Loading...

Messages

Proposals

Stuck in your homework and missing deadline? Get urgent help in $10/Page with 24 hours deadline

Get Urgent Writing Help In Your Essays, Assignments, Homeworks, Dissertation, Thesis Or Coursework & Achieve A+ Grades.

Privacy Guaranteed - 100% Plagiarism Free Writing - Free Turnitin Report - Professional And Experienced Writers - 24/7 Online Support

Nike cost of capital case study solution

31/12/2020 Client: saad24vbs Deadline: 7 Days

Approved Logo 1 Sept 2013


Case 3


Nike Inc.: Cost of Capital


BNFN 4304- Financial Policy


Mr. Masood Aijazi


Group members:


Nour Abdulaziz 1420149


Maryam Barifah 1420023


Balquis Mekhlafi 1420231


Shrouq Al-Jaaidi 1420072


Dar Al Hekma University: Business School


Spring Semester 2017-2018


25th February 2018


Introduction


The following case is about a portfolio manager who works at North Point Group named Kimi Ford who is trying to decide whether to buy Nike’s stock. However, Nike had a negative year which lead in a severe decline in sales growth, decline in profits and market share due to supply-chain issue and it was adverse effect of a strong dollar. A meeting was held to look at different strategies where Nike has revealed that it can boost revenues by having additional exposure in mid-price footwear and apparel lines as well as exerting more effort in controlling the expenses. Analysts had very different reactions to Nike’s changes.


Kimi Ford later created her own discounted cash flow forecast (DCF) to get a clearer conclusion, she asked her assistant Joanna Cohen to estimate the cost of capital. The aim of this case and analysis is to find and show the mistakes that are arising when estimating the cost of capital which was done by Cohen. When estimating the cost of capital she used a single cost instead of a multiple one and we agree with her. Even though there are different business segments for Nike, they all seem to have the same risk, thus using a single cost is more effective. This case shows the importance of weighing a company’s stock prior to buying them via using valuation models which is the WACC the importance of carefully selecting of carefully selecting the variables that are used in the WACC formula.


1. What is the WACC and why is it important to estimate a firm’s cost of capital? What does it represent? Is the WACC set by investors or by managers?


The weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is simply the cost of the individual sources of capital. Capital is almost usually comprised of the equity that shareholders decided to in a company, or the debt that the lenders decided to invest in a company, with each source being individually being proportionally weighted. Calculating the WACC is important as when using that capital in any way would be an opportunity cost to the investors as that any capital that is being invested can be used in any other investment. In calculating the WACC the shareholders or lenders would be able to estimate the return that they would be able to earn when they decide to the invest in this company.


WACC is set by investors not by the managers, as it assists when they choose their final decision in the whether to proceed with that particular investment or not. Having the calculated the WACC which is the minimum rate of return that the investor will accept, for the investor they can find the yield that they will receive as their return by deducting the WACC from the company’s returns. If the WACC > Company’s returns investors would go ahead with their decision to invest. However, if the WACC < Company’s returns then the investor will withhold his decision to invest.


2. Do you agree with Joanna Cohen’s WACC calculation? Why or why not?


No we don’t agree with Cohen’s Weighted Average Cost of Capital for these reasons:


1. She calculated the weights of debt and equity using book value rather than market value. Book value is the price paid for an asset that will never change as long as you own that asset. Therefore, she did a mistake by using historical data in estimating the cost of debt as it is a must for her to use the market value, based on current data. The reason behind this decision is it shows how much it will cost the firm to raise the capital today.


2. Using historical data doesn’t reflect Nike’s current or future cost of debt, therefore Cohen’s cost of debt calculation which was done by taking the total interest expense for 2001 and dividing it by the company’s average debt balance is wrong. She should have instead calculated the yield to maturity on a 20-year debt basis with a coupon rate that is paid semiannually.


3. Another error that was done was using the average beta (from 1996-2001), which is 0.80, this number doesn’t represent the future systematic risk, so it is better to use the most recent beta (0.69)


3. If you do not agree with Cohen’s analysis, calculate your own WACC for Nike and justify your assumptions?


Weights of Equity and Debt:


Market value of equity = (Current Share Price x Current Shares Outstanding)


= $42.09 x 271.5 million


= $11,427.44 million.


There is not enough information to find the market value of debt, therefore, we are going to use the book value for computing:


Market Value of Debt= Current portion of long-term debt + Notes Payable + Long-Term Debt


= $5.4 m + $855.3 m + $435.9 m


= $1,296.6 million


Therefore, = = 89.81 % whereas = = 10.19%


In order to find cost of debt, what we need to do is to calculate the YTM (yield to maturity) of Nike’s bonds so that we can be able to represent the most recent cost of debt.


Current price (Po)= $95.60, Issued date= 07/15/96. Maturity date= 07/15/21, Coupon Rate= 6.75% (Semiannually), Payment (PMT)= , PAR value = $100, a 25-year bond (year 1996 minus year 2021) and since the case is in 2001 the bond was issued 5 years ago therefore N= (25-5) x 2= 40 paid semiannually. This can be calculated by either using an excel worksheet or by using a financial calculator. To calculate the YTM, we can either use the financial calculator or the excel sheet and the result would be; r= 3.58% Semiannual. Rd= 3.58% x 2= 7.16%.


So the after tax cost of debt = 7.16%(1-38%) = 4.439%


To compute the Cost of Equity (CoE), we used the 20-year treasury bond rate (5.74%) to represent the risk free rate as this rate is considered the longest one available. Choosing the 20-year rate is the most applicable, since the CoE and the WACC are actually used to discount cash flows in the long-term as well as the WACC calculations below depend on a mix of debt and equity weights both being long-term. Another reason why choosing this maturity is that long-term is better than short-term as the cumulative from 20-years is accurate that a 1-year figure. So the Rf used is equal to 5.74%.


The next step is to find the market risk premium, we used from the historical equity risk premium. The geometric mean is (5.90%) as it is actually compounded the returns where as the arithmetic mean can actually overstate the return. So the risk premium = 5.90%.


The beta used is the most recent one for 6/30/01 which is equal to 0.69.


Re=Rf +B * (Market Risk Premium)


= 5.74%+0.69 (5.90%)


= 9.811%


The tax rate that was taken was the same as what Joanna Cohen took which was computed by adding the US statutory tax rate with the state taxes (35%+3% = 38%), so the tax rate taken is 38%.


Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)= Wd x Rd x (1-T) + We x Re


=10.19% x 7.16% x (1-38%) + 89.81% x9.811%


= 9.264%.


4. Calculate the costs of equity using CAPM, the dividend discount model, and the earnings capitalization ratio. What are the advantages and disadvantages of each method? Which method is best for calculating the cost of equity? Which of these methods be most appropriate particularly for Nike and why?


Cost of Equity RE :-


a. Using Dividend Discount Model (DDM)


RE = D1/P0 + g D1 = D0 (1+g)


D0 = 0.48; g = 5.5%


D1 = 0.48 x (1+ 0.055)= 0.5064


P0 = 42.09 RE= D1/P0 + g = 0.5064/42.09 + 5.5%= 6.70%


Based on the above calculations, we can see that after June 30, 2001 the company did not pay any dividends to its shareholders, so this model (DDM) is not useful since it doesn’t reflect the intrinsic cost of capital.


Advantages of this model;


· There is a flexibility in forecasting the future dividends.


· It assists in the approximations, no matter the impact of the inputs.


· Helps in sensitivity analysis and analysis of markets variations to changing situations


· Method is very simple.


Disadvantages of this model;


· The model is not suitable to use in many cases so it will result in inaccurate answers.


· High sensitivity to minor variations in the inputs of the models and assumptions


· The model assumes that the company pays substantial dividends that will grow at a constant rate.


· It carries no consideration for systematic risk.


b. Using Earning Capitalization Model


ECM= E1 / P0 = 2.16 / 42.09 = 5.13%


E1: forecasted earnings, current diluted earnings per share P0: stock price today.


This model is not recommended due to that that it ignores the potential growth of the firm.


Advantages of this model;


· It helps in predicting the earnings


· It carries consideration for the forecasted earnings and the current price of the stock.


Disadvantages of this model;


· It ignores the growth of the company


· This model is not appropriate for the firms with no growth


· The estimates may not be accurate


· It has errors in the current capitalization rate.


c. Using Capital Asset Pricing Model(CAPM) to calculate RE:


RE = RRF + (RM – RRF) x Beta


→RE =5.74% + 5.9% x 0.69 = 9.811%


The model is the recommended way to calculate the cost of equity for Nike Inc., as it is very simple to apply, an addition to that it includes the most important variables for instance Beta (systematic risk), risk free rate and also market return.


Advantages of this model;


· Simple


· Applied in practice


· Adjusts for risk


· Can be used by companies that do not have steady dividend growth


Disadvantages of this model;


· Unrealistic assumptions specially in estimations of risk free rate


· Sometimes it fails in explaining the behaviors of the investors and the used beta will not be successful in capturing the risk of investment


· Difficult to validity


· Predicts future based on past (there is change in economic conditions)


· It is important to consider the market value, book values ratios, as it is highly relevant to return.


5. What should Kimi Ford recommend regarding an investment in Nike?


The calculated WACC is 9.27% and the present value per share is $58.13 (15,782.295/271.5). This shows that the present value is higher by 1.38 times than Nike’s current market price of $42.09. The shares price of Nike is undervalued by $16.04 (58.13-42.09) as Nike is presently trading in 2001. The current growth rate that is about 6 to 7% is much lower than the one estimated which was 9.27%. This value is considered majorly understated. Nike Changed their business technique by focusing in mid-priced segment, which for a long time was less concentrated. This means that there is a possibility for their sales total to increase that that will lead to an increase in revenues and profit. In addition to this Nike’s share prices and dividend will be increased in the long-term.


Based on these records, we recommend to the North Point Large-Cap Fund to buy Nike’s shares, because the stock is currently undervalued and it has a major growth potential that will be beneficial to the fund. In addition to this, the goals that were set by the management of Nike Inc. could be a great source of profit. Also by the past performance of Nike Inc. shares against the market index, technical analysis supports the buy decision. The past performance shows that Nike can out preform the current market returns and now that it has gone down, it is left with the hope for an increase based on the plans being set up.


Conclusion


In conclusion, before buying Nike Inc. shares, Kimi Ford must decide whether she wants the shares for long or short term. If it is for the long-term, then the decision to invest is a good one and if it is for the short-term she should be cautious about the fast changing industry the changes that Nike is doing and also changes in the footwear trends. However, based on historical, recent and future data the decision that Kimi should consider that is to buy Nike’s shares for the reason that it is quite safe, currently undervalued and has great potential.


References


Baker, H. and Martin, G. (2011). Capital structure & corporate financing decisions.


Hoboken, NJ.:John Wiley & Sons.


Brealey, R., Myers, S and Allen, F. (2017). Principles of corporate finance. New York, NY:


McGraw-Hill Education.

Homework is Completed By:

Writer Writer Name Amount Client Comments & Rating
Instant Homework Helper

ONLINE

Instant Homework Helper

$36

She helped me in last minute in a very reasonable price. She is a lifesaver, I got A+ grade in my homework, I will surely hire her again for my next assignments, Thumbs Up!

Order & Get This Solution Within 3 Hours in $25/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 3 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 6 Hours in $20/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 6 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 12 Hours in $15/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 12 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

6 writers have sent their proposals to do this homework:

Top Essay Tutor
Homework Guru
Helping Hand
University Coursework Help
Quick Mentor
Coursework Assignment Help
Writer Writer Name Offer Chat
Top Essay Tutor

ONLINE

Top Essay Tutor

I have more than 12 years of experience in managing online classes, exams, and quizzes on different websites like; Connect, McGraw-Hill, and Blackboard. I always provide a guarantee to my clients for their grades.

$40 Chat With Writer
Homework Guru

ONLINE

Homework Guru

Hi dear, I am ready to do your homework in a reasonable price and in a timely manner.

$37 Chat With Writer
Helping Hand

ONLINE

Helping Hand

I am an Academic writer with 10 years of experience. As an Academic writer, my aim is to generate unique content without Plagiarism as per the client’s requirements.

$35 Chat With Writer
University Coursework Help

ONLINE

University Coursework Help

Hi dear, I am ready to do your homework in a reasonable price.

$37 Chat With Writer
Quick Mentor

ONLINE

Quick Mentor

Hey, I have gone through your job posting and become very much interested in working with you.I can deliver professional content as per your requirements. I am a multi-skilled person with sound proficiency in the English language for being a native writer who worked on several similar projects of content writing and can deliver quality content to tight deadlines. I am available for both online and offline writing jobs with the promise of offering an incredibly responsive and supreme level of customer service. Thanks!

$30 Chat With Writer
Coursework Assignment Help

ONLINE

Coursework Assignment Help

Hey, I have gone through your job posting and become very much interested in working with you.I can deliver professional content as per your requirements. I am a multi-skilled person with sound proficiency in the English language for being a native writer who worked on several similar projects of content writing and can deliver quality content to tight deadlines. I am available for both online and offline writing jobs with the promise of offering an incredibly responsive and supreme level of customer service. Thanks!

$30 Chat With Writer

Let our expert academic writers to help you in achieving a+ grades in your homework, assignment, quiz or exam.

Similar Homework Questions

Starbucks fdi case study - Geos Question - Pp management - Carousel symbolism catcher in the rye - Governmental Reporting Presentation - Green mountain coffee roasters annual report - NURSING Care plan - The whole health cairn - Project management simulation scope resources and schedule scenario f - Relate modernization theory to dependency theory. - Briefly explain the basic characteristics of ordinary life policies - Coal a human history - Extra Credit - Assignment OE - Official beer pong rules - Jorge company bottles and distributes - Strickland v rocla concrete pipes - Grandma’s Tomato Farm - Persuasive speech on exercise - Www nbcsd k12 ms us - Final project Securing Ownership of the Software, Trade Secret, Customer Data Collection and Protection, Internal Financial Data Structuring and Compliance - Who invented the sundial - Reflective journal-self appraisal 5 - Interpreting the radial probability distribution of an orbital - Naive ticket machine project in bluej - DQ ! MICRO BIO 4 - 3 pigs in animal farm - Bubup womindjeka family and children's centre - Synthesizing the american dream essay - A beautiful mind discussion questions - Royles wilmslow bike shop - Approximate price range for non residential property - Wuthering heights chapter 5 summary - Mechanical advantage and efficiency worksheet answer key - Moloch owl god california - Eighth planet from the sun - Assignment - Gcse science biology boardworks - Concept analysis in Nursing - Autonomy - Fair trade laws in marketing channels are intended to - Revising and presenting your writing - Eagle corporation owns stock in hawk corporation - Hewlett packard case - Charities sorp frs 102 - Discussion 2.1 - Ford smart charge system - Essentials of business communication 11th edition pdf free - J trading full circle outsourcing - Mycreditfile com au corrections - Factor x 2 6x 25 - Angus young string gauge - Costco executive summary - Assignment 2 - Key themes of hamlet - Dissertation topic in Cyber security or Blockchain. - Biodevices Research - Btn the gallipoli story - Information Technology - Safeguard s100 paper shredder - Cinnamon soho kingly street - How to calculate aspect ratio of a wing - Nhs pension scheme pn1 - Organization Design & Development Case study - Pearson architectural design began operations on january - Pros and cons of repeated measures design - Dublin city council planning applications - Epidemiology for public health practice 5th edition answer key - Three lines of defence immune system - Ancient greece essay topics - Sam sneads early bird menu - Incidents in the life of a slave girl intended audience - Week 3 DQ2 - Ernie dances to the didgeridoo youtube - The astonishing color of after sparknotes - Assignment - American History Discussion - Cisco commerce workspace tool - Nanda nursing diagnosis for lymphedema - Fire rescue safety australia - 57 strathtay bus timetable - National 5 chemistry course specification - How to use eoq formula in excel - Water rocket launcher designs - Ln-25 wire feeder manual - Discussion board (respond to student post below) - Reply to an informal invitation - If ebenezer scrooge spends rather than saves his vast wealth he will - Mount gambier city bus timetable - Week 5 Discussion - Digital cell phone inc case study solution - Culture of international business - Complete nes collection list - Aac block u value - Objectives of emirates airlines - Rn adult medical surgical online practice 2019 a - Rubrics for role playing - Paper - Telephone script for research recruitment - You purchase a bond with an invoice price of - Taylex tanks code 3