Loading...

Messages

Proposals

Stuck in your homework and missing deadline? Get urgent help in $10/Page with 24 hours deadline

Get Urgent Writing Help In Your Essays, Assignments, Homeworks, Dissertation, Thesis Or Coursework & Achieve A+ Grades.

Privacy Guaranteed - 100% Plagiarism Free Writing - Free Turnitin Report - Professional And Experienced Writers - 24/7 Online Support

Phar mor fraud case

09/01/2021 Client: saad24vbs Deadline: 3 days

Phar-Mor


The Dilemma The story of Phar-Mor shows how quickly a company that built its earnings on fraudulent transactions can dissolve like an Alka-Seltzer. One day, Stan Cherelstein, the controller of Phar-Mor, discovered cabinets stuffed with held checks totaling $10 million. Phar-Mor couldn't release the checks to vendors because it did not have enough cash in the bank to cover the amount. Cherelstein wondered what he should do. Background Phar-Mor was a chain of discount drug stores, based in Youngstown, Ohio, and founded in 1982 by Michael Monus and David Shapira. In less than 10 years, the company grew from 15 to 310 stores and had 25,000 employees. According to Litigation Release No. 14716 issued by the SEC,l Phar-Mor had cumulatively overstated income by $290 million between 1987 and 1991. In 1992, prior to disclosure of the fraud, the company overstated income by an additional $238 million. The Cast of Characters Mickey Monus personifies the hard-driving entrepreneur who is bound and determined to make it big whatever the cost. He served as the president and chief operating officer (COO) of Phar-Mor from its inception until a corporate restructuring was announced on July 28, 1992. David Shapira was the CEO of both Phar-Mor and Giant Eagle, Phar-Mor' s parent company and majority stockholder. Giant Eagle also owned Tamco, which was one of Phar-Mor's major suppliers. Shapira left day-to-day operations of Phar-Mor to Monus until the fraud became too large and persistent to ignore. Patrick Finn was the CFO of Phar-Mor from 1988 to 1992. Finn, who holds the Certified Management Accountant (CMA) certification, initially brought Monus the bad news that following a number of years of eroding profits, the company faced millions in losses in 1989. John Anderson was the accounting manager at Phar-Mor. Hired after completing a college degree in accounting at Youngstown State University, Anderson became a part of the fraud.


Coopers & Lybrand, prior to its merger with Price Waterhouse, were the auditors of Phar-Mor.


The firm failed to detect the fraud as it was unfolding.


How It Started


The facts of this case are taken from the SEC filing and a PBS Frontline episode called "How to


Steal $500 Million." The interpretation of the facts is consistent with reports, but some literary


license has been taken to add intrigue to the case.


Finn approached Monus with the bad news. Monus took out his pen, crossed off the losses,


and then wrote in higher numbers to show a profit. Monus couldn't bear the thought of his hot


growth company that had been sizzling for five years suddenly flaming out. In the beginning, it


was to be a short- term fix to buy time while the company improved efficiency, put the heat on


suppliers for lower prices, and turned a profit. Finn believed in Monus's ability to tum things


around, so he went along with the fraud. Finn prepared the reports, and Monus changed the


numbers for four months before turning the task over to Finn. These reports with the false


numbers were faxed to Shapira and given to Phar-Mor's board. Basically, the company was lying


to its owners.


The fraud occurred by dumping the losses into a "bucket account" and then reallocating the


sums to one of the company's hundreds of stores in the form of increases in inventory amounts.


Phar-Mor issued fake invoices for merchandise purchases and made phony journal entries to


increase inventory and decrease cost of sales. The company overcounted and double-counted


merchandise in inventory.


The fraud was helped by the fact that the auditors from Coopers observed inventory in only


4 out of 300 stores, and that allowed the finance department at Phar-Mor to conceal the


shortages. Moreover, Coopers informed Phar-Mor in advance which stores they would visit.


Phar-Mor executives fully stocked the 4 selected stores but allocated the phony inventory


increases to the other 296 stores. Regardless of the accounting tricks, Phar-Mor was heading


for collapse and its suppliers threatened to cut off the company for nonpayment of bills.


Stan Cherelstein's Role


Cherelstein, a CPA, was hired to be the controller of Phar-Mor in 1991, long after the fraud had


begun. One day, Anderson, Phar-Mor's accounting manager, called Cherelstein into his office


and explained that the company had been keeping two sets of books-one that showed the true


state of the company with the losses and the other, called the "subledger," that showed the


falsified numbers that were presented to the auditors.


Cherelstein and Anderson discussed what to do about the fraud. Cherelstein was not happy


about it at all and demanded to meet with Monus. Cherelstein did get Monus to agree to repay


the company for the losses from Monus's (personal) investment of company funds into the


World Basketball League (WBL). But Monus never kept his word. In the beginning, Cherelstein


felt compelled to give Monus some time to tum things around through increased efficiencies


and by using a device called "exclusivity fees," which vendors paid to get Phar-Mor to stock their


products. Over time, Cherelstein became more and more uncomfortable as the suppliers called


more and more frequently, demanding payment on their invoices.


Accounting Fraud


Misappropriation of Assets


The unfortunate reality of the Phar-Mor saga was that it involved not only bogus inventory but also


the diversion of company funds to feed Monus's personal habits. One example was the movement


of $10 million in company funds to help start the WBL.


False Financial Statements


According to the ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals that heard Monus's appeal of his conviction on


all 109 counts of fraud, the company submitted false financial statements to Pittsburgh National


Bank, which increased a revolving credit line for Phar-Mor from $435 million to $600 million in March


1992. It also defrauded Corporate Partners, an investment group that bought $200 million in Phar-


Mor stock in June 1991. The list goes on, including the defrauding of Chemical Bank, which served as


the placing agent for


$155 million in 10-year senior secured notes issued to Phar-Mor; Westinghouse Credit Corporation,


which had executed a $50 million loan commitment to Phar-Mor in 1987; and Westminster National


Bank, which served as the placing agent for $112 million in Phar-Mor stock sold to various financial


institutions in 1991.


Tamco Relationship


The early financial troubles experienced by Phar-Mor in 1988 can be attributed to at least two


transactions. The first was that the company provided deep discounts to retailers to stock its


stores with product. There was concern early on that the margins were too thin. The second was


that its supplier, Tamco, was shipping partial orders to Phar-Mor while billing for full orders. Phar-


Mor had no way of knowing this because it was not logging in shipments from Tamco.


After the deficiency was discovered, Giant Eagle agreed to pay Phar-Mor $7 million in 1988 on


behalf of Tamco. Phar-Mor later bought Tamco from Giant Eagle in an additional effort to solve


the inventory and billing problems. However, the losses just kept on coming.


Back to the Dilemma


Cherelstein looked out the window at the driving rain. He thought about the fact that he didn't


start the fraud or engage in the cover-up. Still, he knows about it now and feels compelled to do


something. Cherelstein thought about the persistent complaints by vendors that they were not


being paid and their threats to cut off shipments to Phar-Mor. Cherelstein knows that without


any product in Phar-Mor stores, the company could not last much longer.


Questions


1. How do you assess blame for the fraud? That is, to what extent was it caused by Finn's willingness


to go along with the actions of Monus? What about Shapira's lax oversight? Should all the blame


go to Monus? What role did Coopers & Lybrand play with respect to its professional judgment?


2. Assume Cherelstein decides to use Rest's Model of Morality to reason out what the right thing


to do is and how to carry out the action. Apply the logic of the model to Cherelstein's decision-


making process. What do you think he should do at this point and why?


3. What is the ethical message of Phar-Mor? That is, explain what you think is the moral of this


story.


Securities and Exchange Commission, Litigation Release No. 14716, November 9, 1995, SEC v. Michael Manus, Patrick Finn, John Anderson and Jeffrey Walley, Case No. 4:95, CV 975 (N.D. OH, filed May 2, 1995), www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/ lrl 4716.txt.


http://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/

Homework is Completed By:

Writer Writer Name Amount Client Comments & Rating
Instant Homework Helper

ONLINE

Instant Homework Helper

$36

She helped me in last minute in a very reasonable price. She is a lifesaver, I got A+ grade in my homework, I will surely hire her again for my next assignments, Thumbs Up!

Order & Get This Solution Within 3 Hours in $25/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 3 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 6 Hours in $20/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 6 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

Order & Get This Solution Within 12 Hours in $15/Page

Custom Original Solution And Get A+ Grades

  • 100% Plagiarism Free
  • Proper APA/MLA/Harvard Referencing
  • Delivery in 12 Hours After Placing Order
  • Free Turnitin Report
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Privacy Guaranteed

6 writers have sent their proposals to do this homework:

Top Essay Tutor
Helping Hand
University Coursework Help
Best Coursework Help
Writer Writer Name Offer Chat
Top Essay Tutor

ONLINE

Top Essay Tutor

I have more than 12 years of experience in managing online classes, exams, and quizzes on different websites like; Connect, McGraw-Hill, and Blackboard. I always provide a guarantee to my clients for their grades.

$65 Chat With Writer
Helping Hand

ONLINE

Helping Hand

I am an Academic writer with 10 years of experience. As an Academic writer, my aim is to generate unique content without Plagiarism as per the client’s requirements.

$60 Chat With Writer
University Coursework Help

ONLINE

University Coursework Help

Hi dear, I am ready to do your homework in a reasonable price.

$62 Chat With Writer
Best Coursework Help

ONLINE

Best Coursework Help

I am an Academic writer with 10 years of experience. As an Academic writer, my aim is to generate unique content without Plagiarism as per the client’s requirements.

$60 Chat With Writer

Let our expert academic writers to help you in achieving a+ grades in your homework, assignment, quiz or exam.

Similar Homework Questions

The blind side description - ECON Forum Replies - Qnt 561 week 5 - Internal control case study with answer - How to find geometric multiplicity - Contemporary issues in business management - Chapter 2 essay - Congressional gridlock causes and solutions - Research Assignment 2: Revise proposal topic - Climax of the glass menagerie - Australian standard 1319 whs safety sign colour guidelines - Final Plan - Appraising the secretaries at sweetwater u case study ppt - Covid Newsletters - Dorothy stringer high school - Rewireable fuse bs 3036 - Chapter 8 test a accounting answer key - Parramatta street parking permit - COMS 301 - EC - Psychology questions - Bank reconciliation and adjusting entries example - Introduction to polar coordinates worksheet - Rv matthews and alleyne 2003 - How does temperature affect mold growth on bread - Sociology Question DQ1 - Noroclav tablets for dogs - 2085 kj to calories - Museo nacional de banco central de ecuador - Www ucmp berkeley education explorations tours fossil index html - Satya jewelry sample sale nyc - 97 confidence interval z score - Strategic management text and cases 7th edition pdf free - Dangers of facial electrical treatments - 32 cheadle crescent bundoora - The coddling of the american mind chapter 1 summary - Vic police air wing tracker - Sand dune regeneration advantages and disadvantages - Discussion: Root Cause Analysis - Max in-plane principal stress abaqus - Board skills matrix aicd - The three signs of a miserable job pdf - Mja lessons from practice - ASSIGNMENT 1 PREPARATION: USP AND POSITIONING STATEMENT & MOTTO - Happy endings margaret atwood analysis - University of worcester sustainability - Cell poem that rhymes - Advantages of hard engineering - Athlean x free workouts - Word module 2 sam exam - Management Information System - Everlasting god fellowship church chords - The devil wears prada discussion questions - Rite aid pharmacy mission statement - 19/14 warringah road mosman - Hating alison ashley cast - Family life cycle chart - Persuasive speech outline on credit cards - How to identify stereogenic centers - Discussion #2 - Module 4 - Periodical Report - Unit I Assessment - Accounting III- Week 4 Discussion - Case Study 1: Part 1 Gulf Oil Spill - IOCAS1 - Managerial Epidemiology Week 2 project - Barnsley federation of racing pigeons - Who wrote blood brothers - Deliverable 4 - Evaluating Financing Strategies/ EXCEL FILE AND EMAIL - SOCIOLOGY - Diversity trends in leadership - LabView Program - Religion test year 10 - What challenges did mary face - How to prepare retained earnings statement - Curriculum development and evaluation in nursing - Examine the geologic cross section below - A wt aqueous sulfuric acid solution - David wallace suck it hoodie - 5 sentences about train - What is Public Health? - Safe work industry module - International marketing and export management 7th edition pdf - Coca cola company risks - An inconvenient truth question answers - Wendy Lewis 1 - Spssexam sav - Needs a Rough Draft AND Final Draft - What does vorsprung durch technik mean in english - +91-8306951337 love marriage specialist astrologer IN Faridabad - Bass clef practice worksheet - Spirax sarco steam powered condensate pump - Earnest pugh net worth - National curriculum for early childhood education 2007 pakistan pdf - Burke research phone calls - Indole reaction with kovac's reagent - How to cite sentinel city in apa format - Experiment 3: the importance of cell cycle control - Kaiser permanente hazard vulnerability analysis - Structural devices in literature - Identify the literature that addresses the disclosure of accounting policies