Loading...

Messages

Proposals

Stuck in your homework and missing deadline?

Get Urgent Writing Help In Your Essays, Assignments, Homeworks, Dissertation, Thesis Or Coursework & Achieve A+ Grades.

Privacy Guaranteed - 100% Plagiarism Free Writing - Free Turnitin Report - Professional And Experienced Writers - 24/7 Online Support

Digital wwnorton com theysay4

20/03/2021 Client: saad24vbs Deadline: 24 Hours

“YES / NO / OKAY, BUT”

Three Ways to Respond

THE FIRST THREE CHAPTERS of this book discuss the “they say” stage of writing, in which you devote your attention to the views of some other person or group. In this chapter we move to the “I say” stage, in which you offer your own argument as a response to what “they” have said.

Moving to the “I say” stage can be daunting in academia, where it often may seem that you need to be an expert in a field to have an argument at all. Many students have told us that they have trouble entering some of the high-powered conversations that take place in college or graduate school because they do not know enough about the topic at hand or because, they say, they simply are not “smart enough.” Yet often these same students, when given a chance to study in depth the contribution that some scholar has made in a given field, will turn around and say things like “I can see where she is coming from, how she makes her case by building on what other scholars have said. Perhaps had I studied the situation longer I could have come up with a similar argument.” What these students come to realize is that good arguments are based not on knowledge that only a special class of experts has access to, but on everyday habits of mind that can be isolated, identified, and used by almost anyone. Though there’s certainly no substitute for expertise and for knowing as much as possible about one’s topic, the arguments that finally win the day are built, as the title of this chapter suggests, on some very basic rhetorical patterns that most of us use on a daily basis.

FOUR “YES / NO / OKAY, BUT”: Three Ways to Respond

chapter04.htm[7/18/2018 10:22:51 AM]

It is always a good tactic to begin your response not by launching directly into a mass of details but by stating clearly whether you agree,

See p. 21 for suggestions

on previewing where you

stand.

There are a great many ways to respond to others’ ideas, but this chapter concentrates on the three most common and recognizable ways: agreeing, disagreeing, or some combination of both. Although each way of responding is open to endless variation, we focus on these three because readers come to any text needing to learn fairly quickly where the writer stands, and they do this by placing the writer on a mental map consisting of a few familiar options: the writer agrees with those he or she is responding to, disagrees with them, or presents some combination of both agreeing and disagreeing.

When writers take too long to declare their position relative to views they’ve summarized or quoted, readers get frustrated, wondering, “Is this guy agreeing or disagreeing? Is he for what this other person has said, against it, or what?” For this reason, this chapter’s advice applies to reading as well as to writing. Especially with difficult texts, you need not only to find the position the writer is responding to—the “they say”—but also to determine whether the writer is agreeing with it, challenging it, or some mixture of the two.

ONLY THREE WAYS TO RESPOND?

Perhaps you’ll worry that fitting your own response into one of these three categories will force you to oversimplify your argument or lessen its complexity, subtlety, or originality. This is certainly a serious concern for academics who are rightly skeptical of writing that is simplistic and reductive. We would argue, however, that the more complex and subtle your argument is, and the more it departs from the conventional ways people think, the more your readers will need to be able to place it on their mental map in order to process the complex details you present. That is, the complexity, subtlety, and originality of your response are more likely to stand out and be noticed if readers have a baseline sense of where you stand relative to any ideas you’ve cited. As you move through this chapter, we hope you’ll agree that the forms of agreeing, disagreeing, and both agreeing and disagreeing that we discuss, far from being simplistic or one-dimensional, are able to accommodate a high degree of creative, complex thought.

https://digital.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/theysay4/EPUB/content/chapter01.xhtml#page_21
FOUR “YES / NO / OKAY, BUT”: Three Ways to Respond

chapter04.htm[7/18/2018 10:22:51 AM]

disagree, or both, using a direct, no-nonsense formula such as: “I agree,” “I disagree,” or “I am of two minds. I agree that __________, but I cannot agree that __________.” Once you have offered one of these straightforward statements (or one of the many variations discussed below), readers will have a strong grasp of your position and then be able to appreciate the complications you go on to offer as your response unfolds.

Still, you may object that these three basic ways of responding don’t cover all the options—that they ignore interpretive or analytical responses, for example. In other words, you might think that when you interpret a literary work you don’t necessarily agree or disagree with anything but simply explain the work’s meaning, style, or structure. Many essays about literature and the arts, it might be said, take this form—they interpret a work’s meaning, thus rendering matters of agreeing or disagreeing irrelevant.

We would argue, however, that the most interesting interpretations in fact tend to be those that agree, disagree, or both—that instead of being offered solo, the best interpretations take strong stands relative to other interpretations. In fact, there would be no reason to offer an interpretation of a work of literature or art unless you were responding to the interpretations or possible interpretations of others. Even when you point out features or qualities of an artistic work that others have not noticed, you are implicitly disagreeing with what those interpreters have said by pointing out that they missed or overlooked something that, in your view, is important. In any effective interpretation, then, you need not only to state what you yourself take the work of art to mean but to do so relative to the interpretations of other readers—be they professional scholars, teachers, classmates, or even hypothetical readers (as in, “Although some readers might think that this poem is about __________, it is in fact about __________”).

Homework is Completed By:

Writer Writer Name Amount Client Comments & Rating
Instant Homework Helper

ONLINE

Instant Homework Helper

$36

She helped me in last minute in a very reasonable price. She is a lifesaver, I got A+ grade in my homework, I will surely hire her again for my next assignments, Thumbs Up!

Guarantee Your Academic Success!

Hire Professional Writers And Get Best Homework Writing Services In Any Subject

6 writers have sent their proposals to do this homework:

Financial Hub
Top Academic Tutor
Assignment Hut
Engineering Mentor
Top Academic Guru
Isabella K.
Writer Writer Name Offer Chat
Financial Hub

ONLINE

Financial Hub

Give me a chance, i will do this with my best efforts

$42 Chat With Writer
Top Academic Tutor

ONLINE

Top Academic Tutor

Give me a chance, i will do this with my best efforts

$31 Chat With Writer
Assignment Hut

ONLINE

Assignment Hut

You can award me any time as I am ready to start your project curiously. Waiting for your positive response. Thank you!

$65 Chat With Writer
Engineering Mentor

ONLINE

Engineering Mentor

I am known as Unrivaled Quality, Written to Standard, providing Plagiarism-free woork, and Always on Time

$35 Chat With Writer
Top Academic Guru

ONLINE

Top Academic Guru

Give me a chance, i will do this with my best efforts

$31 Chat With Writer
Isabella K.

ONLINE

Isabella K.

I have read your project details. I can do this within your deadline.

$25 Chat With Writer

Let our expert academic writers to help you in achieving a+ grades in your homework, assignment, quiz or exam.

Similar Homework Questions

Custer and the great controversy robert m utley - Peter walsh doona cover - 139 viewgrand drive berwick - Comptia security+ 501 objectives - NEED 3+ PAGES WITH 4 Peer Reviewed REFERENCES CITED IN APA FORMAT - Help - Mythological Life in the Time of Covid - Principles of computer security 4th edition mcgraw hill - Discussion: Searching Databases - Separation of the components of a mixture lab report answers - Institute of fire engineers exams - How to maybe measure laser beam quality - A7 size in cm - According to one of dr. sarbaum's videos, when did other (non-tariff) protectionism become popular? - Is bri polar covalent - Assignment - To the wedding john berger summary - Positive risk examples in software project - Pepsi refresh project case study - Abs data integration project principles - CRIMINAL LAW ESSAY - Infotech Import and strat Planning - Smoke signals pontiac magazine - Right triangle trig activity - Christchurch to poole bus - Assignment on marketing plan for a new product ppt - Planet fitness swot analysis - Disaster management - Company sales invoices census data and trade association statistics - Why is helium used in scuba diving - Thin documentary youtube - Starbucks blue ocean strategy - Major personality attributes influencing ob - Do you think that technology is helping over society more or harming it more? In what ways? - Gandom in english - 6 methods of separating mixtures - Consultant's analysis report on enterprise systems - 28000 pounds in euros - Techniques in king lear - Aps talent management guide - Sodium phosphate monobasic and dibasic buffer - Woolworths car insurance drive less pay less - Diary of anne frank play character descriptions - Dr tony hammond glen huntly - Profile leveling lab report - Finance - Whs action plan sample - Leadership Development Plan - Pros and cons of lifelong learning - BCG (Boston Consulting Group) Matrix - What does jiggle a mesa cara mean - Capstone - Introducing new coke case study - Metal that burns green - Needing Assignment for Nursing Class - Mid Term Assessment - Health asessment - How does elizabeth affect victor and henry - CCM-2 - Abc the song by jackson 5 - Cs lewis reflections on the psalms pdf - How can creative expression impact issues we deal with today - Bus 377 discussion question - Power Point Presentation On The Below Topic - Discovering antarctica wilderness challenge - Find the exact value of tan 2pi 3 - Lanley homes great eccleston - The nazis were furious when italy surrendered and they ______ - Who ate the cheese answers - Bca floor waste requirements - Rl circuit lab report conclusion - Consultation skills for pharmacy practice - Soc 808 sociology of food and eating test bank - What is minimum attractive rate of return - Project report on supply chain management of amul - Tendency to pry crossword clue - Fedex locations west chester pa - 7 exercises 250 words each Need first one by Saturday EOD Oct 31 EST No Plagiarism - Gordon roddick net worth - Middle passage robert hayden analysis - Experimental design worksheet iv dv controls and control groups - Time is of the essence construction contract - What the heck is eos sparknotes - United states v microsoft antitrust case summary - History - Key performance indicators list for receptionist - PowerPoint Presentation - A dream deferred poem - Why do you want to work at trader joe's answer - Module 2 - Discussion Question - Renaissance multiple choice questions - Newton international school d ring - Apa style essentials vanguard university - Carta continuous adaptive risk and trust - St george bank term deposits - The penelopiad and photograph 51 - Similation of Telemedicine - ECON Questions - Why are information systems typically used at the operational level - The 50 states that rhyme lyrics