Loading...

Messages

Proposals

Stuck in your homework and missing deadline? Get urgent help in $10/Page with 24 hours deadline

Get Urgent Writing Help In Your Essays, Assignments, Homeworks, Dissertation, Thesis Or Coursework & Achieve A+ Grades.

Privacy Guaranteed - 100% Plagiarism Free Writing - Free Turnitin Report - Professional And Experienced Writers - 24/7 Online Support

Nortel case study

28/12/2020 Client: saad24vbs Deadline: 12 Hours

Page 1 of 10


NORTEL NETWORKS CORPORATION*


ETHICAL MISSTEPS


Linda A. Robinson


Centre for Accounting Ethics School of Accountancy University of Waterloo Waterloo ON N2L 3G1


June 2005


* This case has been developed from publicly available information solely for discussion purposes and does not purport to be a complete and accurate recounting of all relevant


facts, events and conditions.


Page 2 of 10


Acknowledgment:


I would like to thank Efrim Boritz, Allan Foerster and Alister Mason for their helpful comments on this case


Page 3 of 10


NORTEL NETWORKS CORPORATION


Learning Objectives


This case is designed for use in an ethics, auditing or corporate governance course. Through the case, students are encouraged to consider how a corporation once considered a Canadian jewel could lose its way ethically.


Background


It has been a long road that brought Nortel Networks Corporation (“Nortel”) to its present state. Northern Telecom, known as Northern Electric until 1976, was at one time a wholly owned subsidiary of Bell Canada. By the mid 1980’s Northern Telecom was the second largest supplier of telecommunications equipment, largely electronic telephone switches, in North America. Northern Telecom expanded worldwide firstly into Asia then Europe, followed by Latin America. In 1995 Northern Telecom shortens its name to Nortel. Bell Canada, later known as BCE, divested its interest in Northern Telecom throughout the 1970’s owning just over 50 percent by 1980. Finally in 2000, BCE distributed its remaining ownership interest in Nortel to the shareholders of BCE.


Not only was Nortel a telecommunications company, it was a major research powerhouse, receiving substantial support from provincial and national governments. The bulk of Nortel’s R&D was done in Canada to take advantage of generous R & D tax incentives.


Nortel, despite its large size, international shareholders and global reach, was still a “Canadian” company, with the majority of its management and board of directors’ Canadian citizens.


It was John Roth (“Roth”) CEO who took Nortel from traditional telephone technology to the Internet.1 Nortel equipment carried 75 percent of the North American Internet traffic in the late 1990’s. The company’s growth was due to both the explosion in the Internet market and through acquisitions. In 2000 alone, Nortel acquired 11 companies at a cost of US$19.7 billion. By 1998, Nortel was Canada’s largest telecommunication company with 73,000 employees and revenues of US$22 billion.2


The bubble burst when Nortel’s customers stopped buying telecom equipment in the great high-tech bust in 2001. As the industry imploded, Nortel seemed the most secure, until it announced huge declines in prospective sales.


1 CBC.CA News Nortel: Canada’s Tech Giant, May 2, 2005 2 CBC.CA News Northern Telecom buys American firm Nov 13, 1998


Page 4 of 10


During 2000, Nortel, with over 3.8 billion shares outstanding, accounted for greater than one third of the value of the entire S&P/TSX 300 composite index. Nortel shares peaked at the end of July 2000 at Cdn$124.50, giving Nortel a total market capitalization of $473.1 billion. As a secure, growing Canadian company, the company’s shares were held in a large number of institutional and private investor portfolios. In addition, due to Canada’s restrictive rules with respect to pension plans’ investing in foreign securities, Nortel was the most widely held security in Canada. The shares took a two-year slide bottoming out in September 2002 at under Cdn$1. The once mighty Nortel risked being de-listed from the NYSE, which, under exchange rules, can happen if a stock closes below US$1 for 30 consecutive trading days.3 By 2002, Nortel’s long-term debt was downgraded to “junk” status.


The desperate times from mid 2000 through 2002 called for desperate measures. Roth, who had been named Canada’s ‘business leader of the year’ in 2000, announced in April 2001 his intention to step down as CEO . Roth was replaced as CEO in October 2001 by Frank Dunn (“Dunn”), CMA, Nortel’s CFO since 1999. In 2001, Nortel reduced its workforce by 50% to 45,000 with a further 10,000 job cuts in 2002.


In the third quarter of 2002, CFO Doug Beatty directed a company-wide analysis of provisions. Upon completion, Controller Michael Gollogly reported an excess of $303 million of accruals much of which had been left over from charges taken in prior years. Upon determination of the excess, GAAP required that the accruals be immediately released to income. Both Beatty and Gollgoly, officers of the Company withheld disclosure of their discovery from the Audit Committee and the Board. From this point forward, senior divisional finance managers were instructed to report the “hardness” of any excess provisions they were carrying in their divisional records.


During the close of Q4 2002, it was determined that Nortel would report profitability on an “internal” pro forma basis. Under the direction of Frank Dunn, Beatty and Gollogly undertook another review that resulted in a “top-side” increase of $175 million to the reserve account producing a loss and increasing the “hardness” of consolidated provisions. Unlike the reserves that were identified in the second quarter that mainly related to previously estimated cost for restructuring these new reserves were related to valuations estimates on accounts receivable and inventory.


Morale at Nortel was quite low by mid 2002, after the employee base of the company had shrunk to one third of pre-2001 level. Bonus plans involving stock options were substantially “out-of-the-money.” To motivate the remaining employees and convince them to stay at Nortel, the board of directors established a bonus plan tied to profitability. One plan, called the Return to Profitability (“RTP”) bonus, was to pay a one-time bonus to every employee, except the 43 most senior executives, in the first quarter the company achieved a pro forma profit. The senior 43 executives were eligible to receive 20 percent of their share of the RTP bonus in the first quarter in which Nortel attained profitability, 40 percent after the second consecutive quarter and the remaining 40 percent upon the 3 CBC.CA News Nortel: The wild ride of Canada’s most watched stock, May 2, 2005


Page 5 of 10


fourth quarter of cumulative profitability. In order for the RTP bonuses to be paid, the pro forma quarterly profit had to exceed the bonuses paid by at least one dollar. Further, the 43 executives were eligible to receive Restricted Stock Units (“RSU’s”) tied to internal profit targets. The RTP and RSU allocations were based on internal, non-GAAP metrics. Deloitte & Touche LLP who audited Nortel’s annual financial statements did not audit the quarterly statements upon which the bonuses were calculated. Nortel paid out approximately US$50 million in bonuses to the select group of officers based on the pro forma financial statements after profits were reported during the second quarter of 2003. Dunn’s share was US$2.15 million.


At a Board meeting in January of 2003, management indicated that Q1 was going to be a loss of approximately $110 million despite the drastic restructuring that had taken place in previous years. By the close of the quarter, the loss had in fact turned into a US$54 million profit in the first quarter of 2003, its first profit in three years. This resulted in the payment of the RTP cash bonus to virtually all employees and the first tranche to 43 executives. Behind the scenes, Dunn and the finance team had established “roadmaps” that would achieve internal EBT targets by the timely, but non-GAAP release of provisions to income. The Q1 2002 results were inflated by the release of $361 million of accruals to income. Dunn, Beatty and Gollogly continued to represent these adjustments to the Audit Committee and Board as “business as usual”.


In August 2003, Nortel posted a second quarterly profit. The profit was the direct result of $370 million in excess provisions released to income. The 43 executives now received the second tranche of RTP and the RSU’s. On October 23, 2003, in the same press release that Nortel announced third quarter earnings of US$179 million, it advised that a restatement of previous financial statements was required. The restatement would affect the financial statements back to 2000, reducing previously reported net losses and increasing net assets.


As is often the case, the board of directors established a Special Committee to review the reasons for the restatement. The US law firm of Wilmer Cutler was engaged to assist the Special Committee in their review of the restatement. As a result of the review, it was determined that a second restatement of Nortel’s financial statements would be required. The second restatement was completed with the issuance of the December 31, 2003 financial statements on January 10, 2005.


As a result of the review, ten employees were terminated for cause including the CEO, Frank Dunn, the CFO Douglas Beatty and the Controller Michael Gollogly. The remaining seven employees all held senior finance positions throughout the global operating units of Nortel. They were all requested to repay bonuses received. A further twelve senior executives who were not terminated, voluntarily agreed to repay their bonuses. William Owen, a former Admiral in the US Navy, and deputy chief of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff, replaced Dunn as CEO.

Homework is Completed By:

Writer Writer Name Amount Client Comments & Rating
Instant Homework Helper

ONLINE

Instant Homework Helper

$36

She helped me in last minute in a very reasonable price. She is a lifesaver, I got A+ grade in my homework, I will surely hire her again for my next assignments, Thumbs Up!

Order & Get This Solution Within 3 Hours in $25/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 3 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 6 Hours in $20/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 6 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 12 Hours in $15/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 12 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

6 writers have sent their proposals to do this homework:

Homework Guru
University Coursework Help
Helping Hand
Top Essay Tutor
Writer Writer Name Offer Chat
Homework Guru

ONLINE

Homework Guru

Hi dear, I am ready to do your homework in a reasonable price and in a timely manner.

$132 Chat With Writer
University Coursework Help

ONLINE

University Coursework Help

Hi dear, I am ready to do your homework in a reasonable price.

$132 Chat With Writer
Helping Hand

ONLINE

Helping Hand

I am an Academic writer with 10 years of experience. As an Academic writer, my aim is to generate unique content without Plagiarism as per the client’s requirements.

$130 Chat With Writer
Top Essay Tutor

ONLINE

Top Essay Tutor

I have more than 12 years of experience in managing online classes, exams, and quizzes on different websites like; Connect, McGraw-Hill, and Blackboard. I always provide a guarantee to my clients for their grades.

$135 Chat With Writer

Let our expert academic writers to help you in achieving a+ grades in your homework, assignment, quiz or exam.

Similar Homework Questions

Digital capacitance meter using 555 timer - Health the basics 13th edition by rebecca j donatelle - Discovery bible study worksheet - Pr 9 5a transactions for fixed assets including sale - Medical referral letter template - What is the message of alice walker short story elethia - Muslim Molvi 7340613399 OnLine No 1 FaMOUs VashIKaraN sPecIaLIsT IN Davanagere - Which of the following best characterizes jit systems - Higher business management course notes - Dunlopillo latex pillow david jones - Operational Excellence - Objects that represent communication - Midnight 24 hour time - How junk food can end obesity thesis - Eassy on high school starting time, we the theses , we need to give talk about our waking up while we were in school, is a five body paragraph - Kali linux vmware image download - Descriptive Paragraph Instructions - Ubd stage 3 examples - Weekly Insight #2 - International interlac 665 sds - Lump sum contract risk - Tynemet part time courses - Business & society stakeholders etc edition 15th - California pizza kitchen case study - Zoot suit act 1 summary - Case Study: Mortgage Approval Time Study - Assistive devices program mobility devices - The law of diminishing marginal utility explains why - Torsion of circular sections lab report - Https lc ugrad1 gcu edu - Both rdp and tq share the idea that - Celia a slave book notes - 207 allen way incline village - Human population growth most closely resembles - Cyclone in a bottle - Isbn 13 978 1496300232 - Ikea invades america - How to apply for trade support loan - Walden university advanced pharmacology syllabus - Bp oil spill pr case study - L atm to kj - LEADERSHIP AND CREATIVE SOLUTIONS - Non homogeneous differential equation table - Essay - Database Project - Discussion - Khan academy periodic table classification of elements - Anthem for the doomed youth - Need Essay paper done - Learning strengths - Mirror ray diagram worksheet - Criminal law discussion 14 - First angle third angle - Where is nasty gal warehouse located - 4 ways an organism can become a fossil - Java coding - Memorial hermann financial assistance - Can polynomials have negative exponents - International economics solution manual - Old darby whiskey price - Index of project blue book - Nysc 36th and madison gay - Change phone number outlook - Should everyone go to college they say i say questions - Latvian song and dance festival 2013 - As1170 3 free download - House of payne bake rattle and roll - Lack of ho2s11 switches - sensor indicates rich - A student pipets 5.00 ml of ethanol - Factor tree of 56 - Honeywell st9100a wiring diagram - Hand operated can crusher - Ferrero csr report 2019 - Anderson greenwood 81 series - Robert cooper stage gate process - Belvedere vacuum breaker asse 1001 kit - Lesson - Homework market - Wk 4, HCS 335: DQ - Research Paper - Harmonie water case study - Worldventures back office login - An astronaut on a distant planet wants to determine - Understanding globalization george brown - Thread 1 & 2 (160 words each) - Senior advocate job description - Preparing a buret for titration - Effects of climate change and global warming. Discuss. - Where does orographic rainfall occur in australia - Maturity narrative essay - My compliments to the chef er robot - M2 boscombe to poole - Help 2 - What shape has the smallest surface area to volume ratio - Distributive property of equality example - St john the baptist margate - Qualitative analysis of cations ag+ fe3+ cu2+ and ni2+ lab report - Tata steel d200 deck - Bt employer super pds - Discussion