta Norway The Netherlands Poland Portugal Ireland Czech R. Romania U.K. Russia Serbia Slovakia Sweden Switzerland Turkey Ukraine
Africa
S. Africa Cameroon Cote d’Ivoire
14
4 8 1 1 3
10 3
18 2 5 8 1 1 3 6 5 7 1 3 1 9
12 1 1 7 8 3 3
4 1 1
Egypt Gabon Ghana Guinea Kenya Mauritius Morocco Mozambique Niger Nigeria Senegal Tunisia Zimbabwe
Americas
Argentina Bolivia Brazil Canada Chile Colombia Costa Rica Cuba Salvador Ecuador U.S. Guatemala Honduras Jamaica Mexico Nicaragua Panama Paraguay Peru Puerto Rico
2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
3 1 5 2 2 5 1 2 2 2 9 1 1 1 8 2 2 1 1 2
Dom Rep. Trinidad Uruguay Venezuela
Asia
Saudi Arabia Bangladesh Cambodia UAE India Indonesia Israel Japan Jordan Kuwait Lebanon Malaysia Pakistan Philippines S. Korea China Singapore Sri Lanka Syria Thailand Vietnam
Oceana
Australia Fiji N. Zealand New Guinea F. Polynesia New Caledonia 1
1 2 1 3
3 1 1 1 2 1 1 9 1 1 3 7 1 4 4
21 1 1 2 9 2
3 1 1 1 1 1
Note: This list is conservative as it does not include affiliated companies for which proportionate consolidation is employed, associated companies for which the equity method is used, subholding financial and property companies, and technical assistance, research and development companies.
8 Chapter 1 • Introduction
Operations conducted in foreign countries expose both financial managers and accountants alike to an additional set of problems that they do not encounter when solely engaged in international trade. As one example, how should an MNC like Nestle report the results of its operations, both domestic and international, to its South Korean investors? Each affiliate listed in Exhibit 1-4 must prepare its accounts according to the generally accepted accounting principles of the country in which it is domiciled for statutory and tax purposes. As Chapters 3 and 4 will attest, national financial reporting principles can vary significantly from country to country as they are shaped by different socio-economic environments. Environmental influences that impinge on accounting development are examined in Chapter 2. Nestle’s domestic shareholders are used to seeing reports on the basis of Swiss reporting conventions. Examination of Nestle’s accounting policies on consolidation suggests that the company first restates all of its foreign accounts to the reporting framework of the parent company prior to consolida- tion. The report of Nestle’s auditors state that the consolidated financial statements com- ply with Swiss Law and are in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) and with the Interpretations issued by the International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC). But in restating from one set of principles to another, does something get lost in the translation? To illustrate, Mexican companies adjust their financial state- ments for changing prices (a subject that we cover in Chapter 7), owing to serious bouts of inflation in the past. Their adjustment for changing prices utilizes a methodology that incorporates changes in specific prices or replacement costs. Nestle, on the other hand, restates assets located in hyperinflationary countries for changes in the general purchas- ing power of the local currency prior to consolidation. Since general price changes seldom move in tandom with specific price changes, does Nestle’s methodology reduce the information content of the Mexican subsidiary’s inflation-adjusted accounts? Yamaha, producer of world-renowned musical instruments and other lifestyle products, expresses this concern in the first footnote to its consolidated financial accounts:
Yamaha Corporation (the Company) and its domestic subsidiaries maintain their accounting records and prepare their financial statements in accor- dance with accounting principles and practices generally accepted in Japan, and its foreign subsidiaries maintain their books of account in conformity with those of their countries of domicile. The Company and all consolidated subsidiaries are referred to as the “Group.” The accompanying consolidated financial statements have been prepared from the financial statements filed with the Ministry of Finance as required by the Securities and Exchange Law of Japan. Accordingly, the accompanying consolidated financial statements may differ in certain significant respects from accounting principles and practices generally accepted in countries and jurisdictions other than Japan.
Then there is the choice of exchange rate to use in converting foreign accounts to a single reporting currency. As Chapter 6 explains, there are a variety of rates that an MNC can use. As foreign exchange rates are seldom constant, restating accounts using exchange rates that gyrate almost daily produces gains and losses that can have a significant effect on the reported profitability and perceived riskiness of multinational operations. As you might suspect, account- ing treatments for these gains and losses are far from uniform internationally.
Chapter 1 • Introduction 9
Domestic readers are not the only audience that reporting entities must address. What about statement readers that are domiciled abroad? Their information needs must be considered when a firm seeks access to foreign sources of capital and at reasonable costs. Market access and cost of capital considerations are, in turn, related to the nature and quality of a firm’s external financial communications. Should a company send the same set of accounts that it prepares for its domestic readers to its foreign readers? Or, should the reporting entity restate its reports according to the language, currency and/or accounting principles of the reader’s country? This is not a trivial consideration as foreign readers are generally unaccustomed to providing money capital on the basis of an unfamiliar currency, language, and measurement framework. Evidence suggests that some institutional investors tend to exhibit a home country bias in their portfolio choices and tend to invest in nondomestic firms whose accounting and reporting methods conform to the GAAP framework that they are accustomed to.4 Would you be interested in investing in the shares of a Chinese company if the numbers in the annual report you received were expressed in Renmenbi, the text written in Mandarin, and the accounting measurements based on Chinese GAAP?
Both AKZO and Nestle, mentioned earlier, have chosen to accommodate their for- eign readers by restating their financial statements to International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). AKZO’s initiative is in compliance with a European Union (EU) directive that mandates all EU listed companies to follow IASB standards. Nestle’s decision is voluntary as its decision to conform to IFRS predates the EU requirement. Issues associated with management’s use of special disclosures for nondomestic finan- cial statement readers are covered in Chapter 5.
In addition to external reporting, a firm’s internal users of accounting information, that is, financial managers and accountants, must also understand the effects of environ- mental complexities of an MNE’s accounting measurements. Discussion of these topics begins in Chapter 10. For example, understanding the effects of changes in foreign exchange and inflation rates is critical in areas such as the preparation of short- and long-term budgets for parent companies and their subsidiaries (or branches), measuring and evalu- ating the performance of local business units and managers, and making corporate-wide decisions on the allocation of investment capital and retained earnings, among others. To make matters more complex, foreign exchange and inflation rates do not work in tandem. The effect on accounting measurements of changes in foreign exchange rates and foreign inflation is so pervasive that domestic financial control systems cannot serve managers well in the absence of appropriate environmental adaptation. Then there are issues of management control. While companies often expand operations abroad to take advan- tage of low-cost labor or untapped markets, productivity and decision-making styles can be so different that company expectations are often met with disappointment. Imposing culturally inappropriate control systems on foreign managers only magnifies such disap- pointments.5 Managerial accounting from an international perspective includes possibly the most complex and detailed material in this book.