Jen values her time at $60 an hour

5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 1 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

CHAPTER

7 Consumers, Producers, and the

Efficiency of Markets

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 2 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

W

hen consumers go to grocery stores to buy their turkeys for Thanksgiving dinner, they may be disappointed that the price of turkey is as high as it is. At the same time, when farmers bring to

market the turkeys they have raised, they probably wish the price of turkey were even higher. These views are not surprising: Buyers always want to pay less, and sellers always want to be paid more. But is there a “right price” for turkey from the standpoint of society as a whole?

In previous chapters, we saw how, in market economies, the forces of supply and demand determine the prices of goods and services and the quantities sold. So far, however, we have described the way markets allocate scarce resources without directly addressing the question of whether these market allocations are desirable. In other words, our analysis has been positive (what is) rather than normative

5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 3 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

(what should be). We know that the price of turkey adjusts to ensure that the quantity of turkey supplied equals the

quantity of turkey demanded. But at this equilibrium, is the quantity of turkey produced and consumed too small, too large, or just right?

In this chapter, we take up the topic of welfare economics, the study of how the allocation of resources affects economic well-being. We begin by examining the benefits that buyers and sellers receive from engaging in market transactions. We then examine how society can make these benefits as large as possible. This analysis leads to a profound conclusion: In any market, the equilibrium of supply and demand maximizes the total benefits received by all buyers and sellers combined.

welfare economics the study of how the allocation of resources affects economic well-being

As you may recall from Chapter 1, one of the Ten Principles of Economics is that markets are usually a good way to organize economic activity. The study of welfare economics explains this principle more fully. It also answers our question about the right price of turkey: The price that balances the supply and demand for turkey is, in a particular sense, the best one because it maximizes the total welfare of turkey consumers and turkey producers. No consumer or producer of turkeys aims to achieve this goal, but their joint action directed by market prices moves them toward a welfare- maximizing outcome, as if led by an invisible hand.

7-1 Consumer Surplus We begin our study of welfare economics by looking at the benefits buyers receive from participating in a market.

7-1a Willingness to Pay Imagine that you own a mint-condition recording of Elvis Presley's first album. Because you are not an Elvis Presley fan, you decide to sell it. One way to do so is to hold an auction.

Four Elvis fans show up for your auction: John, Paul, George, and Ringo. Each of them would like to own the album, but there is a limit to the amount that each is willing to pay for it. Table 1 shows the maximum price that each of the four possible buyers would pay. Each buyer's maximum is called his willingness to pay, and it measures how much that buyer values the good. Each buyer would be eager to buy the album at a price less than his willingness to pay, and he would refuse to buy the album at a price greater than his willingness to pay. At a price equal to his willingness to pay, the buyer would be indifferent about buying the good: If the price is exactly the same as the value he places on the album, he would be equally happy buying it or keeping his money.

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/glossary.xhtml#welfareeconomics
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch1.xhtml#ch1
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-1
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-2
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#table7.1
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 4 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

willingness to pay the maximum amount that a buyer will pay for a good

TABLE 1 Four Possible Buyers' Willingness to Pay Buyer Willingness to Pay John $100 Paul 80 George 70 Ringo 50

To sell your album, you begin the bidding at a low price, say, $10. Because all four buyers are willing to pay much more, the price rises quickly. The bidding stops when John bids $80 (or slightly more). At this point, Paul, George, and Ringo have dropped out of the bidding because they are unwilling to bid any more than $80. John pays you $80 and gets the album. Note that the album has gone to the buyer who values it most highly.

What benefit does John receive from buying the Elvis Presley album? In a sense, John has found a real bargain: He is willing to pay $100 for the album but pays only $80 for it. We say that John receives consumer surplus of $20. Consumer surplus is the amount a buyer is willing to pay for a good minus the amount the buyer actually pays for it.

consumer surplus the amount a buyer is willing to pay for a good minus the amount the buyer actually pays for it

Consumer surplus measures the benefit buyers receive from participating in a market. In this example, John receives a $20 benefit from participating in the auction because he pays only $80 for a good he values at $100. Paul, George, and Ringo get no consumer surplus from participating in the auction because they left without the album and without paying anything.

Now consider a somewhat different example. Suppose that you had two identical Elvis Presley albums to sell. Again, you auction them off to the four possible buyers. To keep things simple, we assume that both albums are to be sold for the same price and that no buyer is interested in buying more than one album. Therefore, the price rises until two buyers are left.

In this case, the bidding stops when John and Paul bid $70 (or slightly higher). At this price, John and Paul are each happy to buy an album, and George and Ringo are not willing to bid any higher. John and Paul each receive consumer surplus equal to his willingness to pay minus the price. John's

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/glossary.xhtml#willingnesstopay
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/glossary.xhtml#consumersurplus
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 5 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

consumer surplus is $30, and Paul's is $10. John's consumer surplus is higher now than in the previous example because he gets the same album but pays less for it. The total consumer surplus in the market is $40.

7-1b Using the Demand Curve to Measure Consumer Surplus Consumer surplus is closely related to the demand curve for a product. To see how they are related, let's continue our example and consider the demand curve for this rare Elvis Presley album.

We begin by using the willingness to pay of the four possible buyers to find the market demand schedule for the album. The table in Figure 1 shows the demand schedule that corresponds to Table 1. If the price is above $100, the quantity demanded in the market is 0 because no buyer is willing to pay that much. If the price is between $80 and $100, the quantity demanded is 1 because only John is willing to pay such a high price. If the price is between $70 and $80, the quantity demanded is 2 because both John and Paul are willing to pay the price. We can continue this analysis for other prices as well. In this way, the demand schedule is derived from the willingness to pay of the four possible buyers.

The graph in Figure 1 shows the demand curve that corresponds to this demand schedule. Note the relationship between the height of the demand curve and the buyers' willingness to pay. At any quantity, the price given by the demand curve shows the willingness to pay of the marginal buyer, the buyer who would leave the market first if the price were any higher. At a quantity of 4 albums, for instance, the demand curve has a height of $50, the price that Ringo (the marginal buyer) is willing to pay for an album. At a quantity of 3 albums, the demand curve has a height of $70, the price that George (who is now the marginal buyer) is willing to pay.

FIGURE 1 The Demand Schedule and the Demand Curve The table shows the demand schedule for the buyers (listed in Table 1) of the mint-condition copy of Elvis Presley's first album. The graph shows the corresponding demand curve. Note that the height of the demand curve reflects the buyers' willingness to pay.

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-3
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.1
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#table7.1
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.1
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#table7.1
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 6 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

Because the demand curve reflects buyers' willingness to pay, we can also use it to measure consumer surplus. Figure 2 uses the demand curve to compute consumer surplus in our two examples. In panel (a), the price is $80 (or slightly above) and the quantity demanded is 1. Note that the area above the price and below the demand curve equals $20. This amount is exactly the consumer surplus we computed earlier when only 1 album is sold.

Panel (b) of Figure 2 shows consumer surplus when the price is $70 (or slightly above). In this case, the area above the price and below the demand curve equals the total area of the two rectangles: John's consumer surplus at this price is $30 and Paul's is $10. This area equals a total of $40. Once again, this amount is the consumer surplus we computed earlier.

The lesson from this example holds for all demand curves: The area below the demand curve and above the price measures the consumer surplus in a market. This is true because the height of the demand curve measures the value buyers place on the good, as measured by their willingness to pay for it. The difference between this willingness to pay and the market price is each buyer's consumer surplus. Thus, the total area below the demand curve and above the price is the sum of the consumer surplus of all buyers in the market for a good or service.

7-1c How a Lower Price Raises Consumer Surplus Because buyers always want to pay less for the goods they buy, a lower price makes buyers of a good better off. But how much does buyers' well-being rise in response to a lower price? We can use the concept of consumer surplus to answer this question precisely.

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.2
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.2
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-4
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 7 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

FIGURE 2 Measuring Consumer Surplus with the Demand Curve In panel (a), the price of the good is $80 and the consumer surplus is $20. In panel (b), the price of the good is $70 and the consumer surplus is $40.

Figure 3 shows a typical demand curve. You may notice that this curve gradually slopes downward instead of taking discrete steps as in the previous two figures. In a market with many buyers, the resulting steps from each buyer dropping out are so small that they form, in essence, a smooth curve. Although this curve has a different shape, the ideas we have just developed still apply: Consumer surplus is the area above the price and below the demand curve. In panel (a), consumer surplus at a price of P1 is the area of triangle ABC.

Now suppose that the price falls from P1 to P2, as shown in panel (b). The consumer surplus now equals the area ADE The increase in consumer surplus attributable to the lower price is the area BCFD.

This increase in consumer surplus is composed of two parts. First, those buyers who were already buying Q1 of the good at the higher price P1 are better off because they now pay less. The increase in consumer surplus of existing buyers is the reduction in the amount they pay; it equals the area of the rectangle BCED. Second, some new buyers enter the market because they are willing to buy the good at the lower price. As a result, the quantity demanded in the market increases from Q1 to Q2. The consumer surplus these newcomers receive is the area of the triangle CEF.

7-1d What Does Consumer Surplus Measure? Our goal in developing the concept of consumer surplus is to make judgments about the desirability of market outcomes. Now that you have seen what consumer surplus is, let's consider whether it is a good measure of economic well-being.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.3
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-5
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 8 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

FIGURE 3 How Price Affects Consumer Surplus In panel (a), the price is P1, the quantity demanded is Q1, and consumer surplus equals the area of the triangle ABC. When the price falls from P1 to P2, as in panel (b), the quantity demanded rises from Q1 to Q2 and the consumer surplus rises to the area of the triangle ADF. The increase in consumer surplus (area BCFD) occurs in part because existing consumers now pay less (area BCED) and in part because new consumers enter the market at the lower price (area CEF).

Imagine that you are a policymaker trying to design a good economic system. Would you care about the amount of consumer surplus? Consumer surplus, the amount that buyers are willing to pay for a good minus the amount they actually pay for it, measures the benefit that buyers receive from a good as the buyers themselves perceive it. Thus, consumer surplus is a good measure of economic well- being if policymakers want to respect the preferences of buyers.

In some circumstances, policymakers might choose to disregard consumer surplus because they do not respect the preferences that drive buyer behavior. For example, drug addicts are willing to pay a high price for heroin. Yet we would not say that addicts get a large benefit from being able to buy heroin at a low price (even though addicts might say they do). From the standpoint of society, willingness to pay in this instance is not a good measure of the buyers' benefit, and consumer surplus is not a good measure of economic well-being, because addicts are not looking after their own best interests.

In most markets, however, consumer surplus does reflect economic well-being. Economists normally assume that buyers are rational when they make decisions. Rational people do the best they

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 9 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

can to achieve their objectives, given their opportunities. Economists also normally assume that people's preferences should be respected. In this case, consumers are the best judges of how much benefit they receive from the goods they buy.

Quick Quiz Draw a demand curve for turkey. In your diagram, show a price of turkey and the consumer surplus at that price. Explain in words what this consumer surplus measures.

7-2 Producer Surplus We now turn to the other side of the market and consider the benefits sellers receive from participating in a market. As you will see, our analysis of sellers' welfare is similar to our analysis of buyers' welfare.

7-2a Cost and the Willingness to Sell Imagine now that you are a homeowner and you want to get your house painted. You turn to four sellers of painting services: Mary, Frida, Georgia, and Grandma. Each painter is willing to do the work for you if the price is right. You decide to take bids from the four painters and auction off the job to the painter who will do the work for the lowest price.

Each painter is willing to take the job if the price she would receive exceeds her cost of doing the work. Here the term cost should be interpreted as the painters' opportunity cost: It includes the painters' out-of-pocket expenses (for paint, brushes, and so on) as well as the value that the painters place on their own time. Table 2 shows each painter's cost. Because a painter's cost is the lowest price she would accept for her work, cost is a measure of her willingness to sell her services. Each painter would be eager to sell her services at a price greater than her cost and would refuse to sell her services at a price less than her cost. At a price exactly equal to her cost, she would be indifferent about selling her services: She would be equally happy getting the job or using her time and energy for another purpose.

cost the value of everything a seller must give up to produce a good

When you take bids from the painters, the price might start high, but it quickly falls as the painters compete for the job. Once Grandma has bid $600 (or slightly less), she is the sole remaining bidder. Grandma is happy to do the job for this price because her cost is only $500. Mary, Frida, and Georgia are unwilling to do the job for less than $600. Note that the job goes to the painter who can do the work at the lowest cost.

What benefit does Grandma receive from getting the job? Because she is willing to do the work for $500 but gets $600 for doing it, we say that she receives producer surplus of $100. Producer surplus is the amount a seller is paid minus the cost of production. Producer surplus measures the benefit

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-6
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-7
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#table7.2
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/glossary.xhtml#cost
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 10 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

sellers receive from participating in a market.

producer surplus the amount a seller is paid for a good minus the seller's cost of providing it

Now consider a somewhat different example. Suppose that you have two houses that need painting. Again, you auction off the jobs to the four painters. To keep things simple, let's assume that no painter is able to paint both houses and that you will pay the same amount to paint each house. Therefore, the price falls until two painters are left.

TABLE 2 The Costs of Four Possible Sellers

Seller Cost Mary $900 Frida 800 Georgia 600 Grandma 500

In this case, the bidding stops when Georgia and Grandma each offer to do the job for a price of $800 (or slightly less). Georgia and Grandma are willing to do the work at this price, while Mary and Frida are not willing to bid a lower price. At a price of $800, Grandma receives producer surplus of $300 and Georgia receives producer surplus of $200. The total producer surplus in the market is $500.

7-2b Using the Supply Curve to Measure Producer Surplus Just as consumer surplus is closely related to the demand curve, producer surplus is closely related to the supply curve. To see how, let's continue our example.

We begin by using the costs of the four painters to find the supply schedule for painting services. The table in Figure 4 shows the supply schedule that corresponds to the costs in Table 2. If the price is below $500, none of the four painters is willing to do the job, so the quantity supplied is zero. If the price is between $500 and $600, only Grandma is willing to do the job, so the quantity supplied is 1. If the price is between $600 and $800, Grandma and Georgia are willing to do the job, so the quantity supplied is 2, and so on. Thus, the supply schedule is derived from the costs of the four painters.

The graph in Figure 4 shows the supply curve that corresponds to this supply schedule. Note that the height of the supply curve is related to the sellers' costs. At any quantity, the price given by the supply curve shows the cost of the marginal seller, the seller who would leave the market first if the price

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/glossary.xhtml#producersurplus
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-8
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.4
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#table7.2
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.4
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 11 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

were any lower. At a quantity of 4 houses, for instance, the supply curve has a height of $900, the cost that Mary (the marginal seller) incurs to provide her painting services. At a quantity of 3 houses, the supply curve has a height of $800, the cost that Frida (who is now the marginal seller) incurs.

FIGURE 4 The Supply Schedule and the Supply Curve The table shows the supply schedule for the sellers (listed in Table 2) of painting services. the graph shows the corresponding supply curve. Note that the height of the supply curve reflects the sellers' costs.

Because the supply curve reflects sellers' costs, we can use it to measure producer surplus. Figure 5 uses the supply curve to compute producer surplus in our two examples. In panel (a), we assume that the price is $600 (or slightly less). In this case, the quantity supplied is 1. Note that the area below the price and above the supply curve equals $100. This amount is exactly the producer surplus we computed earlier for Grandma.

Panel (b) of Figure 5 shows producer surplus at a price of $800 (or slightly less). In this case, the area below the price and above the supply curve equals the total area of the two rectangles. This area equals $500, the producer surplus we computed earlier for Georgia and Grandma when two houses needed painting.

The lesson from this example applies to all supply curves: The area below the price and above the supply curve measures the producer surplus in a market. The logic is straightforward: The height of the supply curve measures sellers' costs, and the difference between the price and the cost of

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#table7.2
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.5
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.5
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 12 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

production is each seller's producer surplus. Thus, the total area is the sum of the producer surplus of all sellers.

7-2c How a Higher Price Raises Producer Surplus You will not be surprised to hear that sellers always want to receive a higher price for the goods they sell. But how much does sellers' well-being rise in response to a higher price? The concept of producer surplus offers a precise answer to this question.

Figure 6 shows a typical upward-sloping supply curve that would arise in a market with many sellers. Although this supply curve differs in shape from the previous figure, we measure producer surplus in the same way: Producer surplus is the area below the price and above the supply curve. In panel (a), the price is P1 and producer surplus is the area of triangle ABC.

FIGURE 5 Measuring Producer Surplus with the Supply Curve In panel (a), the price of the good is $600 and the producer surplus is $100. In panel (b), the price of the good is $800 and the producer surplus is $500.

PRINTED BY: apcampbell@email.phoenix.edu. Printing is for personal, private use only. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted without publisher's prior permission. Violators will be prosecuted.

https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/contents.xhtml#toc-ch7-9
https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/books/9781305892811/epub/OEBPS/ch7.xhtml#figure7.6
5/11/17, 9(24 AM

Page 13 of 28https://jigsaw.vitalsource.com/api/v0/books/9781305892811/print?from=135&to=153

FIGURE 6 How Price Affects Producer Surplus In panel (a), the price is P1, the quantity demanded is Q1, and producer surplus equals the area of the triangle ABC. When the price rises from P1 to P2, as in panel (b), the quantity supplied rises from Q1 to Q2 and the producer surplus rises to the area of the triangle ADF. The increase in producer surplus (area BCFD) occurs in part because existing producers now receive more (area BCED) and in part because new producers enter the market at the higher price (area CEF).