- 1 -
SCRIBNER
A Division of Simon & Schuster, Inc.
1230 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10020
www.SimonandSchuster.com
Copyright © 2010 by Jonathan Watts
Maps © András Bereznay
First published in Great Britain in 2010 by Faber and Faber Limited
All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this book or portions thereof in
any form whatsoever. For information address Scribner Subsidiary Rights Department,
1230 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020.
First Scribner trade paperback edition October 2010
SCRIBNER and design are registered trademarks of The Gale Group, Inc., used under
license by Simon & Schuster, Inc., the publisher of this work.
For information about special discounts for bulk purchases, please contact Simon &
Schuster Special Sales at 1-866-506-1949 or business@simonandschuster.com.
The Simon & Schuster Speakers Bureau can bring authors to your live event. For more
information or to book an event contact the Simon & Schuster Speakers Bureau at
1-866-248-3049 or visit our website at www.simonspeakers.com.
Designed by Carla Jayne Jones
Manufactured in the United States of America
1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2
Library of Congress Control Number: 2010029901
ISBN 978-1-4165-8076-8
ISBN 978-1-4391-4193-9 (ebook)
To Aimee, Emma, and Murray
http://www.simonandschuster.com/
http://www.simonspeakers.com/
- 2 -
Contents
Southwest Nature .................................................................. 8
1 Useless Trees ............................................................... 9
2 Foolish Old Men ............................................................ 21
3 Still Waters, Moving Earth .................................................... 32
4 Fishing with Explosives ...................................................... 43
Southeast Man ................................................................... 54
5 Made in China? ............................................................. 55
6 Gross Domestic Pollution ..................................................... 64
7 From Horizontal Green to Vertical Gray ......................................... 75
8 Shop Till You Drop ......................................................... 82
Northwest Imbalance .............................................................. 94
9 Why Do So Many People Hate Henan? .......................................... 95
10 The Carbon Trap .......................................................... 106
11 Attack the Clouds! Retreat from the Sands! ..................................... 116
12 Flaming Mountain, Melting Heaven .......................................... 126
Northeast Alternatives ............................................................ 136
13 Science versus Math ....................................................... 137
14 Fertility Treatment ........................................................ 151
15 An Odd Sort of Dictatorship ................................................. 163
16 Grass Roots .............................................................. 177
Afterword Peaking Man .......................................................... 191
Acknowledgments ................................................................... 196
Notes ............................................................................. 198
Introduction: Beijing ......................................................... 198
1. Useless Trees: Shangri-La ................................................... 199
2. Foolish Old Men: The Tibetan Plateau ......................................... 202
3. Still Waters, Moving Earth: Sichuan ........................................... 204
4. Fishing with Explosives: Hubei and Guangxi .................................... 208
5. Made in China? Guangdong ................................................. 211
6. Gross Domestic Pollution: Jiangsu and Zhejiang ................................. 214
7. From Horizontal Green to Vertical Gray: Chongqing .............................. 217
8. Shop Till You Drop: Shanghai ............................................... 219
9. Why Do So Many People Hate Henan? Henan ................................... 221
10. The Carbon Trap: Shanxi and Shaanxi ........................................ 225
11. Attack the Clouds! Retreat from the Sands! Gansu and Ningxia .................... 227
12. Flaming Mountain, Melting Heaven: Xinjiang .................................. 228
13. Science versus Math: Tianjin, Hebei, and Liaoning .............................. 232
14. Fertility Treatment: Shandong ............................................... 235
15. An Odd Sort of Dictatorship: Heilongjiang ..................................... 239
16 Grass Roots: Xanadu ...................................................... 247
Afterword: Peaking Man ...................................................... 250
Bibliography ....................................................................... 251
Books ..................................................................... 251
Reports, presentations, and academic papers ...................................... 256
- 3 -
Index ............................................................................. 260
- 4 -
Praise for When a Billion Chinese Jump
“This is the book on China and climate change that the West has been waiting for. Watts uses his long
experience of China to track the country’s environmental calamity up close, uncovering its causes, its
contradictions and its shocking human toll. Then he poses perhaps the most seminal question of all—can it
save itself and, by extension, the planet?”
—James Kynge, author of China Shakes the World
“The world’s chance of avoiding catastrophic climate change rests in large part with decisions being made
today in Beijing. If China raises its standard of living to Western standards without controlling the
emissions from industry and power plants, it will wreak havoc with the world’s climate—with
unforeseeable and irreversible consequences. If it takes the road now opening up to a low-carbon economy
and leads the world in developing and deploying clean energy technologies, it can show the way to a
sustainable future for the planet. Jonathan Watts turns a keen eye on China’s choices—previously made
and yet to come—that will affect us all.”
—Timothy E. Wirth, president, United Nations Foundation
and Better World Fund
“Jonathan Watts brings us up to date on China’s economic miracle and the environmental consequences
not only for China but for the entire world. With wonderful travelogue-like writing, Watts takes us on an
incredible journey through today’s China—and our tomorrow.”
—Lester R. Brown, president of Earth Policy Institute and author
of Plan B 4.0: Mobilizing to Save Civilization
“This is the environmental book that I am most looking forward to for 2010. I admire Jonathan Watts for
his rigorous approach to journalism and his devotion to human stories at the grass roots.”
—Ma Jun, founder of the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs and author of China’s Water Crisis
“A fascinating, engaging, and beautifully written book. Jonathan Watts shines a light onto an issue that
affects us all but of which we are woefully ignorant. This book succeeds in both informing and
entertaining us. It is a masterpiece.”
—George Monbiot, author of
Heat: How to Stop the Planet from Burning
“This is a spectacularly important book, superbly researched and engagingly written. Jonathan Watts has
given us a shocking eyewitness account of China’s environmental meltdown. It should be compulsory
reading for all.”
—Rob Gifford, NPR Shanghai correspondent
and author of China Road
“Watts has written a nationwide audit of where China’s environment stands as of the end of the first
decade of the twenty-first century. His eyewitness accounts are the great strength of this important book.”
—Kerry Brown, Times Higher Education (UK)
“An excellent read. A few good gags in it, too, something few writers on China dare ever to try.”
- 5 -
—Paul French, author of Through the Looking Glass:
China’s Foreign Journalists from Opium Wars to Mao
“Meticulously documented, wide-ranging account … this is a revealing and depressing book. There is no
‘middle truth’ in it. During his painstaking investigative journeys, which called on all his powers as a top-
class reporter, Jonathan Watts concluded that ‘China has felt at times like the end of the world.’”
—Jonathan Mirsky, Literary Review (UK)
- 6 -
Introduction
Beijing
As a child, I used to pray for China. It was a profoundly selfish prayer. Lying in bed, fingers clasped
together, I would reel off the same wish list every night: “Dear Father, thank you for all the good things in
my life. Please look after Mum and Dad, Lisa (my sister), Nana, and Papa, Toby (my dog), my friends
(and here I would list whoever I was mates with at the time), and me.” After this roll call, the sign-off was
usually the same. “And please make the world peaceful. Please help all the poor and hungry people, and
please make sure everyone in China doesn’t jump at the same time.”
That last wish was tagged on after I realized the enormousness of the country on the other side of the world.
For a small British boy growing up in a suburb of an island nation in the 1970s, it was not easy to grasp the
scale of China. I was fascinated that the country would soon be home to a billion people. 1 I loved numbers,
especially big ones. But what did a billion mean? An adult explained with a terrifying illustration I have
never forgotten. “If everyone in China jumps at exactly the same time, it will shake the earth off its axis
and kill us all.” 2
I was a born worrier and this made me more anxious than anything I had heard before. For the first time,
my young mind came to grips with the possibility of being killed by people I had never seen, who didn’t
know I existed, and who didn’t even need a gun. I was powerless to do anything about it. This seemed both
unfair and dangerous. It was an accident waiting to happen. Somebody had to do something!
Life suddenly seemed more precarious than I had ever imagined. In variations of my prayer, I asked God
to make sure that if Chinese people had to jump, they only did it alone or in small groups. But in time, my
anxieties faded. With all the extra maturity that comes from turning six years old, I realized it was childish
nonsense.
I did not think about the apocalyptic jump again for almost thirty years. Then, in 2003, I moved to Beijing,
where I discovered it is not only foolish little oiks who fear China leaping and the world shaking. In the
interim, the poverty-stricken nation had transformed into an economic heavyweight and added an extra
400 million citizens. China was undergoing one of the greatest bursts of development in history and I
arrived in the midst of it as Beijing prepared for the 2008 Olympics.
The city’s transformation was vast and fast. Down went old hutong alleyways, courtyard houses, and the
ancient city walls. Up rose futuristic stadiums, TV towers, airport terminals, and other monuments to
modernization. Restaurants and bars one day were piles of rubble the next. Tens of thousands of old walls
were daubed with the Chinese character chai (demolish). The hoardings around a nearby development site
were decorated with giant pictures of the old city and a half-mocking, half-mournful slogan: “Our old town:
Gone with the wind.”
Living amid such a rapidly shifting landscape, it was hard to know whether to celebrate, commiserate, or
simply gaze in awe. The scale and speed of change pushed everything to extremes. On one day, China
looked to be emerging as a new superpower. The next, it appeared to be the blasted center of an
environmental apocalypse. Most of the time, it was simply enshrouded in smog.
Soon after arriving, I walked home before dawn one morning in a haze so thick I felt completely alone in a
city of 17 million people. The milky white air was strangely comforting. Skyscrapers had turned into
thirty-story ghosts. The world seemed to have vanished. Yet it was also being remade. Overhead, cranes
loomed out of the mist like skeletal giants.
- 7 -
Over the following years, the crane and the smog were to become synonymous in my mind with the two
biggest challenges facing humanity: the rise of China and the damage being wrought on the global
environment. The builders were constructing the most spectacular Olympic city in history. The chimney
emissions and car exhausts were destroying the health of millions and helping to warm the planet as never
before.
The year after my arrival, China’s GDP overtook those of France and Italy. Another year of growth took it
past that of Britain—the goal that Mao Zedong had so disastrously set during the Great Leap Forward fifty
years earlier. From 2003 to 2008, China stopped receiving aid from the World Food Programme and
overtook the World Bank as the biggest investor in Africa. Its foreign-exchange reserves surpassed those
of Japan as the largest in the world. The former basket-case nation completed the world’s highest railway,
the most powerful hydroelectric dam, launched a first manned space mission, and sent a probe to the moon.
This was a period in which the population increased at the rate of more than 7 million people per year,
when more than 70 million people moved into cities, when GDP, industrial output, and production of cars
doubled, when energy consumption and coal production jumped 50 percent, water use surged by 500
billion tons, and China became the biggest emitter of carbon in the world. 3
As a parent, I worried for my two daughters’ health when the air became so bad that their school would not
let pupils out at break times. I feared too for my lungs. A regular jogger since my teens, I found myself
wheezing and puffing after even a short run. When the coal fires started burning each winter, I suffered a
dry, rasping cough that sometimes left me doubled up. In Beijing I was to suffer two bouts of pneumonia
and, for the first time in my life, I was prescribed a steroid inhaler. The city was choking and so was I.
To be in early twenty-first-century China was to witness the climax of two hundred years of
industrialization and urbanization, in close-up, playing at fast-forward on a continentwide screen. It soon
became clear to me that China was the focal point of the world’s environmental crisis. The decisions taken
in Beijing, more than anywhere else, would determine whether humanity thrived or perished. After I
arrived in Beijing, I was first horrified at the chaos and then excited. No other country was in such a mess.
None had a greater incentive to change.
The environment had become a national security issue and the government started to respond. The
leadership—the hydroengineer Hu Jintao and the geologist Wen Jiabao, or President Water and Premier
Earth, as I came to think of them—started to shift the communist rhetoric from red to green. They wanted
science to save nature. Instead of untrammeled economic expansion, they pledged sustainability. If their
goals were achieved, China could emerge as the world’s first green superpower. Alternatively, if they
failed and the world’s most populous nation continued to leap recklessly onward, our entire species could
tip over the environmental precipice.
These were the extremes. The truth was probably somewhere in between—but where? That became the
biggest question of my time in China. For the first five years as a news correspondent for the Guardian,
the environment was my primary concern. After that it became such an obsession that I took six months
off for private research trips and then returned to a new post as Asia environment specialist. Traveling
more than 100,000 miles from the mountains of Tibet to the deserts of Inner Mongolia, I witnessed
environmental tragedies, consumer excess, and inspiring dedication. I went to Shangri-La and Xanadu,
along the Silk Road, down coal mines, through dump sites, and into numerous cancer villages. I saw the
richest community, the most polluted city, and the foulest sea. On the way I talked to leading
conservationists, politicians, lawyers, authors, and China’s top experts on energy, glaciers, deserts, oceans,
and the climate. Most compelling were the stories of ordinary people affected in extraordinary ways by a
burst of human development and climate change the like of which the world had never seen before.
This, then, is a travelogue through a land obscured by smog and transformed by cranes; one that examines
how rural environments are being affected by mass urban consumption. What are we losing and how?
- 8 -
Where are the consequences? Can we fix them? It projects mankind’s modern development on a Chinese
screen.
Though the chapters progress through regions and themes, the structure is polemical rather than
geographic. When I had to choose between a strong case study and a line on the map, I opted for the
former even if that occasionally meant leapfrogging provinces, returning to some places twice, and cutting
across boundaries. Lest anyone fear that I am asserting a new territorial claim by Dongbei on Inner
Mongolia, or by the southeast on Chongqing, I should state their place in these pages is determined by the
powerful trends they illustrate. Similarly, my apologies to anyone who feels slighted or frustrated by my
selective approach. Omission of a province is not intended to dismiss its importance any more than
inclusion is meant to indicate a paradigm case.
The choice of location and topics in these pages is determined purely by my own experience. Even over
many years and miles, that is limited. China is simply too vast and changing too fast to capture in its
entirety. Starting from the world’s high, wild places and descending into the crowded polluted plains, the
book tracks mankind’s modern development and my own growing realization: now China has jumped, we
must all rebalance our lives.
Southwest
Nature
- 9 -
1 Useless Trees
Shangri-La
A man with a beard is respected. The same applies to mountains. A person with a beard and hair is like a
mountain covered with forest and grass. In the same vein, a mountain sheltered in forest and grass is like a
person well clothed. A barren mountain is no different from a naked person, exposing its flesh and bone.
An unsheltered mountain with poor soil painfully resembles a penniless and rugged man.
—Inscription on monument found in Yunnan, dated 1714 1
Paradise is no longer lost. According to the Chinese government, Shangri-La can be found at 28° north
latitude, 99° east longitude, and an elevation of 3,300 meters at the foot of the Himalayas in northwest
Yunnan Province. I started my journey at this self-proclaimed mountain idyll with the intention of working
my way down and across China, tracking the progress of development on the way. Shangri-La seemed a
- 10 -
fitting place to begin. Environmentalists considered it pristine, economists thought it backward. I planned
to search here for natural and philosophical ideals, for untouched origins. But I may have arrived too late.
Bumping along a dirt road through the mountains, I spied muddy hovels and forests spoiled by the
blackened aftermath of logging teams. Gray drizzle doused a blaze of purple azaleas and white
rhododendron shrubs. A track cut through a field of flowers to an alpine pool scarred on one side by the
stumps of dozens of felled trees. The landscape, once one of the most stunning in China, had been violated.
For millennia, Bigu Lake in the heart of the region was protected by its remoteness. Although worshipped
by local Tibetan communities, it was not mentioned in the extensive canons of Chinese literature.
Government administrators and poetic wanderers rarely made it this far. It was too poor, too little known,
too difficult to exploit.
All that changed in December 2001, when the Chinese authorities found a new way to sell northwest
Yunnan’s beauty: they renamed the region Shangri-La. As well as being a brilliant piece of marketing, the
appropriation of a fictional Utopia dreamed up seventy years earlier on the other side of the world was a
remarkable act of chutzpah for a government that was, in theory at least, communist, atheist, and
scientifically oriented.
The tourist trickle quickly became a flood. Road builders, dam makers, and hotel operators added to the
height of the swell. Beauty was marketed as fantasy, often with disastrous consequences. When the Oscar-
nominated filmmaker Chen Kaige wanted a spectacular location for a new kung fu blockbuster, The
Promise, he came to Bigu Lake and completely reconfigured the idyllic landscape. With the enthusiastic
support of the local government, the director’s team built a road through the field of azaleas, drove 100
piles into the lake for a bridge, and erected a five-story “Flower House” for the love scenes. Nobody took
responsibility for the consequences. 2 After he ended shooting, the concrete-and-timber house was left
dilapidated; the ground was strewn with plastic bags, polystyrene lunch boxes, and wine bottles. The lake